Accrington Web

Accrington Web (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/index.php)
-   Music, Bands, Noise! (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/f92/)
-   -   Punk heralded the death of pop (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/f92/punk-heralded-the-death-of-pop-60367.html)

mobertol 25-02-2012 11:01

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Another which stands the test of time -love his blue nail varnish too, he has lovely hands.
"Deperir a gris":D

Visage - Fade To Grey - YouTube

garinda 25-02-2012 15:49

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 972651)
Another which stands the test of time -love his blue nail varnish too, he has lovely hands.
"Deperir a gris":D

Visage - Fade To Grey - YouTube

Good video.

I know the girl who was in it with him, Princess Julia. Not really a princess, and now a successful DJ.

Steve Strange played Macmillian's in Liverpool, when the hits had dried up.

He was dreadful, and didn't get much appreciation.

:D

jaysay 26-02-2012 10:24

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 972760)
Good video.

I know the girl who was in it with him, Princess Julia. Not really a princess, and now a successful DJ.

Steve Strange played Macmillian's in Liverpool, when the hits had dried up.

He was dreadful, and didn't get much appreciation.

:D

That Steve Strange were such an odd bloke:D

mobertol 02-03-2012 20:03

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Sweet Dreams x

Eurythmics - Sweet Dreams (Are Made Of This) - YouTube
:D

kestrelx 02-03-2012 21:52

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 974460)
Sweet Dreams x

Eurythmics started off as punks.:mad::rolleyes:

Saw "Saturday Night Fever" the other night it's a good film, the music was around in 77 - so who asked this dumb question in the first place?

Saturday Night Fever (1977) Trailer - YouTube

Michael1954 02-03-2012 21:57

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 974490)
Eurythmics started off as punks.:mad::rolleyes:

Did they? I bought their first few albums and I don't hear any punk influences. Do you mean when they were the Tourists?

kestrelx 02-03-2012 22:00

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael1954 (Post 974491)
Did they? I bought their first few albums and I don't hear any punk influences. Do you mean when they were the Tourists?

They were originally called The Catch a punk band which evolved into The Tourists! ;) Then the Eurythmics!

Michael1954 02-03-2012 22:02

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 974490)
so who asked this dumb question in the first place

It was davebtelford, who seems to have disappeared. You're not to blame this time!

Michael1954 02-03-2012 22:04

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 974494)
They were originally called The Catch a punk band which evolved into The Tourists! ;) Then the Eurythmics!

Ah, I never knew that. I can't imagine Annie Lennox gobbing at the audience!

annesingleton 02-03-2012 22:32

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Siouxsie & The Banshees / Robert Smith - Love In A Void - YouTube
Sorry this is my new toy - The wonderful Robert Smith with Siouxie

annesingleton 02-03-2012 22:35

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Or should I have said Siouxie with the wonderful Robert Smith? But look at her fantastic 80's style!

Michael1954 02-03-2012 22:39

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Here's a challenge for you, Anne. Can you attach her version of Dear Prudence please.

Michael1954 02-03-2012 22:40

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
I come on here on my mobile phone so I can't figure out if I can attach You Tube clips.

annesingleton 02-03-2012 23:04

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael1954 (Post 974507)
Here's a challenge for you, Anne. Can you attach her version of Dear Prudence please.

I'll try but I am a novice at this!

annesingleton 02-03-2012 23:06

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael1954 (Post 974508)
I come on here on my mobile phone so I can't figure out if I can attach You Tube clips.



Siouxsie & the Banshees - Dear Prudence (HQ) - YouTube
Here you go!

Michael1954 02-03-2012 23:12

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Great! You've got the job, Anne!

annesingleton 02-03-2012 23:26

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Thank you! Now I know how to do it there'll be no stopping me, I'm going to bore everyone stupid - just blame Garinda for being such a good teacher!

garinda 02-03-2012 23:37

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael1954 (Post 974491)
Did they? I bought their first few albums and I don't hear any punk influences. Do you mean when they were the Tourists?

You're right to question the statement, because it's wrong.

Pre-Eurythmics Annie Lennox, and Dave Stewart were in the pop band The Tourists.

Whose musical roots were in folk rock.

About as punk as Pickettywitch.

:rolleyes:

garinda 02-03-2012 23:40

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Pre-Tourists, Annie Lennox was in the group Dragon's Playground.

Who appeared on ITV's New Faces.

Very punk.

