Accrington Web

Accrington Web (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/index.php)
-   General Chat (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/f69/)
-   -   Gingerism (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/f69/gingerism-31155.html)

maxwell silver 02-06-2007 07:11

Gingerism
 
Seems gingerism is becoming the new form of racism.On the front page of todays Mirror is the story of a family from Newcastle who have been hounded out of thier homes three times due to haressment,abuse & bullying all because they all have ginger hair.One of the four children has already attempted suicide because of it.The father has contemplated dying the families hair in the hope of stopping it,but quite rightly deciding against altering their appearance.It would be like a coloured man bleaching his skin.We all know gingers get a bit of a raw deal,being the brunt of many a joke & having to keep covered up in the sun etc,but this is no joke;though i would believe the morons responsible for this abuse would find it so.My best mates a ginger & if you gave him any hassle about his appearance he'd wipe the floor with the face of the person responsible.

MargaretR 02-06-2007 09:43

Re: Gingerism
 
I was often called 'Ginger' in my early teens, but it was never said in an unkindly way. I think that ginger boys do get teased about it. Like any teasing - if you show that it hurts, the bully thrives on it and does it more.
My son has fair hair but not ginger, and none of my grandchildren are ginger, but I do have a nephew who is truly a 'carrot head'. I dont know whether he was bullied because of it in his youth.
I suspect that there is more to this story than the family just being ginger

Ianto.W. 02-06-2007 09:51

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Margaret@Rothwell5f, I suspect that there is more to this story than the family just being ginger
I suspect you are right Margaret, it does not add up a little more info would be a great help.

ploppysirploppy 02-06-2007 10:06

Re: Gingerism
 
When I was younger my best friend was ginger, my neighbour was ginger, my best friend now is ginger, I have a two other friends at college who are ginger.... I have made jokes about it for years that they're ginger.... it's not offensive.... depends how you take it.... luckily.... all my friends have a laugh about it too.... people just don't seem to have a giggle at themselves.
About that harrassment.... well I agree that there has to be more to the story than just because they're ginger.....
Lea
x

garinda 02-06-2007 11:07

Re: Gingerism
 
Bullying of any kind is wrong, but this story did make me thine of the Catherine Tate scetch, which you can watch on this link.:D


Ginger Ail: Redhead Chapmans Forced To Leave Home » Big Brother Celebrity News & Gossip : Anorak

spinner 02-06-2007 11:11

Re: Gingerism
 
kids will target anyone who is 'bullyible'. i dont tink its just the red hair

cashman 02-06-2007 11:56

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by spinner (Post 431468)
kids will target anyone who is 'bullyible'. i dont tink its just the red hair

got it in one. theres more to this than meets the eye,i think.

WillowTheWhisp 02-06-2007 11:56

Re: Gingerism
 
What a sad story. The parents should have brought their children up to be proud of their looks. I have a friend whose youngest daughter has the most beautiful deep rich titian hair and it's gorgeous. Her mousy friends envy her beautiful locks.

Tin Monkey 02-06-2007 13:58

Re: Gingerism
 
Perhaps it's also the very pale, freckly skin? Combine that with the ginger and you have just cause.
















;) :D

grego 02-06-2007 14:04

Re: Gingerism
 
I think its very sad, but I'm sure it cant just be that, children are very cruel and will always find the obvious reason to pick on others whethers it be big ears, specky, spotty etc.

West Ender 02-06-2007 15:03

Re: Gingerism
 
No, I don't believe it's just because of red hair, either. One of my best friends had really red hair - it was beautiful. My daughter's friend is "strawberry blonde" - it's beautiful. Another of her friends has a daughter with deep auburn hair - it's unusual and beautiful. If people are worth bullying their tormentors will pick up on some characteristic to target.

mallard 02-06-2007 15:16

Re: Gingerism
 
Ithink its so silly kids are any one with red hair should not be picked on they are just the same as any other one

WillowTheWhisp 02-06-2007 15:25

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tin Monkey (Post 431526)
Perhaps it's also the very pale, freckly skin? Combine that with the ginger and you have just cause.

;) :D

So if all the members of one family wear glasses does that mean people should bully them too?

Tin Monkey 02-06-2007 16:10

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 431535)
So if all the members of one family wear glasses does that mean people should bully them too?

http://img127.imageshack.us/img127/3428/whooshqg8.gif

WillowTheWhisp 02-06-2007 16:31

Re: Gingerism
 
Do I have to explain?

THERE IS NEVER A JUST CAUSE FOR BULLYING.

Tin Monkey 02-06-2007 16:40

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 431551)
Do I have to explain?

