Accrington Web

Accrington Web (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/index.php)
-   General Chat (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/f69/)
-   -   American (Georgian) style policing (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/f69/american-georgian-style-policing-27571.html)

steeljack 11-01-2007 03:34

American (Georgian) style policing
 
Any Brits with thoughts of visiting Georgia should read this ........
incidentally this is the home state of one of our regular contributors......
I await her comments on this incident :D :D :D , if they behave this way to a visiting history professor I wonder how they treat members of the local ethnic communites.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main...istorian11.xml

WillowTheWhisp 11-01-2007 06:48

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Well that's enough to put me off going to Atlanta. I'm amazed he doesn't intend to sue, I would certainly have expected him to.

steve 11-01-2007 06:54

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Next time he might listen, they should try that here.:Banane33:

WillowTheWhisp 11-01-2007 07:13

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
If I was in a strange city and some guy who didn't clearly look like a policeman shouted at me to stop I'd be more likely to hurry on as quickly as possible. If I was kicked to the ground I'd be more likely to think I was being mugged than being arrested. It does sound very OTT.

jedimaster 11-01-2007 07:49

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
id have thought that it would be comon sense when in a foreign country to make yourself aware of the rules and seeing that this is a supposedly well educated person i'd have thought that this would have been obvious.

i make two observations from the picture

1. it's pretty obvious to anyone that these are police officers
2. he doesn't look like he has been subjected to the extreme violence he
so claims he experienced

it seems to me that this is just another toffee nosed git in a foreign country with the "that's hardly cricket old boy" attitude

bet he won't do it again though!

chav1 11-01-2007 07:50

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
well done to the police i wish they would do that to the morons here that just walk out into the road without looking :D


i have an online buddy who is a state marshall i think they call them in georgia and he woulda probably shot the idiot :D

chav1 11-01-2007 08:03

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
from teh story

Quote:

The professor said he had no plans to sue, adding: "It was actually a fantastic experience going into that detention centre and spending time with those miserable wretches of the earth. I feel I've learnt more than I would have in important sessions of the Historical Association."
so hes in jail for breaking the law but somehow hes above everyone esle in jail

deserved to get a kicking teh snotty nerd :rolleyes:

garinda 11-01-2007 08:23

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
I've travelled the world, and have never been arrested.

The professor sounds an idiot, and a snob.

It would have been interesting to read a fuller account of the incident from the police officer's side.

Moral, when in Rome, or Atlanta, don't jay walk, and if you break the law comply with the authorities, even if you have leather patches on the elbows of your tweed jacket.

Ianto.W. 11-01-2007 10:01

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
I wonder if 'Bullseye' has read this yet steeljack.:D

shakermaker 11-01-2007 10:30

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Looks like the police around there are just egotistical idiots.
You can jaywalk in some of the busiest places in the world such as Manhattan without a cop batting an eyelid but once the donut munchers in Georgia (just look at the detective with the beer gut - I really bet you'd want that serving and protecting you) get the chance to exercise authority then they abuse it.
The guy is a snob yes, but no one deserves that treatment.

garinda 11-01-2007 10:52

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
If you go down to 'day 3' of this link, you can watch the 'victims' account of the incident, by pressing play on the YouTube link.

Though he doesn't mention the kicking, and flying arms that he apparently exhibited when asked for his i-d, according to the offical police report.

http://hnn.us/articles/33409.html#Day3

jedimaster 11-01-2007 11:04

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
what a twot!!!!

Lolly 11-01-2007 11:56

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Just sounds like a snob. Its quite funny actually.

SPUGGIE J 11-01-2007 13:15

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
When in Rome.

He might have been shot then he might have had a complaint. Try that over here and shouts of police brutality and my human rights would come forth faster than a Cheetah on speed. :eek:

WillowTheWhisp 11-01-2007 13:48

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Are you guys really serious? Because you think this professor is a snob it's OK for his to be violently assaulted by the police?

Why is he a snob? Is it because he speaks with an educated accent and doesn't say "Well, like, er, yunno" ? He seems like a very aimiable mild mannered likeable chap to me. He clearly didn't realise that the person speaking to him was a policeman but from what he says he hadn't even ignored the guy. He'd thanked him for telling him he couldn't cross the road there.

As a foreigner in town would he be clearly aware that it was a crime to cross the road there? Especilly considering he'd seen plenty of other people doing so. Is there anyone on this board who has never crossed elsewhere than on a zebra crossing or waited for the little green man? I see loads of people in accy walking across at pelican crossings when the red man is lit.

Is it really so offensive to ask the policeman to identify himself as a police officer? I thought they were obliged to do that anyway (seen them flashing the badge so many times in the movies) and over here we are constantly being told we should ask officials for their ID and that they expect this and will not be offended.

This part of the article struck me:


Quote:

In court even the prosecutors seemed embarrassed by the incident, which got out of hand when Fernandez-Armesto requested to see the policeman's identification (the policeman was wearing a bomber jacket; to Fernandez-Armesto, a foreigner unfamiliar with American culture, the officer did not look like an officer). The prosecutors asked the professor to plead nolo contendere. He refused, concerned that the stain on his record might put his green card status in jeopardy. Officials finally agreed to drop all charges. The judge expressed his approval. The professor says he has no plans to sue. But the AHA council is considering lodging a complaint with the city.
Even the prosecutors seemed embarrassed? The judge approved of the charges being dropped? The AHA is not best chuffed.

