Accrington Web

Accrington Web (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/index.php)
-   General Chat (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/f69/)
-   -   alternative vote (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/f69/alternative-vote-57385.html)

Barrie Yates 26-04-2011 00:11

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ken Moss (Post 900876)
You're currently at Norden View, Barrie, a highly exclusive area of Rishton and worthy of best bib and tucker. Leaflet on standby.... I have to watch my appearance these days, particularly as one of the Conservative candidate's supporters branded me 'common' for using Facebook to link to my political blog.

What a proud moment that was, I am finally one of the common people too!

Join the club Mate, despite what a lot of people may think, it is pretty exclusive:D

garinda 26-04-2011 06:04

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ken Moss (Post 900876)
You're currently at Norden View, Barrie, a highly exclusive area of Rishton and worthy of best bib and tucker. Leaflet on standby.... I have to watch my appearance these days, particularly as one of the Conservative candidate's supporters branded me 'common' for using Facebook to link to my political blog.

What a proud moment that was, I am finally one of the common people too!

I think a local politician, who uses new technologies to communicate with the people they represent, and is prepared to speak their mind, makes you anything but common.

In Hyndburn that very nearly makes you unique.

jaysay 26-04-2011 08:48

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barrie Yates (Post 901042)
Join the club Mate, despite what a lot of people may think, it is pretty exclusive:D

Na Barrie, I would think your not the only Plastic Manc in Rishton:D

Balbus 26-04-2011 11:34

Re: alternative vote
 
Isn't the point of democracy to give us a government which broadly represents the views of the people? An election isn't a race. It isn't a competition. Very few governments have had an overall majority of votes. Under the present system, if one party gained 626 votes more than the other parties (one vote in each constituency) then it could, theoretically, win all the seats in the Commons. Is that logical or fair? AV would prevent that. Equally, you don't have to express a preference if you do not wish to do so. You can, if you prefer, just vote for one candidate.

cashman 26-04-2011 11:40

Re: alternative vote
 
Whats the point of all this? it aint rocket science as Balbus says yeh can just choose 1 candidate, be honest how many Labour/Tory voters will pick a second choice? not very many i would wager.

jaysay 26-04-2011 17:58

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cashman (Post 901138)
Whats the point of all this? it aint rocket science as Balbus says yeh can just choose 1 candidate, be honest how many Labour/Tory voters will pick a second choice? not very many i would wager.

Totally agree cashy can you actually see me or Mossy picking Labour/Tory as forth fifth sixth or twenty second place on a ballot paper, it just wouldn't happen:rolleyes:

Margaret Pilkington 26-04-2011 20:34

Re: alternative vote
 
Cashy, you are right in one respect, but this will only work if everyone does the same thing and there will be some who will follow the letter of the law.......and something that hasn't actually been made clear...if you do choose only one candidate, would your vote be discarded as a 'spoiled vote'....if that is the case then it casts a whole different complexion on things.

The political parties need to tighten up their acts and attack the apathy that is so prevalent among voters......mainly because of the dishonesty with which politicians of all parties are regarded.
You won't get more people to vote by making the system more complicated, more open to manipulation and back room deals......we already see politicians as Snake oil salesmen.....with their hands firmly dipped into our back pockets.

cashman 26-04-2011 21:42

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Margaret Pilkington (Post 901307)
Cashy, you are right in one respect, but this will only work if everyone does the same thing and there will be some who will follow the letter of the law.......and something that hasn't actually been made clear...if you do choose only one candidate, would your vote be discarded as a 'spoiled vote'....if that is the case then it casts a whole different complexion on things.

The political parties need to tighten up their acts and attack the apathy that is so prevalent among voters......mainly because of the dishonesty with which politicians of all parties are regarded.
You won't get more people to vote by making the system more complicated, more open to manipulation and back room deals......we already see politicians as Snake oil salesmen.....with their hands firmly dipped into our back pockets.

Dont think it would need everyone Margaret,to demonstrate what a farce this A,V. is, hence why i said not many would actually choose another party, cos i credit most folk wi more sense, perhaps i'm wrong? time will tell if it happens.;)

Mancie 26-04-2011 22:09

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Margaret Pilkington (Post 901307)
Cashy, you are right in one respect, but this will only work if everyone does the same thing and there will be some who will follow the letter of the law.......and something that hasn't actually been made clear...if you do choose only one candidate, would your vote be discarded as a 'spoiled vote'....if that is the case then it casts a whole different complexion on things.

The political parties need to tighten up their acts and attack the apathy that is so prevalent among voters......mainly because of the dishonesty with which politicians of all parties are regarded.
You won't get more people to vote by making the system more complicated, more open to manipulation and back room deals......we already see politicians as Snake oil salesmen.....with their hands firmly dipped into our back pockets.