THERE IS NEVER A JUST CAUSE FOR BULLYING.

Or for satirical humour, by the looks of it and that's a shame. Perhaps it's an internet thing? :rolleyes:

ploppysirploppy 02-06-2007 18:21

Re: Gingerism
 
When Catherine Tate does the ginger sketches...why isn't that considered bullying in some way? And this will obviously influence people (mostly kids) to actually insult ginger people. Also...she's carrying a trend on... in twenty years time that'll probably still be on telly... influencing the next generation on scum bags.....oh well....
Lea
xXx
PS. Catherine Tate is the most unfunniest female in existance... sorry I had to say it...

grego 02-06-2007 18:47

Re: Gingerism
 
Have to disagree with you I think Catherine Tate is hilarious, dont think her sketch re the gingers would influence bullies either.

garinda 02-06-2007 18:49

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ploppysirploppy (Post 431578)
When Catherine Tate does the ginger sketches...why isn't that considered bullying in some way? And this will obviously influence people (mostly kids) to actually insult ginger people. Also...she's carrying a trend on... in twenty years time that'll probably still be on telly... influencing the next generation on scum bags.....oh well....
Lea
xXx
PS. Catherine Tate is the most unfunniest female in existance... sorry I had to say it...

She's not making fun of red haired people, she's naturally red haired herself, she's using satire for comedic affect.

Would you say the Royle Family encourages southerners to bully us northerners, or female vicars face ridicule and bullying, because of the Vicar of Dibley?

katex 02-06-2007 18:56

Re: Gingerism
 
I love the red-hair sketches of Catherine Tate, make me laugh even though a red head myself.

Ok .. now have to liven it up now with Schwarzkopf's Red Violet (whoops don't believe I said that). Want to keep the Auburn hair, as always felt a little different from the mousy and now bleached blonde clones there is about.

Never had nothing but compliments when I was young, love my pale skin and don't mind the freckles .. try to stay out of the sun anyway.

Only one thing I read in a Newspaper article that slightly affected me, is that we 'smell' different ... :confused:

garinda 02-06-2007 19:01

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ploppysirploppy (Post 431578)
Also...she's carrying a trend on... in twenty years time that'll probably still be on telly... influencing the next generation on scum bags

People have been bullied for hundreds of stupid reasons, long before Ms. Tate came along.

WillowTheWhisp 02-06-2007 19:02

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tin Monkey (Post 431554)
Or for satirical humour, by the looks of it and that's a shame. Perhaps it's an internet thing? :rolleyes:

OK, I'll try again - words on a page with accompanying smilies do not indicate to everyone the exact nuances you feel you indicated when you were writing it. I.E. this could be interpreted that pale skinned people with freckles deserve ridicule more than ginger haired people and that you are laughing at pale skinned people with freckles OR it could mean that you are laughing at the idea of people laughing at pale skinned people with freckles.

People regard the humour of TV shows such as "Love Thy Neighbour" as racist now whereas they were poking fun at the bigotted hypocrisy of the Jack Smethurst character not poking fun at the racial or ethnic origin of his neighbours. If it is so difficult for people to understand that when they6 have all the additional assistance of facial expressions and tone of voice how much more difficult must it be to interpret the written word on a message board.

Beautifully illustrated by your response to my post. :D

Tin Monkey 02-06-2007 19:32

Re: Gingerism
 
Whether in type form or in pictorial form, the message was obvious. I find it very difficult to believe that anyone would think that I was being serious in saying that being ginger wasn't enough to attract derision, but adding pale skin and freckles would make that derision justified. It is ridiculous beyond belief!

I also take issue with your comparison to Love Thy Neighbour. The issue isn't that the sitcom promoted racist attitudes in audiences, but that it reinforced existing stereotypes. I think you do audiences an injustice by assuming that they are too stupid to realise that Eddie Booth was the butt of the humour and if you were to watch it again now, you would realise that the majority of the jokes were at Eddie's bigotted expense. Audiences got that, mainly because it was made obvious.
The issue today with Love Thy Neighbour lies more in the negative stereotypes it reinforced. For example, Bill Reynolds is better than white people at limbo dancing in one episode, which in turn reinforces the stereotype that black people are better at physical 'past-times' than 'academic' ones (the primitive man vs the sophisticated being).
The language used in the sitcom is also not acceptable in 21st Century Britain, which is another reason for it not being repeated on TV today.

Using stereotypes in humour is nothing new and I would think that they form the basis of 99.9% of comedy produced today. Just look at Little Britain, a programme based on nothing but stereotypes. On another thread a number of people expressed their support for Basil Fawlty and his encounter wth the Germans, as the most memorable thing on British TV. What's that about?