I don't think the large gentleman is a police officer. It sounds like he was one of the security staff who came out to assist.

Why did the professor need to be kicked to the ground even if he was being arrested? Did the policeman really need 4 others to assist him? He wasn't tackling the incredible hulk.

Church Boy 11-01-2007 14:10

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
If they did something like that to an African American there would be hell to pay.I think this sort of thing is happening because copper's today have no power over crim's,and they pick on the easy target,ordinary citizen,s like him,who don't deserve shabby treatment like that.

jedimaster 11-01-2007 14:50

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
like i said judging by the pics and now the video - no visible signs of extreme violence

bearing in mind an upper class twerps interpretation of excessive violence does generally differ somewhat to joe publics

methinks the press are trying to beef up the story in their usual way

garinda 11-01-2007 15:25

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
I think he should count his bessings he didn't even get a caution, and that it happened in Atlanta Georgia, rather than Stockwell south London, where he might have been shot dead.:D

Billcat 11-01-2007 15:26

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shakermaker (Post 365399)
Looks like the police around there are just egotistical idiots.
You can jaywalk in some of the busiest places in the world such as Manhattan without a cop batting an eyelid but once the donut munchers in Georgia (just look at the detective with the beer gut - I really bet you'd want that serving and protecting you) get the chance to exercise authority then they abuse it.
The guy is a snob yes, but no one deserves that treatment.

I'm originally from Atlanta. Certainly would never wish to move back.

You raise some good points. In many big cities, the police on occasion get way out of line. It's obvious that this cop overrated in a very serious way. While jaywalking is against the law, it is only a minor misdemeanor, roughly on a par with a parking violation! And I'm not aware that being a snob, or being a slob for that matter, is a chargeable offense anywhere.

Any reasonable city cop is also very well aware that, while jaywalking may be strictly enforced in Atlanta or Seattle, there are many cities in the USA where it is not. Can't imagine a NYC cop spending time on such nonsense when there are far more serious problems that need to be dealt with.

If this cop wanted enforce the law, he should have promptly identified himself as a policeman and told the professor that he was being issued a summons. Even in Seattle, when the cops realize that you are from out of town, they generally let you off with a warning. Once the visitors know the rules, they generally comply.

Not surprised that the judge threw the case out. They don't want to waste their time on this stuff either. There are more important issues to be addressed.

garinda 11-01-2007 15:28

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 365479)
Are you guys really serious? Because you think this professor is a snob it's OK for his to be violently assaulted by the police?

Why is he a snob? Is it because he speaks with an educated accent and doesn't say "Well, like, er, yunno" ? He seems like a very aimiable mild mannered likeable chap to me. He clearly didn't realise that the person speaking to him was a policeman but from what he says he hadn't even ignored the guy. He'd thanked him for telling him he couldn't cross the road there.

As a foreigner in town would he be clearly aware that it was a crime to cross the road there? Especilly considering he'd seen plenty of other people doing so. Is there anyone on this board who has never crossed elsewhere than on a zebra crossing or waited for the little green man? I see loads of people in accy walking across at pelican crossings when the red man is lit.

Is it really so offensive to ask the policeman to identify himself as a police officer? I thought they were obliged to do that anyway (seen them flashing the badge so many times in the movies) and over here we are constantly being told we should ask officials for their ID and that they expect this and will not be offended.

This part of the article struck me:



Even the prosecutors seemed embarrassed? The judge approved of the charges being dropped? The AHA is not best chuffed.

I don't think the large gentleman is a police officer. It sounds like he was one of the security staff who came out to assist.

Why did the professor need to be kicked to the ground even if he was being arrested? Did the policeman really need 4 others to assist him? He wasn't tackling the incredible hulk.

True his class has nothing to do with it, but his arrogance has. The police were doing their job, mainly stopping people getting killed from crossing between the two hotels. He should have complied with the request for i-d, and should not have flailed his arms and legs about when he was being arrested.

WillowTheWhisp 11-01-2007 15:36

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
I've seen video footage of people flailing their arms and legs about when being pinned to the ground by several burly police men and being sat upon thus making breathing extremely difficult. I think I would probably flail too.

Heaven help us if it becomes an arrestable offence here not to cross the road at the correct designated point. The jails would be full.

garinda 11-01-2007 15:42

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 365517)
I've seen video footage of people flailing their arms and legs about when being pinned to the ground by several burly police men and being sat upon thus making breathing extremely difficult. I think I would probably flail too.

Heaven help us if it becomes an arrestable offence here not to cross the road at the correct designated point. The jails would be full.

But none of that would have happened, if he had produced his driving licence when requested, or even simpler complied with the request in the first place not to cross the road.

It's hardly up there with Rodney King, in the list of police brutality.

When you travel, you obey the laws and customs of your host country or pay the consequences, you don't bleat about it afterwards.

Tealeaf 11-01-2007 15:48

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Please remember that in the USA, driving is done on the right-hand side of the road. This is of course, illogical, both from a health and a social viewpoint. It is a simple fact that the 50-odd countries that drive on the left have a lower accident per mile/vehicle than those that drive on the right. And, of course, if your girlfriend/wife happens to be right handed, it is much better that she sits on your left to give some comfort in the course of a long and arduous journey, such as to and from the Accy ASDA.