Why do politicians need "to tighten up thier act" ? it's down to the individual wether or not they decide to vote..the dishonesty of politics has been around since cavemen times.. it is the lazy and indifferent attitude of people who live in a relevantly prosperous society who don't vote..making the voting system "more exciting" is rubbish.

Margaret Pilkington 27-04-2011 08:10

Re: alternative vote
 
Why is it down to the individual, and whether or not they choose to vote?(are you alluding to me in this statement? If you are, then say so....I have all my own teeth, you do not need to mince your words...and I have already explained my rationale for not voting..many times, if you care to read it).
You state that dishonesty has been around since caveman times...what evidence have you to support this...were you around then?

What my comment was meant to convey was, that people have lost faith in their ability to affect how the country is run, by exercising their voting privilege.....they vote but their voice is lost in the dishonesty of the politicians action(or in some cases inaction).

The electorate are far more questioning than they were in my fathers day, the media is far more manipulative than it was years ago......politicians act like celebrities instead of what they truly should be....that is, the servant of those who elected them.

If AV is taken as the way forward then it won't make politics more exciting, it will make voting more complicated(and that will turn off even more of the electorate), it will take longer to determine who runs the country, and it may be someone who you wouldn't vote for in a million years who ends up running the country.

It still isn't clear whether if AV is adopted, and you vote for just one candidate, whether it would count as a spoiled vote.
Mancie.....unlike you, I am not shackled to any particular party....I do not follow a dogma......I use my critical thinking skills to choose who will get my vote....and if no-one fits the bill then conscience forbids me from voting for the next best thing, second best is never best.

jaysay 27-04-2011 08:42

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Margaret Pilkington (Post 901397)
Why is it down to the individual, and whether or not they choose to vote?(are you alluding to me in this statement? If you are, then say so....I have all my own teeth, you do not need to mince your words...and I have already explained my rationale for not voting..many times, if you care to read it).
You state that dishonesty has been around since caveman times...what evidence have you to support this...were you around then?

What my comment was meant to convey was, that people have lost faith in their ability to affect how the country is run, by exercising their voting privilege.....they vote but their voice is lost in the dishonesty of the politicians action(or in some cases inaction).

The electorate are far more questioning than they were in my fathers day, the media is far more manipulative than it was years ago......politicians act like celebrities instead of what they truly should be....that is, the servant of those who elected them.

If AV is taken as the way forward then it won't make politics more exciting, it will make voting more complicated(and that will turn off even more of the electorate), it will take longer to determine who runs the country, and it may be someone who you wouldn't vote for in a million years who ends up running the country.

It still isn't clear whether if AV is adopted, and you vote for just one candidate, whether it would count as a spoiled vote.
Mancie.....unlike you, I am not shackled to any particular party....I do not follow a dogma......I use my critical thinking skills to choose who will get my vote....and if no-one fits the bill then conscience forbids me from voting for the next best thing, second best is never best.

It cant be a spoiled vote Margaret, by only voting for one candidate you have made your own personal choice, at the moment we have first past the post, with one person one vote, what AV will do will allow a vote to be counted numerous times, to me that just isn't democracy

Balbus 27-04-2011 08:45

Re: alternative vote
 
Voting for one candidate is permissible in AV - it does not spoil your ballot paper. You only express a preference if you wish to do so. It prevents candidates being elected who have more people against them than for them.

Margaret Pilkington 27-04-2011 10:08

Re: alternative vote
 
thank you for that information John and Balbus.......I still won't be voting for a change to AV......it is a very falwed system.You are right about it not being democracy John...One man(or woman)...One vote.

Personally I struggle to find one politician in which to invest my trust...so I would have a hard time trying to place who I thought was second least dishonest.

jaysay 27-04-2011 10:22

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Margaret Pilkington (Post 901419)
thank you for that information John and Balbus.......I still won't be voting for a change to AV......it is a very falwed system.You are right about it not being democracy John...One man(or woman)...One vote.

Personally I struggle to find one politician in which to invest my trust...so I would have a hard time trying to place who I thought was second least dishonest.

If ya lived in Ossy Margaret you'd always have PB:hidewall::hidewall::hidewall::hidewall: ;):D

Margaret Pilkington 27-04-2011 11:20

Re: alternative vote
 
Trust PB...John...what are you saying?
I would rather gouge out my own eyeballs with a rusty nail.
The thought of that makes me shudder......not the gouging, but the trusting PB.
aaaaaaargh(runs of screaming and frothing at the mouth).

jaysay 27-04-2011 17:54

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Margaret Pilkington (Post 901436)
Trust PB...John...what are you saying?
I would rather gouge out my own eyeballs with a rusty nail.
The thought of that makes me shudder......not the gouging, but the trusting PB.
aaaaaaargh(runs of screaming and frothing at the mouth).

