[Retlaw]

Originally Posted by churchfcrules

and how is this not a thread wander, you only posted to tell me i was wrong, then provided evidence!, when in fact i was correct and you dont know everything with your access to all of those records, history is about learning from all sources, and edith appletons is a primary source, the closet one to the event we have, not a letter printed in a paper that some widow asked them to print (read the nurses account)

the whole point of the thread was to ask people THEIR family history in accrington, i merely provided background to the fact that his name is on the cenotaph

where is your oldest family trace, has nothing to do with, your wrong your wrong your wrong.

another case!!!!!!

What the LLL are you getting exited about, I was only providing a newspaper cutting in case you didn't know of it, lots of people on Accy web have mentioned a relative in WW1 and I've provided them with info they didn't have.
I can't help it if your such a big head, that you expect every one to assume you already know it all.