![]() |
Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
I was discussing funerals with a colleague the other day when the subject of The Iron Lady came up. It has been reported in the press that when Lady Thatcher dies she will be accorded the honour of a State Funeral which will be conducted at St Paul's Cathedral.
Unusually, when it comes to discussions of Lady Thatcher, we were at variance over the proposals for the funeral. What do members think; is it an honour too far or the appropriate acknowlegement of service to the nation? |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Honour to far, she deserves burning in public.
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Why?
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Did Winston Churchill or any other "great" PM ever get one?
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Why should she get one? She was nothing special, silly cow
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
But for Thatcher, Britain would have had the economy of a banana republic years before Tony and Gordon achieved it
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Winston Churchill had a state funeral in 1965.
Other notable people who were afforded a state funeral were: Viscount Nelson,The Duke of Wellington, William Gladstone, Earl Haigh. Benjamin Disraeli was offered a state funeral, but declined it in his will. Florence Nightingals was also offered a state funeral but declined this honour. So the answer to your question Dianne, is yes...... there have been a few great statesmen who have had state funerals |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
On the whole I do like a good funeral and state occaisions are pretty special. I am just old enough to have reliable memories of Sir Winston Churchill's funeral and pretty spectacular it was too. I think watching it in black and white added something to the occaision.
So Lady Thatcher guided the country for a while, through troubled times, using wit intelligence and energy. For which she was amply rewarded in pecuniary terms and also by being elevated to the nobility. Fair enough. But my mind is continually drawn to those men and women who also serve their country in its hour of need. Who face danger to life and limb on a daily basis. Who forego the joys of family life for extended periods so that we may enjoy our own in freedom and peace. Who, whenever they are required to do so, are willing to give up their own lives and futures without hesitation or complaint. There are also those who survive, but with appalling injuries to mind and body. My question is this: where is the offer of an equal schedule of honours for them? Where is the sad, solemn procession to St Pauls Cathedral for those who die in war? Why does our nation's capital not come to a halt to mark the passage of those who gave not only their time, their wit and intellience, but also their very lives? If every life is unique and every life uniquely valuable, why must the many make do with so little simply because they are the many? It all seems a tad unfair somehow. Perhaps if all those who died in war were accorded the honour of a state funeral then the true cost of war would be brought home more forcibly to those so eager to indulge in it. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
It looks like preparations are underway.
They are even rewriting history to say that the Belgrano was sailing the other way. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Yes, I remember Churchill's funeral... in black and white, as you say. Very moving and solemn. Bet you didn't watch Diana's - I certainly didn't. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Story in the press this morning that the BBC are recording items for Tony Blair's Obituary, do they still hang um for war crimes, or are we not being told something
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
There would be problems with giving Margaret Thatcher a state funeral, because there is such divided opinion about her "achievements" in power.
Yes she took over at a time that the country was on its knees financially, but were her solutions socially fair? I'm sure that there are plenty of ex miners and public sector workers who feel they were made to bear a disproportionate burden of the measures that brought about the economic improvements in the early 1990s. The Loadsamoney culture of the 1980s benefitted only a few, and the disastrous privatisation of the railways and bus services are hardly achievements she can be proud of. And the poll tax was one of the most divisive pieces of legislation in history. Just ask the Scots! By all means mark her passing with the respect it deserves, but keep state funerals for leaders who worked in the interests of EVERYONE. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Does it really matter which way the Belgrano was sailing? We were at war.
It was or could be a threat, to our ships and lads. Why don't we ask those fortunate enough to have survived the HMS Sheffield attack? Or maybe Simon Weston? |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
[quote=gynn;958457
By all means mark her passing with the respect it deserves, but keep state funerals for leaders who worked in the interests of EVERYONE.[/quote] Pray tell, who would you have make the judgement of who receives a state funeral and who doesn't? Would these judges be likely to be 'bought'....by honours,position or money? I am not being fly when I ask this....I am truly interested in who you think would be neutral and unbiased enough to make the decision. (please don't tell me you would allow it to be a public vote.....this would make the honour something like an X factor final) |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Gynn, John Major privatised the Railways in 1993 thru 1997. Maggie opposed the privatisation of British Rail, saying it 'would be waterloo for the government'
Regarding the Council House issue, it can be said it empowers people and gives them aspirations, my Grandpartents bought theirs and in selling it several years later were able to buy a nice bungalow in Birkdale. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Yes they might think someone deserves one, but if it is going to provoke a wave of arguments, bad feeling and even public misbehaviour, they won't do it. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Yes Gynn.....I think you are being naive.