We are bombarded with stereotypes on a daily basis and I find it very difficult to believe that you, Willow, could not detect the satire in my original post. Perhaps we now live in an age where hyper-sensitivity has undermined the basis of satire and replaced it with a sanitised simulacrum where people are afraid to laugh, for fear of how they will perceived by others?
As I said before, it's a shame.

maxwell silver 02-06-2007 19:39

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tin Monkey (Post 431596)
Whether in type form or in pictorial form, the message was obvious. I find it very difficult to believe that anyone would think that I was being serious in saying that being ginger wasn't enough to attract derision, but adding pale skin and freckles would make that derision justified. It is ridiculous beyond belief!

I also take issue with your comparison to Love Thy Neighbour. The issue isn't that the sitcom promoted racist attitudes in audiences, but that it reinforced existing stereotypes. I think you do audiences an injustice by assuming that they are too stupid to realise that Eddie Booth was the butt of the humour and if you were to watch it again now, you would realise that the majority of the jokes were at Eddie's bigotted expense. Audiences got that, mainly because it was made obvious.
The issue today with Love Thy Neighbour lies more in the negative stereotypes it reinforced. For example, Bill Reynolds is better than white people at limbo dancing in one episode, which in turn reinforces the stereotype that black people are better at physical 'past-times' than 'academic' ones (the primitive man vs the sophisticated being).
The language used in the sitcom is also not acceptable in 21st Century Britain, which is another reason for it not being repeated on TV today.

Using stereotypes in humour is nothing new and I would think that they form the basis of 99.9% of comedy produced today. Just look at Little Britain, a programme based on nothing but stereotypes. On another thread a number of people expressed their support for Basil Fawlty and his encounter wth the Germans, as the most memorable thing on British TV. What's that about?

We are bombarded with stereotypes on a daily basis and I find it very difficult to believe that you, Willow, could not detect the satire in my original post. Perhaps we now live in an age where hyper-sensitivity has undermined the basis of satire and replaced it with a sanitised simulacrum where people are afraid to laugh, for fear of how they will perceived by others?
As I said before, it's a shame.

Fair enough,but are any of them ginger:rolleyes:

WillowTheWhisp 02-06-2007 19:42

Re: Gingerism
 
:D You are actually illustrating my point!

You are not reading my words in the same way you would hear them if I was saying them. If you were then you wouldn't have said all of that. Stereotyping of bigots is just as bad as stereotyping races. Like the idea that all Welshmen can sing. It's silly and of course people should know that it's silly. But silly should not automatically be offensive. When people do "Irish" humour I can choose to be offended or I can choose to be amused - the amusement comes on two levels, one at the joke itself and on a deeper level at the idea of the nonsensical stereotyping.

Do you see what I'm saying yet?


OK, I give up.

harwood red 02-06-2007 19:53

Re: Gingerism
 
Note to willow:

We only just get Tin Monkey's humour in stanley forum...that took a while :p

Tin Monkey 02-06-2007 19:57

Re: Gingerism
 
Stereotyping is a natural, human response. We can never hope to know everyone we come across everyday, so by grouping them together it helps us to make sense of the world. The vast majority of people know that stereotypes aren't accurate depictions of whoever, but that doesn't stop them from being useful in many cases.

I actually agree that internet messageboards are prone to misunderstandings, as there is nothing but words on a screen to help us to understand how the message is being transmitted. However, things like 'winky smilies' do give us a clue when something is said in jest and I assumed (wrongly it would seem) that people would understand that.

Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 431601)

OK, I give up.

Let's just agree that I'm right and leave it at that. ;) <--- winky smilie

Tin Monkey 02-06-2007 19:58

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by harwood red (Post 431605)
Note to willow:

We only just get Tin Monkey's humour in stanley forum...that took a while :p

That's why I had to move on here :D ;)

ploppysirploppy 02-06-2007 20:41

Re: Gingerism
 
You make it sound like I'm saying it's ALL of Catherine Tate's fault for the bullies... that's just silly.... I just mentioned it because she got mentioned in a previous post. And she makes fun of herself.... big deal... I do that all the time....
I've only watched a couple of the episodes.... didn't draw me in... maybe I should give it one more go....
Lea
xXx

WillowTheWhisp 02-06-2007 20:47

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tin Monkey (Post 431606)
However, things like 'winky smilies' do give us a clue when something is said in jest and I assumed (wrongly it would seem) that people would understand that.



Let's just agree that I'm right and leave it at that. ;) <--- winky smilie


Aaargh! See I said I had given up and here I am again!

