Greatest American musician(s)??
 

Who's it gonna be? Dylan, Cash or Presley??

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

Now this I find difficult, I like them all………The problem with this choice is that they are all the same in the cultural context of there musical background, but play, sound and resonate differently to their followers…..Bu**er I what to say Johnny cash, I hear Dylan in my mind and Elvis Presley “I met is Cousin three weeks ago” was at the top of is particular brand of music…….

It’s Johnny cash, No it’s Dylan……… Sorry folks it is Johnny Cash. I hope that didn’t “Hurt”

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

psst (hurt is a nine inch nails song covered by cash)

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

I refer you to my previous post else where on this forum..........

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

who the do you think you are?
referring me 'elsewhere'
pull yer head out of yer own jacksy and smell the coffee

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

Yes woody, its rich roast actually…………..:)

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

Woody, I realise you've arrived on this site and you want to make an impression but to stick around you're really going to have to learn to appreciate irony!

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

i dont have to prove anything to you , and i am most certainly not 'out to stay around'
i will say what i want - you say what you want, and we'll get along fine - just dont compare Cliff to The Beatles again :)haha

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

i have voted for elvis ...the one and only king...
but hey,, i loved the man in black.. with his sexy ,sultry .voice ..
dillon is just average in my opinion

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

i think rock n roll would be lyrically lost if Dylan wasnt on the scene - he definately aint the best musician but his lyrics are unrivalled in my opinion

...just listen to his first album; 'Song to Woody', :D

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

voted for elvis - but dylans the man for a differant sphere,saw him in the late 60s,brilliant artist, but not everyones looking for a message with their music.

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

johnny cash a definite for me .............not an elvis fan never was, & i like some of bob dylans music/songs too

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

WANTED: MORE DYLAN FANS!!!!



(cash was a legend though, always will be, RIP man in black!)

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

I voted Elvis. No hesitation.
I do like Johnny Cash though.
Woody Cliff is every bit has good has the Beatles.
Elvis No 1 Singer.
Beatles No 1 Band.
Cliff Richard up there with Elvis.

Re: Greatest American musician(s)??
 

....in your opinion.....