Is it any wonder, then, that American or European pavements have to be policed in the way they are? The simple solution to all this nonsense about jaywalking is to make traffic drive on the correct side of the road - the left - and then we can all cross the road in safety and without harressment from cops who have nowt else to do.

WillowTheWhisp 11-01-2007 15:49

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
I don't think he had his driving licence on him. From what he said in the interview he was dithering because he was wondering what he did have that he could show which would be adequate for the purpose. I still think the police actions were OTT. If it had been me I don't have a driving licence and my passport would be locked safely away so what would I produce?

garinda 11-01-2007 16:28

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 365526)
I don't think he had his driving licence on him. From what he said in the interview he was dithering because he was wondering what he did have that he could show which would be adequate for the purpose. I still think the police actions were OTT. If it had been me I don't have a driving licence and my passport would be locked safely away so what would I produce?

He did have his UK driving licence on him at the time, but not his passport.

Tealeaf 11-01-2007 16:37

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Who gives a damn what sort of identification he had with him? This arrogant fool chose to break the laws of a country of which he was a guest; he gave a little bit of lip to a copper and got a little slap in return. So what?

Can someone tell me what is currently going on in Accrington? Has the storm blown over yet? Do I need my wellys tomorrow?

garinda 11-01-2007 16:46

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tealeaf (Post 365551)
Who gives a damn what sort of identification he had with him? This arrogant fool chose to break the laws of a country of which he was a guest; he gave a little bit of lip to a copper and got a little slap in return. So what?

Can someone tell me what is currently going on in Accrington? Has the storm blown over yet? Do I need my wellys tomorrow?

Oh dearie me. I'm in agreement with old Teabag on this one.

Re: the weather in Accy.

Storm still raging. All roads are closed, and impassable. Travellers warned to stay at home.:D

WillowTheWhisp 11-01-2007 16:49

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Oh well I'm in a very small minority here but I still feel sorry for him for the ordeal he went through which seems so unfair.

What exactly is the legal definition of 'jaywalking' ?

Lolly 11-01-2007 16:51

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
If you are going to put ur wellies on put weights in the bottom!!

and I agree with Tealeaf and Garinda on this one.

Lolly 11-01-2007 16:52

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaywalking

WillowTheWhisp 11-01-2007 16:58

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
This is an interesting paragraph
Quote:

Some supporters of jaywalking argue that on certain streets, jaywalking can be safer than crossing properly at an intersection. When a pedestrian crosses at an intersection, there is traffic going three or more different directions, with four directions being standard in almost all cases. Vehicles may go straight, or they may turn left or right across the pedestrian's path. This is typically at high speed, sometimes without signalling, and sometimes while running red lights at even higher speeds. However, drivers may be more likely to expect pedestrians at a corner than in the middle of the block.

I would much rather cross where there is only traffic from two directions if there isn't a pelican crossing type thing with lights at the crossroads. In fact I've walked up a road rather than cross at a junction many times. Good job it's not illegal here. In fact didn't the Green Cross Man actually tell children to cross "away from junctions and parked cars"?

chav1 11-01-2007 16:58

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
right or wrong i still find the bashing of this ****** hilarious :D

LancYorkYankee 11-01-2007 17:52

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tealeaf (Post 365551)
Who gives a damn what sort of identification he had with him? This arrogant fool chose to break the laws of a country of which he was a guest; he gave a little bit of lip to a copper and got a little slap in return. So what?

Can someone tell me what is currently going on in Accrington? Has the storm blown over yet? Do I need my wellys tomorrow?

I too agree with Tealeaf here. I also believe the cop was probably one of our arrogant type of police officer.

I work with aot of police officers and they come in all types. Unfortunately, many have an overactive bravado about them. These types use their position of authority in a somewhat bullyish manner.

You can see it on the "Cops" show. I've seen some of those guys (cops) reactive so violently when there was absolutely no cause. They just felt like either showing off for the camera or having a go at someone who isn't allowed to "resist!"

I mean, even in this case, it was only Jaywalking. In all the cities or towns I've been in, jaywalking is permissable (although still basically illegal). Where the cities/towns take it more seriously and enforce this law it is usually clearly posted along many of the roads!

Brian

Billcat 11-01-2007 18:08

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LancYorkYankee (Post 365612)
I mean, even in this case, it was only Jaywalking. In all the cities or towns I've been in, jaywalking is permissable (although still basically illegal). Where the cities/towns take it more seriously and enforce this law it is usually clearly posted along many of the roads!

Brian

And, if the cop is really concerned about jaywalking, a polite warning is usually the worst outcome.

About the only time I've ever seen a cop get upset with jaywalking is when a fellow did some very unsafe jaywalking with his children. The cop's theme was pretty much "get yourself killed if you wish, but don't endanger the kids." No ticket, just a stern warning.

You are also correct, LancYorkYankee, there police work attracts a number of folks who abuse the powers of the office. It's a small percentage, but one that does a lot to destroy respect for law enforcement. Had a fellow the year behind me in high school who went into the local force. A felloow with little in the way of people skills from his early days, not a lick of common sense, and never changed. Spent his career doing whatever the captain (a pretty good friend of mine) could do to keep him away from interaction with the public - and a lot of time on probationary status for his improper behavior! I can easily imagnie him acting as the officer did in Atlanta.