Yes the smiley says it's a joke but what I am trying to say (as with my illustration re "Love Thy Neighbour" which you didn't like for different reasons.) is that the smiley :D denotes that I am laughing but am I laughing at a person insulting someone (ie sharing in the insult) or laughing at a person insulting someone (ie laughing at the person who is doing the unsulting rather than at the insultee)

Now do you understand?

Actually, as regards your point with "Love Thy Neighbour" and the stereotyping isn't that in itself a dig at the people who see others as stereotypes rather than as individuals? Let's consider Alf Garnett as another example. Did people laugh at those Alf Garnett poked fun at or did they laugh at the silly old fool who made himself look stupid by making fun of them?

Tin Monkey 02-06-2007 21:03

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 431618)

Let's consider Alf Garnett as another example. Did people laugh at those Alf Garnett poked fun at or did they laugh at the silly old fool who made himself look stupid by making fun of them?

Ahhhh... now that's a different matter altogether. How audiences decode meaning in texts is a complex debate and much depends on the hegemonic nature of the media itself.
Anyway, I thought we'd agreed that I was right?? :p

Seems our discussion is a little unpopular with some. I've already had a couple of negative karma comments left. :D

Wynonie Harris 02-06-2007 21:16

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tin Monkey (Post 431623)
Seems our discussion is a little unpopular with some.

Not with me, it isn't! Two of the "big beasts" (metaphorically speaking) of Accyweb lock horns...fascinating stuff!

maxwell silver 02-06-2007 21:28

Re: Gingerism
 
Do you know if you get a book of different shades of colours as in a pantone book for mixing paint or inks there is not a pantone ginger.There's every other colour under the sun but no ginger.Is this a form of discrimination.It's not under red or ......it's just not there.

WillowTheWhisp 02-06-2007 22:19

Re: Gingerism
 
Do you realise also that what I see on my screen as 'darkorchid' (ie the colour of my text) may not be the same as the colour you see on your screen which is the techy version of the age-old question as to whether what you see as ginger is the same as what I see as ginger - or indeed any other colour. Our eyes could be as different as the monitor screens we use.

garinda 03-06-2007 00:09

Re: Gingerism
 
I'd stop debating Willow.

Just give the Monkey a good spanking instead.

mani 03-06-2007 04:39

Re: Gingerism
 
why is ginger hair so frowned upon or looked down on?

i mean i can understand if was cuz ginger rhymes with minger... but thats a recent thing - the whole anti-ginger thing is age-old and i cant seem to find out why

ginger girls are hot in bed. the end.

grego 03-06-2007 08:31

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mani (Post 431670)
why is ginger hair so frowned upon or looked down on?

i mean i can understand if was cuz ginger rhymes with minger... but thats a recent thing - the whole anti-ginger thing is age-old and i cant seem to find out why

ginger girls are hot in bed. the end.

Now Mani thats quite offensive are you saying that brunettes and blondes aren't:D

Ianto.W. 03-06-2007 11:33

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Wynonie Harris (Post 431626)
Not with me, it isn't! Two of the "big beasts" (metaphorically speaking) of Accyweb lock horns...fascinating stuff!

You'r right there Wynonie, can't get enough of this great crack.:D;)

katex 03-06-2007 11:38

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by grego (Post 431678)
Now Mani thats quite offensive are you saying that brunettes and blondes aren't:D

And wonder how he came to this conclusion in the first place .. :rolleyes:

grego 03-06-2007 11:52

Re: Gingerism
 
Is there something your not telling us Katex?:D

katex 03-06-2007 11:59

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by grego (Post 431747)
Is there something your not telling us Katex?:D

Eeew hek Grego ! No .. just shows how text can be misinterpreted (proving points above).. :eek:

Just sorta' meant, like, ahem, .. how many had Mani 'trialed' to make such an assumption .. hope that explains it. :o

WillowTheWhisp 03-06-2007 12:00

Re: Gingerism
 
Is it a British thing? Someone I know has a friend in America who told them that everyone she knows thinks ginger hair is adoreable and they love to see it.

SPUGGIE J 03-06-2007 12:10

Re: Gingerism
 
Read heads were around before blondes (who will be extinct in 200 years according to scientists) and dark haired people. Besides red headed blue eyed people are the original inhabitants in the British Isles until the was the start of our imigration problems.

Was red when younger and had red stuble which is now greying faster than GW Bush changes his mind. :(

WillowTheWhisp 03-06-2007 12:12

Re: Gingerism
 
I thought green eyes went naturally with red hair. Supposedly the traditional Irish colouring is red hair and green eyes.