Perhaps the only person who can't be bought is the Monarch.....but then that would perhaps not sit well with those who do not like the Royals. I can't think of anyone I would trust....not someone who wouldn't subvert it for their own purposes......yes, I know....I need to take another anti cynical pill. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
British Pathe - WORLD IN REMEMBRANCE Churchill's funeral boat returns to Thames with £1m price tag | UK news | The Guardian January '65. One in, me. One out, him. Pity I don't believe in reincarnation. It would explain why I'm always giving people a two fingered salute. :rolleyes::D |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
To gauge public opinion. Oh, hang on. You don't believe in them. ;):D |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
on the behalf of anyone who ever had a poll tax bill , was imprisoned for been poor and unable to afford their poll tax bill and also on behalf of those poor children who watched their fathers beaten infront of them in their homes by police on her orders i will gladly burn the bitch alive now for free :D
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
i think it would cost way too much in extra policeing trying to keep it peacefull alone to justify it in these hard times.Although i dont see the point in protesting at someone who is dead there is an element out there that would gladly use her funeral as an excuse to have a ding dong with the police.I dont see the point in inviting trouble the woman was very much a hated and despised person by a lot of people and giving her this unwarranted glorification is just asking for trouble.
Chuck her in a hole and letthe worms have their pound of flesh and be done with it :) if that dosnt sway any die hard tory think of it as denying tony blair a photo opportunity because im pretty sure he will be attending lol |
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
set her on fire and send her down the Ganges
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
ohhh yes it would .....( in panto voice) :D |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
I've just mentioned this thread to my partner who reckons that Whinney Hill tip would be too good for her - I must say I'm inclined to agree.
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Belgrano was heading to the Falklands, secret papers reveal - Telegraph |
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
History of war is written by the winners.:rolleyes:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
we were at war. what would you have done?
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Of course they don't have any hidden agenda's unlike the press, tv and anyone who does not agree with your interesting view of the world. Just so you know Sir Winston Churchill is credited with that. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
I AM SO WITH YOU ON THIS CASHY |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Seems a little harsh to want to do that to a poor little frail old lady.
Sorry, never agreed with her ideals but i don't get this "hatred". To many she was an inspirational woman in her day ,first female PM and I think she wore the pants when she was in office ,not easy back then as it was very much a male dominated world. By the way, has she actually expressed any interest in a State funeral herself? |
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
She and her government introduced the Poll Tax, sold off our nationalised industries, decimated our social housing stock and mining/manufacturing industries, significantly broadened the gap between rich and poor, over three million out of work, increased interest rates, manufactured a war to meet her own ends, I could go on I'm sure.
I certainly wouldn't support a state funeral for her and should we be tempted by a bank holiday I will choose to work instead or do voluntary work. Her party was interested only in keeping down the masses in order that the upper classes could gain more wealth - in my opinion. |
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Margaret Thatcher approves plan for state funeral costing at least £2m Dec 12 2011 By Torcuil Crichton MARGARET THATCHER is said to have approved a blueprint for an eye-wateringly expensive state funeral. The former Tory Prime Minister's plans are said to include similar arrangements to those given to Winston Churchill, including a send-off at St Paul's Cathedral and a concert orchestra playing Land Of Hope And Glory. But the 86-year-old has said that she does not want the public to see her lying in state and does not want a military fly-over at her funeral. The price for a state funeral is likely to run into millions of pounds, with policing such an event costing s2million alone. Thatcher has requested to be buried at the cemetery of the Royal Chelsea Hospital, where her husband Denis, who died in 2003, was laid to rest. Although her health has deteriorated in recent months, plans for the funeral have been ongoing since 2007. Details are set to be discussed this week in a meeting chaired by Cabinet Office minister Francis Maude. Whitehall officials are said to be concerned about the cost of a state funeral and there are fears of a public backlash against the plans from those who view her as a hate figure after the Falklands War and miners strikes of the 80s. Last night, there was already a political outcry at the idea of spending so much on the arrangements. Former MP George Galloway said she should got to an unmarked watery grave after details of plans for the expensive pomp were leaked. He said: "A far better plan would be to for a funeral at sea off the Falklands at a spot where she ordered the sinking of the Belgrano." |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Could we give George Galloway a funeral at sea, he does not need to be dead....