LancYorkYankee 11-01-2007 18:23

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Yeah, I agree with that Billcat. I too knew a few guys from high school who became cops. It seemed to be either the bullies or the ones who had been bullied. Both types joined the force with some anger or people lacking issues. It's unfortunate how they do bring discredit to the rest of the police.

:D:D I mean, the typical U.S. cop is content with his daily dozen donuts and lack of any type of physical exertion!:D :D

Brian

Ianto.W. 12-01-2007 00:20

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Why do they do they call it 'Jaywalking', I do not think this beautiful bird would be daft enough to walk in front of traffic in 'blighty', never mind a main street in the USA. As for the brutal police officer was he racially motivated? Correct me if I am wrong please, but did not the State of Georgia play a significant part in the slave trade.

garinda 12-01-2007 00:24

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ianto.W. (Post 365821)
Why do they do they call it 'Jaywalking', I do not think this beautiful bird would be daft enough to walk in front of traffic in 'blighty', never mind a main street in the USA. As for the brutal police officer was he racially motivated? Correct me if I am wrong please, but did not the State of Georgia play a significant part in the slave trade.


http://www.askoxford.com/asktheexper...ins/jaywalking


Bah, those damn Yankies are to blame again.:D

shakermaker 12-01-2007 00:26

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ianto.W. (Post 365821)
As for the brutal police officer was he racially motivated?

Could well be true.
That bloke's accent certainly makes me want to give him a slap!

Surely the just and fair USA law enforcement should be more professional :rolleyes: Yeh right...

steeljack 12-01-2007 00:33

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ianto.W. (Post 365821)
Why do they do they call it 'Jaywalking', I do not think this beautiful bird would be daft enough to walk in front of traffic in 'blighty', never mind a main street in the USA. As for the brutal police officer was he racially motivated? Correct me if I am wrong please, but did not the State of Georgia play a significant part in the slave trade.

after viewing the videos of the interview with the supercilious arrogant prat of a history professor I agree with the actions of Bubba , think I would have given him a slap 'upside' the head . I dont think the cop was guilty of racial profiling , unless it was against effete British intellectuals who think its ok to use the word 'louche' in everyday conversation .........:D :D

jedimaster 12-01-2007 00:33

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
well i say send him to joe arpaio - that'll teach him not to jaywalk (or give grief to a copper)

garinda 12-01-2007 00:36

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
'I come from a country where you can cross the road where you like," said the visiting professor of global environmental history.'

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/6251431.stm


Yes you do Professor. You also come from a country where the age of consent is sixteen. So it's a good job you didn't sleep with a girl in Arizona, because unlike here the age of consent is eighteen in that state.

I wasn't there to witness this incident, but I just know there was the sort of attitude from the learned academic, that shouts of
'How very dare you! Don't you know who I am?'

jedimaster 12-01-2007 00:38

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
reminds me of those damned impudent fuzzy wuzzy's - they don't like it up 'em you know!

shakermaker 12-01-2007 00:42

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
The '...but I didn't know officer!' is of course a lie. & very 'Carry On...'.

Still, as I said earlier, no one deserves that kind of treatment for such a non-crime.

steeljack 12-01-2007 00:46

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by shakermaker (Post 365834)
The '...but I didn't know officer!' is of course a lie. & very 'Carry On...'.

Still, as I said earlier, no one deserves that kind of treatment for such a non-crime.

I think the professor protesteth to much .....probably the type who likes being roughed-up by a guy in cop uniform, I understand there are folks that enjoy this type of abuse :eek:

garinda 12-01-2007 00:48

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by steeljack (Post 365837)
I think the professor protesteth to much .....probably the type who likes being roughed-up by a guy in cop uniform, I understand there are folks that enjoy this type of abuse :eek:


Whose the Daddy?:D

http://www.trinachow.com/blog/images..._05/folsom.jpg

Ianto.W. 12-01-2007 00:51

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

garinda, I wasn't there to witness this incident, but I just know there was the sort of attitude from the learned academic, that shouts of
'How very dare you! Don't you know who I am?'
Now now garinda the Yanks are past masters at playing that card, "you can't do that, don't you realise i'm an American citizen"

steeljack 12-01-2007 00:55

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 365838)

yep, and probably everyone of them is a vegan .....

garinda 12-01-2007 00:55

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ianto.W. (Post 365839)
Now now garinda the Yanks are past masters at playing that card, "you can't do that, don't you realise i'm an American citizen"

I honestly disagree. Over 50% of my customers used to be Americans, and nearly all were respectful and uncomplaining, whilst in our country. Well once they realised it wasn't always foggy, we rode in carriages, and didn't all wear Deer Stalker hats.

Oh, and that our drinks don't always come with ice, and we have no air conditioning.:D

garinda 12-01-2007 00:57

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by steeljack (Post 365841)
yep, and probably everyone of them is a vegan .....


I suspect you are wrong. I bet they eat meat.

How very louche.:D

LancYorkYankee 12-01-2007 01:40

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 365824)
http://www.askoxford.com/asktheexper...ins/jaywalking


Bah, those damn Yankies are to blame again.:D

Ooh Rindy, thought you were referring to someone in Georgia as a Yankee. That'd be a HUGE faux pas! Just to protect me English mates from bloodshed if they ever happen to visit here . . . please don't refer to anyone from "the South" as a Yankee. It'd be kinda like me calling you guys . . . wait for it . . . :eek: Irishmen:eek: (he ducks at the horror).