In the words of David Cameron, calm down, calm down,:D:D

Margaret Pilkington 27-04-2011 18:03

Re: alternative vote
 
I need to......now you have put that thought into my head.:)

DaveinGermany 27-04-2011 18:24

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaysay (Post 901496)
In the words of David Cameron, calm down, calm down,:D:D

I think you'll find it was Ga' Ba' & Te' who said it Jay !

YouTube - Calm down, calm down! The Scousers - Harry Enfield - BBC comedy

jaysay 27-04-2011 18:26

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveinGermany (Post 901513)
I think you'll find it was Ga' Ba' & Te' who said it Jay !

YouTube - Calm down, calm down! The Scousers - Harry Enfield - BBC comedy

Cameron said it to Angel Eagles during Prime Ministers Question Time today Dave:)

Margaret Pilkington 27-04-2011 18:56

Re: alternative vote
 
And seemingly, caused a bit of an uproar.
Angela Eagles won't have liked that one little bit.

DaveinGermany 27-04-2011 19:00

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaysay (Post 901514)
Cameron said it to Angel Eagles during Prime Ministers Question Time today Dave:)

What Cameron chatting to a Bird ? Suppose it's better than a Clegg.

Cheeky scrote ! He's not a Scouser & as such has no right using one of our ® Catch phrases ! Next he'll be using "Gis a Job ! I can do dat !" ® Southern Shandy drinking wuss ! The neck of the Fella ! :eek: :)

Margaret Pilkington 27-04-2011 19:02

Re: alternative vote
 
More front than Blackpool :D:D:D

Mancie 27-04-2011 23:13

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveinGermany (Post 901523)
What Cameron chatting to a Bird ? Suppose it's better than a Clegg.

Cheeky scrote ! He's not a Scouser & as such has no right using one of our ® Catch phrases ! Next he'll be using "Gis a Job ! I can do dat !" ® Southern Shandy drinking wuss ! The neck of the Fella ! :eek: :)

I reckon he is a scouser.. likes a sunbed..got his bike nicked by his mates so claimed 500 sovs..moved his family into a multi bedroom house at the expense of the tax payer.. turns up for work at 11am and shoves off at 2pm...talks crap and looks like a lizard.:).... seems pretty clear to me.. a scouser! :rolleyes:

jaysay 28-04-2011 08:52

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveinGermany (Post 901523)
What Cameron chatting to a Bird ? Suppose it's better than a Clegg.

Cheeky scrote ! He's not a Scouser & as such has no right using one of our ® Catch phrases ! Next he'll be using "Gis a Job ! I can do dat !" ® Southern Shandy drinking wuss ! The neck of the Fella ! :eek: :)

That saying has more recently been linked to good old Michael Winner and his Saga insurance ads which of course you won't have seen in Deutschland :rolleyes:

DaveinGermany 28-04-2011 16:01

Re: alternative vote
 
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mancie (Post 901587)
I reckon he is a scouser.. likes a sunbed..got his bike nicked by his mates so claimed 500 sovs..moved his family into a multi bedroom house at the expense of the tax payer.. turns up for work at 11am and shoves off at 2pm...talks crap and looks like a lizard.:).... seems pretty clear to me.. a scouser! :rolleyes:

Mancie, Mancie, Mancie :) What are we to do with you eh ? :rolleyes: That's Scouser with a big "S", you almost had it nailed but you slipped up with the job comment ! ;) Work is going to collect yer Giro & that doesn't take 3 hours, we've got better things to do with our time. But that wicked Cameron & the clown Clegg are clamping down on us "S'not fair like ! Der pickin' on uz coz wer from Li'pooil !":D

Barrie Yates 28-04-2011 16:39

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveinGermany (Post 901680)
"S'not fair like ! Der pickin' on uz coz wer from Li'pooil !":D

Thought you would be "pickin'" your nose to clear it of the "s'not":D:D:D

DaveinGermany 28-04-2011 16:52

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Barrie Yates (Post 901691)
Thought you would be "pickin'" your nose to clear it of the "s'not":D:D:D

Droll Barrie, very droll ! Have you no ear for the nuances of Language ? ;) :D

jaysay 28-04-2011 17:37

Re: alternative vote
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveinGermany (Post 901696)
Droll Barrie, very droll ! Have you no ear for the nuances of Language ? ;) :D

Ya have to make exceptions for Plastic Mancs Dave;)


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:58.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1
© 2003-2013 AccringtonWeb.com