Ianto.W. 03-06-2007 12:14

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mani (Post 431670)
why is ginger hair so frowned upon or looked down on?

i mean i can understand if was cuz ginger rhymes with minger... but thats a recent thing - the whole anti-ginger thing is age-old and i cant seem to find out why

ginger girls are hot in bed. the end.

An explanation would be a great help mani, personally iv'e never noticed with the lights out:D.

SPUGGIE J 03-06-2007 12:44

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 431758)
I thought green eyes went naturally with red hair. Supposedly the traditional Irish colouring is red hair and green eyes.

Its a variation and proberly was in the past in Ireland red hair blue eyes in this neck of the woods. Personally hair colour shouldnt matter its the person themselves that count.

SPUGGIE J 03-06-2007 12:46

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ianto.W. (Post 431760)
An explanation would be a great help mani, personally iv'e never noticed with the lights out:D.

Sure it was the lights out and not you with a blindfold on? :p

SamF 03-06-2007 12:49

Re: Gingerism
 
Haha, moving house because your ginger, that is terrible, so what if some people have a go at ya for it ? I am ginger(though I tan easily and never burn :) ) and heavy sarcasm along with fake gratitude ususually shuts up any comments.

garinda 03-06-2007 12:53

Re: Gingerism
 
The only refuge for this family is to move to Easterhouse, just outside Glasgow.

99.9% of residents there are ginger. There is safety in numbers.:D

SPUGGIE J 03-06-2007 13:05

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 431774)
The only refuge for this family is to move to Easterhouse, just outside Glasgow.

99.9% of residents there are ginger. There is safety in numbers.:D

I wouldnt send any poor soul to Easterhouse just because of hair colour.

Tin Monkey 03-06-2007 14:29

Re: Gingerism
 
GorillaMask.net: South Park: Cartman's 'Ginger Kids' Speech

[Warning - contains some strong language and ginger related humour] ;)

grego 03-06-2007 19:41

Re: Gingerism
 
Brilliant that T M, karma your way.

Tin Monkey 03-06-2007 20:27

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by grego (Post 431892)
Brilliant that T M, karma your way.

Oh good, I could just eat a curry...... oh, hang on...... ;)

LancYorkYankee 03-06-2007 20:58

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 431750)
Is it a British thing? Someone I know has a friend in America who told them that everyone she knows thinks ginger hair is adoreable and they love to see it.

You're quite right Willow. At least in this area of the country many kids and adults are dying their hair red. Plus my wife is a redhead so i tend to like it anyhow.

Brian

WillowTheWhisp 03-06-2007 22:14

Re: Gingerism
 
My daughter has had some red streaks and highlights put in her hair this week.

garinda 03-06-2007 23:14

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 431750)
Is it a British thing?

Golbert Blythe was teasing Anne about the colour of her hair, in that North American classic, Anne of Green Gables, which was written in 1908.

WillowTheWhisp 04-06-2007 06:55

Re: Gingerism
 
I've never read that.

But South Park is American and apparently they are Gingerists too.

garinda 04-06-2007 08:44

Re: Gingerism
 
[quote=garinda;431962]Golbert Blythe/quote]

Gilbert Blythe*

Oh I do wish we had the edit button back.

WillowTheWhisp 04-06-2007 09:15

Re: Gingerism
 
I hadn't even noticed that :D

SamF 04-06-2007 10:33

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 431985)
I've never read that.

But South Park is American and apparently they are Gingerists too.

I always thought South Park was Canadian for some reason :rolleyes:

Ianto.W. 04-06-2007 11:24

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tin Monkey (Post 431816)
GorillaMask.net: South Park: Cartman's 'Ginger Kids' Speech

[Warning - contains some strong language and ginger related humour] ;)

That was hilarious Tin Monkey, the last one in the slide show said it all, the most amusing thing for me was the teachers attitude to the barracker.:D

WillowTheWhisp 04-06-2007 16:38

Re: Gingerism
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SamF (Post 432015)
I always thought South Park was Canadian for some reason :rolleyes:

Not unless they've moved Colorado north. :D

LancYorkYankee 04-06-2007 16:48

Re: Gingerism
 
Brief Thread break

Willow, you've never heard or seen or heard of Anne Of Green Gables? It's been made into a very delightful movie series. My ladies watch it over and over.

Actually, really not a thread break because the Red Hair issue is oft an issue!

Brian

Oh, never saw South Park and rather it wasn't from this country!

WillowTheWhisp 04-06-2007 17:13

Re: Gingerism
 
I've heard of 'Anne of Green Gables'. Just never read it.


All times are GMT. The time now is 09:47.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1
© 2003-2013 AccringtonWeb.com