However, the article correctly stated that jaywalking was "invented" in Boston, which, from only your guys, and the Souths, point of view could be referred to as Yankees. However, as a New Englander myself, you could also be popped up there for calling any of them folks Yankees

It's based on the hated rivalry in the game of baseball between the Boston Red Sox (yay, woohoo, yippee, Go Sox) and the hated New York Yankees (boo, hiss, eat my shorts Billcat . . .).

Okay, American etiquet lesson, and 3 lagers, over!

Brian

LancYorkYankee 12-01-2007 01:45

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Okay, wicked thread wander here!

Rindy, I blame you for my bit of overindulgence tonight. Why the heck would you horrify us all with that pic of Nellie bloody Olson from Little House on The Prairie! Am I correct about that or am I hallucinating over here?

Oh what a little beast she was!! (not that I ever watched that girlie show, though I did "have a friend" who thought Mr. Edwards was pretty cool!

Brian

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 07:12

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Billcat (Post 365636)
And, if the cop is really concerned about jaywalking, a polite warning is usually the worst outcome.

About the only time I've ever seen a cop get upset with jaywalking is when a fellow did some very unsafe jaywalking with his children. The cop's theme was pretty much "get yourself killed if you wish, but don't endanger the kids." No ticket, just a stern warning.

That was precisely my point.

OK the guy crossed where he shouldn't have. The policeman told him. He thanked the policeman for the info, although he didn't know at the time that he was a policeman. Why on earth should it have escalated into the prof having his legs kicked out from under him and half a dozen policemen to arrest him? Did it really need so many to pin down one puny little professor? Was it his upper class English accent that caused such a furore? It seems that it would have provoked a few AccyWebbers to join in if they'd had the chance. Is that a form of snobbery in reverse?

garinda 12-01-2007 08:27

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
"Where I'm from, you don't associate young gentlemen in bomber jackets with the police. But he was extremely upset I had questioned his bona fides," recalled Fernandez-Armesto.



But Leonpacher said he asked Fernandez-Armesto why he didn't follow the instructions of a uniformed officer, and the author shrugged him off and walked away.



"He was swinging, kicking wildly," Leonpacher said.





It's hardly thanking him, and walking away, before being arrested. Sounds to me he was being an arrogant ass.

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 10:00

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 365868)
"Where I'm from, you don't associate young gentlemen in bomber jackets with the police. But he was extremely upset I had questioned his bona fides," recalled Fernandez-Armesto.

I don't think I'd associate a young man in a bomber jacket with the police either and what's wrong with asking for ID? We ask people who come to read the meter to prove who they are don't we? OK that's because we let them into our homes, but aren't police officers supposed to show people their ID not get the 'ump about being asked for it?

Quote:

But Leonpacher said he asked Fernandez-Armesto why he didn't follow the instructions of a uniformed officer, and the author shrugged him off and walked away.



"He was swinging, kicking wildly," Leonpacher said.
Didn't the kicking wildly take place after he'd been thrown to the floor and pounced on? A fairly natural reaction I would have thought. It's not exactly pleasant to have your legs kicked out from under you and find yourself face down on the ground with several people on top of you.


Quote:




It's hardly thanking him, and walking away, before being arrested. Sounds to me he was being an arrogant ass.
The kicking of the legs from under him occurred after he was thanking and walking away and before he was flailing wildly didn't it?

I can't help wondering what would have happened if the prof had had a heart condition and suffered a heart attack whilst all this was happening. What if the officer did the same to someone in poor health and as a consequence the person died?

I'm still not convinced the actions were appropriate. Yes the guy crossed the road in the wrong place. Yes he should have been corrected for doing so - but was the punishment really equal to the crime? If he'd been a mugger who'd robbed a little old lady's handbag then I could have understood the cop flooring him to prevent his escape, but for crossing the road in the wrong place?

Yes it still puts me off visiting Georgia if this should be regarded as normal acceptable behaviour.

garinda 12-01-2007 10:05

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Apparently he was kicking wildly when an attempt was made to arrest him, thus other officers were called to assist.

All the officers in the photograph look like policemen to me.

Then again, I'd have had the good sense to show my driving licence, and wouldn't have been arrested in the first place.

jedimaster 12-01-2007 10:15

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 365892)

I'm still not convinced the actions were appropriate. Yes the guy crossed the road in the wrong place. Yes he should have been corrected for doing so - but was the punishment really equal to the crime?

dont think he was floored for jaywalking i think it was more the attitude and the walking away then the kicking and flailing - couldn't this be interpreted as resisting arrest?

it is actually nice to see that police in some places in the world aren't prepared to take any cr#p

if he had done as he was asked in the first place none of this would have happened!

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 10:25

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 365896)
Apparently he was kicking wildly when an attempt was made to arrest him, thus other officers were called to assist.

But at what point was this "attempt" occurring? From what I could gather he was told he was going to be arrested and then his legs were kicked out from under him. Why on earth was that necessary? He wasn't a huge tough muscular bloke he is a puny little bod. Why was force necessary? Even the police officer himself described it in a way which implied it was more than he perhaps needed to have done.


