Players who should go , who should stay ? - Page 3

Revived Red · 29-04-2008, 21:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by shakermaker

Sorry RR, was way off! Long day

Well instead of just "experienced league manager", I'll add "with a good record", that do?

Yep, that's fine! Enjoyed the exchange of views. Pity that some didn't really follow it but not to worry. I'll be there on Saturday, shouting for the Stanley boys - and for JC.

cashman · 30-04-2008, 13:09

sorry to be a killjoy, but for the club to move forward, the only person who should go is Eric Whalley, he needs to sell out to somebody with a bob or two, don't think fer a minute he will, but fer me its the only way forward.

dabeast · 03-05-2008, 23:38

Keep:

Kenny, Fearon (back up keeper)

Phil, Leam, Cav,

Mannix, Craney (as a midfielder), Grant,

Mullers, Whalley (as an out-and-out striker), Evil (top striker if we get the best out of him)

Everyone else can go. Toddy sadly isn't the same player, Jay and Proc have occasional great games but they are both playing for one place in the side and i beleive mannix can do a better job than either. Perhaps keep one as back up.

So that leaves room for about 3 defenders (of which Kempson should be one if we can get him). We also need two good quality wingers and another pacey striker

Perhaps a couple of the youth/reserve squad to fill in any gaps / provide cover

We also must develop a side capable of playing without Mullin - good as he is he is not getting any younger, but more importantly we are a very predictable side and need to mix up the attack a bit.

MCR ADIM · 03-05-2008, 23:45

we should keep jay harris he always puts top effort in hes a good player! i think we should keep rocky becuase he is a good defender he has put in some good games this season and next season when he comes back he will be in good form we should also play McGivien more often to take over mullins role as he is more than capable of doing. i hope mannix stays but think he can play at alot higher leave and king can aslo

smudgie · 04-05-2008, 09:42

Arthur- Looked abit dodgy again, but surely hes our number 1? STAY
Dunbavin- No problem with shot stopping ability but has the moment of madness, a number 2 tho. MAYBE
Fearon- Good prospect, hopefully will get a chance next season. STAY

Cav- Mr Dependable, hopefully no injuries next season. STAY
Edwards- Looks a much better player at center back. STAY
Richardson- Solid. Must play Left back in my opinion. STAY
Williams. Shocking season. GO
Roberts. Very Dissappointing. GO
Webb. Solid but no Pace at all. GO
King. Looks the best left back in the league but doesnt get a chance and plays toddy at left back. GIVE HIM A CHANCE! STAY
Murphy. Looks a great prospect at center back. Surely cant be relied on 2 start next season tho at 18? STAY
Bell- Looks a decent back up, again i emphaise BACKUP! STAY

Proctor. Needs to up his game again next season, tho he has scored more goals than ever. STAY
Whalley- Great Prospect, hopefully more consistent next year. STAY
Harris- Yes he gets stuck in, thats not enough im afraid. GO
Miles- Most disappointing signing for me. GO
Carden. Who? GO
Branch. still got the brain, just no legs. GO
Brown. Steady but thats not enough. GO
Craney. Needs to improve but big signing wont leave. STAY
Mannix. Injury prone?? Or another failed signing?? MAYBE?
Todd. Does not look the same player as last year. MAYBE?
Grant. Another promising youngster. STAY

Mcgivern. Not given a big chance looks decent still tho. MAYBE?
Mcevilly. Seems to score everywhere else but here? MAYBE?
Mullin. Mr Reliable. Hes not a big goalscorer anymore, needs to be looked at as a League 2 version of Kevin Davies. Still Important tho. STAY

My Opinion what we need.

1 Keeper.

2 center backs. Kempson would do nicely alongside edwards.

1 right back. Will cav stay fit?

2 wingers. Toddy doesnt look the same player. Whalley inconsistent still.

2 strikers. including a GOALSCORER. ROSCOE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

we shall see what Coleman can magic up

smudgie · 04-05-2008, 09:48

sorry didnt see this thread, ive posted my opinion in a new 1

ZOMBIE · 04-05-2008, 10:00

Merging.

maccawozzagod · 05-05-2008, 14:25

todays Telegraph says that the players are due in on tuesday (tomorrow). They have some fitness letters to give out to those that are staying and only thanks to give out to those that are going. Anybody fancy parking on the car park and doing commentary on who comes out with letters

grinch · 05-05-2008, 18:17

and of the players that do leave how many will make the trip over to sligo do you reckon? also can anyone help me out on carden's contact length, im sure he's still tied down after this year i maybe wrong though

depechemode · 05-05-2008, 18:20

think kenny A should go , dodgy keeper

Wynonie Harris · 05-05-2008, 18:30

Me, too. Bring back Bossu!

slerpy · 05-05-2008, 19:02

Coleman is a god. He will remain and we will prosper.

Pendle Red · 05-05-2008, 19:30

All I want is whoever stays or comes in is to have pride and know what it means to wear the colours of Accrington Stanley

steve chippendale · 05-05-2008, 21:05

After witnessing the performance on sat against bury i think the whole squad apart from mullin + proctor should go we desperatly need some new players

Tin Monkey · 05-05-2008, 21:07

Quote:

Originally Posted by steve chippendale

After witnessing the performance on sat against bury i think the whole squad apart from mullin + proctor should go we desperatly need some new players

We also need £1million for a new stand, or we'll be leaving the League anyway.