:rofl38::rofl38::rofl38:

garinda 02-03-2012 23:51

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 974494)
They were originally called The Catch a punk band which evolved into The Tourists! ;) Then the Eurythmics!

Original recording of The Catch's one and only single, in 1977.

The Catch - Borderline - YouTube

Borderline / Black Blood (The Catch)

Much more The Spinners.

Than The Slits.

Punk my arse.

:rofl38::rofl38::rofl38:

mobertol 03-03-2012 07:36

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael1954 (Post 974499)
Ah, I never knew that. I can't imagine Annie Lennox gobbing at the audience!

When I saw her in the Student's union in L'pool in '83 the only thing that left her body and went into the audience was her bra!:eek::D Think they were still the Tourists then...Great voice.

jaysay 03-03-2012 08:53

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by annesingleton (Post 974523)
Thank you! Now I know how to do it there'll be no stopping me, I'm going to bore everyone stupid - just blame Garinda for being such a good teacher!

Ya I once remember Wynonne showing somebody how to put YouTube links on here, nobody as ever forgiven him:D:D:D

jaysay 03-03-2012 08:54

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 974525)
You're right to question the statement, because it's wrong.

Pre-Eurythmics Annie Lennox, and Dave Stewart were in the pop band The Tourists.

Whose musical roots were in folk rock.

About as punk as Pickettywitch.

:rolleyes:

Ya I think Dave Stewart would be most peeved if he knew some people thought his musical roots were in Punk:rolleyes::D

garinda 03-03-2012 13:52

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 974543)
When I saw her in the Student's union in L'pool in '83 the only thing that left her body and went into the audience was her bra!:eek::D Think they were still the Tourists then...Great voice.

I was at that gig.

It was the Eurythmics.

You could have been rubbing yourself up against me, never knowing who I was.

Small world.

;)

mobertol 03-03-2012 15:19

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 974658)
I was at that gig.

It was the Eurythmics.

You could have been rubbing yourself up against me, never knowing who I was.

Small world.

;)

How very dare you suggest such a thing.

I would have remembered I'm sure in any case...

Unless you were the tall, golden boy with the colgate smile?;):D
Colgate anniversary Ad - YouTube

garinda 03-03-2012 15:21

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 974681)
How very dare you suggest such a thing.

I would have remembered I'm sure in any case...

Unless you were the tall, golden boy with the colgate smile?;):D
Colgate anniversary Ad - YouTube

My 'ring of confidence' is always a dead give away.

;):D

kestrelx 03-03-2012 16:49

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 974526)
Pre-Tourists, Annie Lennox was in the group Dragon's Playground.

Who appeared on ITV's New Faces.

Very punk.

:rofl38::rofl38::rofl38:

Who cares....

Toyah was a punk!!! :mosher:

Toyah - It's A Mystery - YouTube

The issue is that Punk was POP! So how could it replace it???

kestrelx 03-03-2012 16:58

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaysay (Post 974565)
Ya I think Dave Stewart would be most peeved if he knew some people thought his musical roots were in Punk:rolleyes::D

Dave Stewart suffers from Paradise Syndrome;
Paradise Syndrome - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
which is when you feel unhappy and depressed even when you've achieved all your dreams and made loads of money - so I don't think he'd give a toss about being called a punk! :)

annesingleton 03-03-2012 17:17

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaysay (Post 974565)
Ya I think Dave Stewart would be most peeved if he knew some people thought his musical roots were in Punk:rolleyes::D

Sorry, I'll try to control myself! (But I do have very eclectic tastes in music.....!)

annesingleton 03-03-2012 17:18

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaysay (Post 974563)
Ya I once remember Wynonne showing somebody how to put YouTube links on here, nobody as ever forgiven him:D:D:D

Sorry again, wrong quote above - I really am rubbish at this!

DaveinGermany 03-03-2012 17:20

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 974701)
I don't think he'd give a toss about being called a punk! :)

Think he would if it was Harry Callahan doing the calling :D

"Go ahead Punk ! Make my day !" ;)

mobertol 03-03-2012 20:02

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Was never a fan of hers but the early arrival of spring has me thinking of summer:D

Toyah Willcox - Echo Beach - YouTube

walkinman221 03-03-2012 20:06

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Martha & The Muffins - Echo Beach [totp2] - YouTube
Sorry di but this is better

walkinman221 03-03-2012 20:09

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
The Undertones-Teenage Kicks - YouTube
Love this track

walkinman221 03-03-2012 20:13

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
A guilty pleasure don't tell wynonie
Wheatus - Teenage Dirtbag - YouTube

kestrelx 03-03-2012 20:19

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 974776)
Was never a fan of hers but the early arrival of spring has me thinking of summer:D

"It's a Mystery" is a classic pop song don't ya think?:rolleyes:

kestrelx 03-03-2012 20:21

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by walkinman221 (Post 974783)
A guilty pleasure don't tell wynonie

Nirvana - Smells Like Teen Spirit - YouTube

This is a classic piece of "grunge punk" !