I see more than 5 officers in that photo too - are we sure any of them is the one who originally approached the prof and floored him?

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 10:31

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jedimaster (Post 365905)
dont think he was floored for jaywalking i think it was more the attitude and the walking away then the kicking and flailing - couldn't this be interpreted as resisting arrest?


It sounds like he walked away because he thought the matter was ended when he'd been told it was the wrong place to cross. He thanked the young man and walked away - then was kicked to the ground.

Perhaps it boils down to the officer hadn't finished but the prof theought he had - a misunderstanding.

By walking away the officer interpreted it as resisiting arrest - a misunderstanding.

So he kicked him to the ground - a trifle OTT.

Then he called for backup because the prof was flailing about, a natural reaction to having your legs kicked out from under you. Now OTT getting out of hand.


A simple matter which could ahve been resolved with a little more understanding and tolerance of foreign visitors on behalf of the police officer.

I would like to see an image of him wearing the bomber jacket so I'd know if I would realise he was a policeman.

garinda 12-01-2007 10:51

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 365917)
But at what point was this "attempt" occurring? From what I could gather he was told he was going to be arrested and then his legs were kicked out from under him. Why on earth was that necessary? He wasn't a huge tough muscular bloke he is a puny little bod. Why was force necessary? Even the police officer himself described it in a way which implied it was more than he perhaps needed to have done.

I presume his legs were kicked from under him whilst he was kicking and flailing his arms about.

Reading the full account on the site were the video was posted, all the delegates knew there was police outside to prevent them from jaywalking, because they were complaining about it. They were there to prevent them presumably from being injured or killed, if they were knocked down.

garinda 12-01-2007 10:53

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 365922)
It sounds like he walked away because he thought the matter was ended when he'd been told it was the wrong place to cross. He thanked the young man and walked away - then was kicked to the ground.

Perhaps it boils down to the officer hadn't finished but the prof theought he had - a misunderstanding.

By walking away the officer interpreted it as resisiting arrest - a misunderstanding.

He didn't walk away, he admitted he challenged on what authority the police officer had to see his i-d.

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 10:56

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
I shall go and have another read of that site. I found the videos hard to listen to as there's always too much peripheral noise here even when I ask people to be quiet and he is so softly spoken.

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 11:01

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Well I can see the bit where it says:

Quote:

On the days after the professor's ordeal, the Atlanta police were continuing to stop historians from jaywalking. Anybody caught crossing the street against the light was reprimanded. Many were asked to produce their driver's license. But police did not arrest anybody. Some historians were mildly amused by the attentiveness of the police to the crime of jaywalking.
I don't see where it says that they'd been doing it before.

When I read that part previously I was just pleased to see that they hadn't manhandled anyone else and assumed that perhaps they'd learned that less is more.

garinda 12-01-2007 11:05

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Well without going around in circles, we'll have to agree to disagree.

I just know none of it would have happened to me, because I have more sense, and would have complied with the request for i-d.

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 11:07

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
You see what I mean about it all being down to understanding or misunderstanding? Even reading the report of the incident can be interpreted in diffrent ways. :D

Anyhow I still say being an upper class twit has never been a crime either here or in Georgia.

jedimaster 12-01-2007 11:09

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
but was he actually kicked to the ground?

or was he pushed onto the ground to be handcuffed ( a common thing to quickly and safely immobilise the person and prevent injury to both detainee and police officer if detainee decides to put up a fight)

i believe that this has been blown out of all proportion and that it is the nutty professor and the press that are ott in this case

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 11:11

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
His version of events is that he had his legs kicked out from under him. Why do people have to be on the ground to be arrested? People here are normally arrested in a vertical position aren't they?

garinda 12-01-2007 11:16

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
http://www.ajc.com/metro/content/met...twalk0110.html

jedimaster 12-01-2007 11:19

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 365974)
His version of events is that he had his legs kicked out from under him. Why do people have to be on the ground to be arrested? People here are normally arrested in a vertical position aren't they?

depends on the situation if they agree yes
if not then it means using force and putting the suspect on the ground is one of the safest and most effective ways for both police officer and suspect

SPUGGIE J 12-01-2007 12:36

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Looking back and after a look at some of the posts I started to wonder why wlse the cops would go nuts. Then it occured to me that its not just the numpty bimbling accros the road in the wrong place that gets hurt. There is the car that could hit him and the trouble that would cause with injuries possibly to the driver. Then what about the mental trauma the medical bills and what it would do to any kids seeing it especially if they were in the car. So fair doo's the police were over the top but compared to what might have happened he got off lightly.

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 13:21

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Now that's a very interestingly different slant to things Rindy because to read the officers account there is no reference at all to the professor having his legs kicked out from under him and yet:
Quote:

"It looked rather pathetic," said Lisa Kazmier, a professor of history at Drexel University in Philadelphia. She witnessed the arrest. "I definitely felt sorry for the guy. It was like he was Osama Bin Laden or something. It seemed so bizarre seeing this helpless looking guy on the ground like that."

At least it hasn't been dismissed or poohpoohed by Mayor Shirley Franklin who said she has asked police chief Richard Pennington to look into 'the incident' so it is obviously a concern that this shouldn't be a normal ocurrance.

Billcat 12-01-2007 14:00

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 365843)
I suspect you are wrong. I bet they eat meat.