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Come to think of it, Tony Blair was a strong, controversial PM. Had to handle the Diana crisis. Got involved in a couple of neat wars. State funeral for Tony anyone?:rolleyes: Now, or later:D |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
when tony blair dies they are having a seperate funeral for his smug smile
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
quote,,,,,But the 86-year-old has said that she does not want the public to see her lying in state at her funeral.,,,,,unquote
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, Shes probably scared to think how many people would spit on her coffin, I would. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Methinks that the Great British Public will be unable to achieve the degree of solemnity and tearfulness required for a State Funeral. Maybe the government could hire a few thousand North Koreans.:D
Apart from Mrs. Thatcher, has anyone given any thought to any particular piece of music that would be appropriate for the occasion:rolleyes: |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
ding dong the witch is dead - Bing Video# |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
did santa bring you those stilts you wanted ? :D |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
played twinkle in our school play which i dont recall been an official dwarf but according to the little song and dance i had to do he was teh more hyperactive of teh bunch :D |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
As sung by the good Lady herself -what could be more fitting than the Grantham Anthem?
Spitting Image - Granthem Anthem - YouTube :D |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Are there any incriminating photos I wonder? Were you wearing a pink Tutu and gossamer wings? |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
my small part in the play got the biggest laugh :(:) |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Karma to you for this one -a real laugh out loud moment -can't stop!!! Thank-you;):D Sorry - am hysterical. It's just that i called you Twinkie - should have dropped the "T" perhaps! |
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
And I do realise that a lot of people other than the upper classes vote Tory, although I personally completely fail to understand why, but I don't think we have a credible alternative at the moment. Anyway we're all entitled to our own opinions and to vote for who we want, my main problem is with Mrs. Thatcher, I don't mind Mr. Cameron quite so much and I do agree with one or two of the current policies, the thought of him doesn't make my blood boil like the thought of Maggie does! |
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
I think we need to agree to differ here Jaysay, I'm coming across as a far left wing socialist which I can assure you I'm not!
But I stand by my comments about Margaret Thatcher and her government. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Now please.......and don't be offering to dirty the clayton cut....I live right next to it....don't want such unpalatable debris floating about on the top, thanks!
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
An aside: when I was at the University of Saskatchewan the authorities had problems with John Diefenbaker's grave on campus. Seems like after the usually friday nite beer fest at the Louis Riel pub, students were performing minor desecrations on his grave. I think that urinating, defecating, and vomiting sums it up;):D They moved his mortal remains to a resting place in a more right-wing, red neck area.:cool: |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
hang on the river stink has been known by a different name ?
I wasnt aware they cleaned it up i thought they just relocated the sewage pipe lol |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
"The Queen had decided in 1963 - when Churchill was already too ill to attend the ceremony where President John F Kennedy made him the first honorary citizen of the United States - that it would be a state funeral, the most spectacular since the Duke of Wellington's more than a century earlier." Who has decided now that Lady Thatcher should have a State funeral -is it still The Queen's choice or is it in the hands of politicians? I would love to have been a fly on the wall back in their weekly meetings, somehow I can't imagine them getting on:rolleyes: |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
looks like they are trying to soften the public up to the idea of this farce
a document has just been released showing she insisted on paying for her own ironing board at number 10 to keep costs down what a heroine she was :rolleyes: Quote:
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
I see they are trying to propose an Austerity-Olympics - don't think it will take off as the Nation is too used to the spend-spend-spend/ think about paying later mentality.:rolleyes: |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Just listened to a discussion on Radio 2.
