jonny edwards
 

gone from hull to Woking on loan so he has gone

Re: jonny edwards
 

At least the lad will get a run down yon.:rolleyes:

Re: jonny edwards
 

He's better than that but agree Cashy at least he'll get some game time

Re: jonny edwards
 

Add the need for another striker to needing more defenders! Plus a big central midfielder wouldn't go amiss. Team is very thin on ground now, 2 or 3 injuries could put us in all sorts of trouble. Barely have enough to fill the bench!

Hope Coleman has some more signings lined up ASAP

Re: jonny edwards
 

Good luck to the lad :)

Re: jonny edwards
 

I have always thought that.

Re: jonny edwards
 

Perhaps he left not best pleased? and thats why silence is golden?

Re: jonny edwards
 

Silence golden??

No loads of issues plus rules and regs; which ASFC perfer to keep "in house"!!

T'internet and Social Media does cause so many "issues"

I'm a fan of the old days when club news was on the back page of the Accy Observer !!:rolleyes:

Re: jonny edwards
 

Complete bullshine, a player leaving aint an issue, no need for reasons.so why the silence.?

Re: jonny edwards
 

He was officially "re-called"at 2pm today by Hull.

At this time we were busy getting players IN

Re: jonny edwards
 

Nothing hard about that was there?

Re: jonny edwards
 

Of course he was Mr T. Hahaha ! That gets around the rules nicely ...........

Re: jonny edwards
 

So some members talking tosh again then

Re: jonny edwards
 

Care to explain my friend???

Re: jonny edwards
 

T, was referring to 28 making things up

Re: jonny edwards
 

at the end of the day the lad for me wasn,t really given a chance. good luck to him at woking.

Re: jonny edwards
 

You just don't get it do you my friend ......... sad but true.
Mr T has given the formal stance but enough people apart from me on here know the truth.
Did you see Jonny anywhere near the club for the last three weeks ?
Was he named in a squad ?
Did he train with the lads ?
No.
Officially he was on loan to us until the end of the season.
Nothing could be said until he'd found another club because Hull City could have insisted we keep him.
Woking deal done - then everyone can put out a convenient party line.
Get it ? Got it ? Good.

Re: jonny edwards
 

What baffles me Monkey is why we went back for him at the start of this season.
Surely we should have been able to make decisions based on last season so that indicates Coley thought he was right for us ?
Unless he's gone backwards of course.

Re: jonny edwards
 

Actually agree with you here 28

Re: jonny edwards
 

28, maybe - just maybe, even if someone knows the truth about a situation but the club have their reasons for keeping quiet until it is time for 'the truth' to be announced it might be a good idea for that person to keep what they know to themselves, I know it can he frustrating if sometimes we feel we're being kept in the dark but blabbing things that aren't meant to be in the public domain isn't too clever either. Just my opinion of course :)

Re: jonny edwards
 

It's a discussion forum. Fans deserve to know what's going on particularly during a transfer window.
I never tout speculation.

Re: jonny edwards
 

On the bench today, at home to Maidstone.

Re: jonny edwards
 

The should call him 'The Judge'

Re: jonny edwards
 

I was a fan of Jonny Edwards and was surprised at the lack of game time he got. I thought he had a good season to offer us. I wish him well but I am disappointed at the way he treated by our club.

Re: jonny edwards
 

Edwards was on loan here last season, so why our manager brought him back on a season loan then never gave him a good run defies logic to me.:confused:

Re: jonny edwards
 

Was he treated badly though?

Re: jonny edwards
 

I believe so, As others have pointed out he was brought back after already having a season with us last year, so we knew what we were getting. Surely he could have had a better run of games to keep him up to scratch. We for some reason didn't give him a fair go.

Re: jonny edwards
 

Due to the form of our forwards post Christmas last season I don't think JC could have given him a proper chance if he'd wanted to, however when he did get chances off the bench looked way off the mark. Only thing he had going for him is a bit of pace and energy, and without being harsh on him think even at Woking he's a league too high for his ability. Don't expect him in full time football next season...

Regarding treating him badly, surely we put out our best team to win games? Clearly rate him or not that was never the case while he was here

Re: jonny edwards
 

Sorry, but gonna quote you here as I think it's you who 'doesn't get it' - if you repeat something that you've been told by a family member/friend or whoever it doesn't always serve them any good by repeating it on a public forum if it wasn't meant to be general knowledge

Re: jonny edwards
 

Spot on accy

Re: jonny edwards
 

It was public knowledge in the stand where I sit. Family didn't tell me - what family ?
It was talked about openly by football people.

Re: jonny edwards
 

How on earth can you say he was that bad compared to wilks??? I would be first to admit when he came back I expected to see him play more not less. You can't leave a player on the bench for as long as he was and then bring him on to play in the last 10 mins and do miracles. sorry it does not work like that. I understand we put the best team we have out to play games and that is the managers decision. We all have our own opinion as to whether he picked the right players. I totally disagree with your comment that woking is a league to high for him. I think we will hear more about him next season when he gets a regular run in a team. If he was as bad as you claim then we have to question Coley's judgement.

Re: jonny edwards
 

28, in your eyes what constitutes a football person?

Re: jonny edwards
 

If you're talking about the context in which I placed my reply people working in the game.
Overall anyone connected with the game are football people. Fans players coaches the lot.

Re: jonny edwards
 

Ok thanks