Having just watch the ‘highlights’ I revise my comments about the ref.
I think he got the three big decisions right!
Coyle does appear to push his hand past the Charlton player’s arm to try and knock the ball away.
Leigh does lead with his arm, although it didn’t look and very much doubt it was malicious.
And the Charlton player does use his upper arm to control the ball before putting it in the net.
There were plenty of other strange decisions but, on those three, I don’t think Mr. Mather merits being a member of the Kettle Klutz Klub.