Seems the T.U.C. at their conference, are allowing party packs and T-shirts to be sold for the inevitable death of Margaret Thatcher. The party packs are labelled 'Ding, Dong, Thatcher's Gone', and contain party poppers, balloons and other celebratory items for when she has passed away. T-shirts emblazoned with 'Hey Ho, The Witch is Dead.'' No matter what your opinion of this lady is, I find this pretty disgraceful and obscene. Sadly, they are selling quite well. :( |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
No doubt they will be removed shortly and some embarassed official will say it was never endorsed by the TUC.
I fear all pretence at respect for others has now gone in the general spreading of bad-taste which seems to be a feature of western living since it began to follow the American dream...:rolleyes: |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
I wasn't commenting on her past actions, just the actions that some British people intend to carry out after her demise. Pretty sickening. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
I'm with you Kate.
To celebrate the death of a person shows how far this country has fallen. Tactless, tasteless and moronic. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
A democratically elected leader, who followed her own path, irrelevant of policy, one of the greatest leaders this county has seen, remember in the 70,s we were a washed up has been of a country, she put us back on world stage!
I protested against thatcher when she was in power, I met her once. But I too will shed a tear for the iron lady, and agree with those who find it sad that some would celebrate. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
I'm not sure how I feel on this one. I cannot help but consider Thatcherism to be the instigator of the "Greed is Good" mentality which is at the root of the country's descent into it's current state. On the other hand to celebrate someone's death seems somewhat tasteless.
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
But- the incompetent management deserved it, the militant union leaders deserved it(a strike nearly every week),just a shame thousands of workers had to take the pain. Quote:
After her no leader or party has had the courage to have that sort of forward plan or to push it through and what has happened-we've slowly gone under! |
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
If we had operated such a system in the Fire Brigade, no fires would have been put out, no lives saved, the man who operates the hydrant key is off sick. I was a union official in the Fire Brigade Union, there was alway crap coming from the head office, via the district representative with orders sell it to your members, my responce was you lot dreamt it up you sell it to the members. As for pay rises whilst serving in the F.B., the Labour lot were the most difficult to deal with, always looking for ways to change our conditions of service, 3 half crowns or we change the shift system. We always fared better when the tories were in power. Let hope the unions don't go back to running the country again. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
as for one who was jailed because i could not afford to pay my poll tax,i spent 6 weeks in prison,not a police station nick and lost my home when i came out,she deserves nothing she was a self righteous pompous egostistical warmonger,who brought this country to its knees and devastsated the mining community and the coal industry and put thousands out of work,(see the film BRASSED OFF )she made families split up because of money problems and divided families over whether to break the miners strike and be a scvab
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
No doubt folks will show up in their thousands for her funeral. As Red Skelton said of the well-attended funeral of L. B. Mayer: "Give the people what they want, and they'll come out for it.";)
|
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
I thought the Poll Tax was an unfair system too, however, never considered the Rates to be fair either. I was a divorced single parent with a young child, living in close proximity in identical property, to larger families with grown up children, but paying the same amount. Hardly fair .... suppose I should have rioted or refused payment too. |
Re: Oooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
|
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Hate what she did, if you must, as I certainly did. Not the woman herself. It's not usually how the British behave. It's the sort of manic, effigy burning, giddy hysteria you usually see on the news, when some tin pot dictator's been overthrown, somewhere hot. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
I've no problem with it, it's what she encouraged, do away with our own Manufacturers turn the Country into a service only industry with the odd few making a bit of extra cash from re-packaging and re-distributing cheap Chinese imports, for once I think she'd be proud of the T.U.C.
All is going according to her long term plan. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Your view, and of course you are entitled to it. Just as you were when you shared your thoughts on Michael Jackson's death. Quote:
It's sad when anyone dies. Thatcher's children, and grandchildren will miss her. There's probably someone, somewhere, who'll miss you when you pop your clogs. |
Re: Ooooh, I like a good funeral.
Quote:
Twisted. Thank you. Never thought she might be pleased that her death's being turned into a fine example of free market enterprise, and might very well be a nice little boost to the economy. :rolleyes::p |
All times are GMT. The time now is 11:41. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1
© 2003-2013 AccringtonWeb.com