How very louche.:D

Nope. Donuts! :p

Billcat 12-01-2007 14:06

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LancYorkYankee (Post 365852)
It's based on the hated rivalry in the game of baseball between the Boston Red Sox (yay, woohoo, yippee, Go Sox) and the hated New York Yankees (boo, hiss, eat my shorts Billcat . . .).

Okay, American etiquet lesson, and 3 lagers, over!

Brian

"Eat my shorts?" My, you are being retro today!

You are welcome to my share of the lagers.

Red Sox? Red Sox? Is that one of those minor-league franchises? :confused: I will admit, however, that my dad was a Boston Braves fan while he was at Hahvahd! "Spahn, Sain, and two days of rain!"

Billcat 12-01-2007 14:11

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp (Post 365861)
Why on earth should it have escalated into the prof having his legs kicked out from under him and half a dozen policemen to arrest him? Did it really need so many to pin down one puny little professor? Was it his upper class English accent that caused such a furore?

An English accent and just a soupcon of attitude (or the preception of attitude, even) would be enough to set off some cops. Obviously, as the mayor saw fit to have this incident investigated, there is a possibility that something was amiss.

Church Boy 12-01-2007 14:13

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by steeljack (Post 365841)
yep, and probably everyone of them is a vegan .....

Yes,But these fine officer's are attached to the vice squad,Georgia,s best kept secret.Jay walking is a way of life to them.

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 14:14

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
I think his accent and mannerisms could easily have been misinterpreted as "attitude".

Church Boy 12-01-2007 14:47

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
I would have liked to be a fly on the wall
after this case was thrown out of Court,just
to hear the avalanche of scorn put on this overzealous cop by his superiors.What a waste of Taxpayers money.

bullseyebarb 12-01-2007 18:36

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
At first blush, I was inclined to be sympathetic towards the Prof. After all, it's not entirely unheard of for Atlanta cops to do a little body-slamming. However, after I read his remarks about this experience as it relates to our country, I had a change of heart......and I quote:

"I have long known, as any reasonable person must, that the courts are the citizen's only protection against a rogue executive and uncontrolled security forces. Though my own misadventure was trivial - and in perspective laughable - it resembles what is happening to the world in the era of George W. Bush. The planet is policed by a violent, arbitrary, stupid and dangerous force. Within the USA, the courts struggle to maintain individual rights under the bludgeons of the "war on terror", defending Guantanamo victims and striving to curb the excesses of the system. We need global institutions of justice and judges of Judge Jackson's level of humanity and wisdom to help protect the world."

So, there you are. And what would that force be? Why, the United States, of course! No mention of the threat of Islamic fascism. No mention of the violent, arbitrary and dangerous nature of flying airplanes into office buildings. In fact, the good Prof puts scare quotes around his reference to the war on terror, as if to say that he doesn't really believe that there is any terrorism to be fought. Then he goes on to say that what we really need is some sort of an international court to protect the world from the United States. Some historian. Perhaps he doesn't remember the role of the United States in saving his precious Europe from Hitler and Soviet expansionism.

All the guy had to say to the police officer was, "I'm sorry. I'll be more careful next time." He would have been on his way in moments. But given the above diatribe, is it possible he gave the cop some lip?


I agree with many of the posters on this thread. The guy is a pompous ass.

garinda 12-01-2007 19:20

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
It's a bit hard to read, but here is a copy of the police report.

Included is a statement from another delegate, a Professor no less, stating that the officer in question 'kept his cool'.


http://alt.coxnewsweb.com/ajc/metro/MetJayWalk.pdf

WillowTheWhisp 12-01-2007 22:18

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Aha! Now this is the first time that the blowing of a whistle is mentioned as far as I'm aware. The blowing of the whistle should have been significant. It would indicate something more official than a passing lout telling the guy where to cross.

Barb would probably have totally agreed with you at one time but that was before I watched a recent program on the CIA involvement in overthrowing the governments of other countries and I can see where they get the idea now that the USA was the terrorisor first.

bullseyebarb 20-01-2007 20:19

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Update. This past week, a lady went jaywalking in Atlanta. No watchful, donut eating cop in sight. She went splat. Now deceased. I think people really should pay attention when crossing busy city streets. Use the designated crosswalks for goodness sake!

WillowTheWhisp 20-01-2007 21:36

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
It's funny but I have always thought of jaywalking as being walking out into the road without looking if anything is coming - in which case hardly surprising if people end up going splat. The sort of jaywalking where people cross at a non-designated place but still do look both ways and only cross when they can see the road is clear is the sort of normal way people over here cross the road because it's safer to do that than at a junction where traffic is coming from four different directions rather than two.

Ianto.W. 21-01-2007 12:14

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
This is the bit that realy amused me.
Quote:

Officer Leonpacher denied that he overreacted, saying the historian repeatedly refused to co-operate. The 28-year-old told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution: "I used an excessive amount of discretion"
And this statement ha ha.
Quote:

Atlanta's mayor, Shirley Franklin, said: "We want everyone who visits Atlanta to find Atlanta to be friendly and helpful
America land of the 'not' so free to go, sorry if I appear cynical but they'd have been better off saying nowt.

garinda 21-01-2007 12:50

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
The jacket the police officer was wearing the day the Professor refused to obey his order not to cross the road where he wanted to.


