View Single Post
Old 10-10-2012, 19:02   #18
annesingleton
Senior Member
 
annesingleton's Avatar
 

Re: Sir! Would you like a milkshake?

I'm not saying I agree with what this young person did to his teacher. But if you decide to make a career for yourself working with young people this is the way things work:
Any professional working with young people may not use any form of physical restraint unless they are trained to restrain safely using recognised techniques. It should never be used by one professional in isolation.
Restraint can only be used as a last resort in order to protect either the young person or others from harm. It cannot be used as a punishment or in retaliation.
I fully understand the frustration and anger this teacher must have felt when faced with a disruptive pupil who had thrown milkshake over him. He would have been better dealing with the pupil by removing him from the scene and going through the correct channels, but I expected he reacted instinctively, which is an absolute no - no in such a situation.
The teacher would be fully aware of what he should and should not do when dealing with a disruptive pupil, and whilst I can see the situation from his point of view, his experience and professionalism should have led him to take a different course of action - he now faces the consequences of his own inappropriate behaviour.
And under no circumstances do I condone the actions of the pupil whose behaviour was completely unacceptable - but in this situation the teacher was a professional adult, the pupil was a child.
Some people may say that children and young people today lack discipline and respect and in a lot of ways I agree, but if such behaviour by teachers was allowed, a lot of vulnerable children and young people who deserve more would be at the mercy of professionals who would be free to treat them with aggression for the least misdemeanour.
annesingleton is offline   Reply With Quote