Seems pretty obvious to me, unless there was also a Village People convention near by.

http://www.ajc.com/news/content/news...atjaywalk.html

jedimaster 21-01-2007 14:23

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
hmmmm is it just me or does it quite categorically state atlanta police

Ianto.W. 21-01-2007 14:51

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
There is an old saying in Yorkshire where I was Born, I have heard 'posher' versions but here goes. "There is a difference between sh*****g yourself and blowing your brains out", that my good friends is what was lacking here, not who was right, and who was wrong. DISCRETION!

WillowTheWhisp 21-01-2007 16:51

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jedimaster (Post 371906)
hmmmm is it just me or does it quite categorically state atlanta police


It does, right across the back - presumably the police officer approached the prof in a forward motion so I'd have liked to see the front of the jacket rather than the reverse.

Ianto.W. 21-01-2007 19:55

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Willow even if as they have dubed him, was a giant SNOB, it did not warrant the level of violence dished out by this COWARD of a 'police' officer, who obviously had the 'odds' weighed up.

cashman 21-01-2007 23:25

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
just read through this thread i believe about 90% of what the press publish is either exajerated or pure crap, about 40% of what the police say is the same. about 99% of people who are accused say they are innocent, as any prison officer will testify, and reading between the lines of all this info i believe that there was a damn site more to this than jaywalking. just my 2 cents.;)

Ianto.W. 21-01-2007 23:40

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Me to cashman like I said before, who was right or wrong defeats me, but the way the saga has been handled leaves a lot to be desired. I once would have said "it could only happen in America", but after recent events in London 'the man from Brazil' fiasco, i'm not so sure now.

cashman 21-01-2007 23:52

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ianto.W. (Post 372288)
Me to cashman like I said before, who was right or wrong defeats me, but the way the saga has been handled leaves a lot to be desired. I once would have said "it could only happen in America", but after recent events in London 'the man from Brazil' fiasco, i'm not so sure now.

agree with that,saying though everyone i.e. the guy,the police,as the primary two but i cant help but wonder that if this had been a working class oik or a bum, would the justice system have thrown it out?that i have serious doubts about.

steeljack 21-01-2007 23:54

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
As details have come out over time it appears this guy (the professor) is a bit of a jerk , evidently he is a teacher at Tufts university near Boston Massachusetts , as such he is not FOB (Fresh Of the Boat)and has spent some time in the US and as such knows the laws about crossing the street ,

As I said in an earlier post he is probably just an effette intellectual looking for a bit of rough and wanted to get slapped around

Ianto.W. 22-01-2007 00:06

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cashman (Post 372291)
agree with that,saying though everyone i.e. the guy,the police,as the primary two but i cant help but wonder that if this had been a working class oik or a bum, would the justice system have thrown it out?that i have serious doubts about.

It would not even have made the papers, unless 'Billy's Weekly Liar' had taken it up.;)

WillowTheWhisp 22-01-2007 07:38

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ianto.W. (Post 372143)
Willow even if as they have dubed him, was a giant SNOB, it did not warrant the level of violence dished out by this COWARD of a 'police' officer, who obviously had the 'odds' weighed up.

That was what I was saying at the start - did it really need such heavy handed methods and ALL those other policemen for one puny little English prof, snob or not? Wouldn't they have been better employed nabbing a few muggers and flinging them to the floor?

garinda 22-01-2007 09:18

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Being half Spanish, and a little on the dark side, I think he was lucky not to have been shot.:D

WillowTheWhisp 22-01-2007 10:26

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
nah, that only happens over here. ;)

garinda 22-01-2007 11:07

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
'Where I'm from you don't associate young gentlemen in bomber jackets with the police.'

That one supercilious comment sums up his all elitist attitude. As was pointed out this is a well travelled individual, not some naive first time tourist. The laws of any land apply the same to everyone. No one is above it, as the Professor found out.

Ianto.W. 22-01-2007 11:15

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
This has got to be an accyweb first four members agreeing, garinda when are you going to change that hideous activar for something a little more attractive, like an Atlanta s**t kicker cop in a bomber jacket.:D

garinda 22-01-2007 11:18

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ianto.W. (Post 372385)
This has got to be an accyweb first four members agreeing, garinda when are you going to change that hideous activar for something a little more attractive, like an Atlanta s**t kicker cop in a bomber jacket.:D

Since it's the atavar that's had the most negative comments, I shall keep it a while longer, if only to unite people.

My little way of bringing peace and harmony to Accy Web.:)

Ianto.W. 22-01-2007 12:12

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 372388)
Since it's the atavar that's had the most negative comments, I shall keep it a while longer, if only to unite people.

My little way of bringing peace and harmony to Accy Web.:)

You are as sadistic as the said Atlanta cop.:D

LancYorkYankee 22-01-2007 16:24

Re: American (Georgian) style policing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ianto.W. (Post 372385)
This has got to be an accyweb first four members agreeing, garinda when are you going to change that hideous activar for something a little more attractive, like an Atlanta s**t kicker cop in a bomber jacket.:D

Make it 5 people agreeing Ian. I still think the cops were the bullying bravado creeps though.

And Nellie Roo Olson . . . . . . .:o


All times are GMT. The time now is 12:29.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1
© 2003-2013 AccringtonWeb.com