SMELLS LIKE PUNK SPIRIT!

garinda 03-03-2012 21:17

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 974699)
Who cares....

We don't.

We expect you to be wrong.

Why don't you pop some middle of the road pap on, and have a little pogo?

Try Manhattan Transfer.

Now they really were hard core punk rockers.

jaysay 04-03-2012 09:48

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 974816)
We don't.

We expect you to be wrong.

Why don't you pop some middle of the road pap on, and have a little pogo?

Try Manhattan Transfer.

Now they really were hard core punk rockers.

Ya can imagine doing the Pogo to that little number Rindi:D:D

kestrelx 07-03-2012 14:44

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 974816)
We don't.

We expect you to be wrong.

Why don't you pop some middle of the road pap on, and have a little pogo?

Try Manhattan Transfer.

Now they really were hard core punk rockers.

"WE" is the word , i,e you and you side kicks your "Accy web mafia" to quote Tommiasfc, - you are always making nice little bitchy comments! Go Bitch somewhere else! :cool:

jaysay 07-03-2012 17:50

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 975897)
"WE" is the word , i,e you and you side kicks your "Accy web mafia" to quote Tommiasfc, - you are always making nice little bitchy comments! Go Bitch somewhere else! :cool:

Twas you who said they were leaving, when you do decide to go please close the door quietly on your way out:cool:

kestrelx 07-03-2012 20:22

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 974816)
We don't.

We expect you to be wrong.

Why don't you pop some middle of the road pap on, and have a little pogo?

Try Manhattan Transfer.

Now they really were hard core punk rockers.

White Dopes on Punk...

The Tubes White Punks live 1982 - YouTube

Just for you Rindi! ;)

kestrelx 09-03-2012 16:48

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 971912)
Probably thought "if they can get away with playing that, you can get away with anything":rolleyes:

As to the Police - cream always floats to the top!:D

Rave band the Prodigy had 2 number one records in the 90's with Punk influenced songs and still pack out festivals with fans...


The Prodigy - Breathe - YouTube

So don't tell me Punk died out! :mosher:

mobertol 09-03-2012 18:42

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
I like this one of theirs but its not just Punk is it?

The Prodigy - Firestarter - YouTube

Has some element of dance:D...and is more original.

mobertol 09-03-2012 18:57

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Howard Jones "What is Love" - YouTube

Much prefer these given a choice...

Howard Jones - Like To Get To Know You Well - YouTube

This one is a great video.

jaysay 09-03-2012 19:04

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 976409)
Howard Jones "What is Love" - YouTube

Much prefer these given a choice...

Howard Jones - Like To Get To Know You Well - YouTube

This one is a great video.

A slightly older Howard Jones was on Breakfast TV yesterday mobertol:rolleyes:

mobertol 09-03-2012 20:28

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaysay (Post 976410)
A slightly older Howard Jones was on Breakfast TV yesterday mobertol:rolleyes:

Think I heard he now runs a gym or something similar in London...

Liked his songs -really bring back a certain time of life for me..:)

kestrelx 10-03-2012 19:54

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 976406)
I like this one of theirs but its not just Punk is it?



Has some element of dance:D...and is more original.

But have you noticed that Sex Pistols vocal bit?


green day - american idiot - YouTube

Also Greenday had a lot of hits more recent with a punk sound! Sold 65 Million records apparently!

Boeing Guy 10-03-2012 20:44

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 976725)
Also Greenday had a lot of hits more recent with a punk sound! Sold 65 Million records apparently!

So they are in good company, they have sold more than Johnny Cash, 1 million more than Lady Gaga, the same amount of Village People, very punk!
10 Million less than Journey, 35 million less than Dolly Parton, The Who, Paul Maccartney (solo) Janet Jackson! Britney Spears!
It gets better, 65 million less than Backstreet Boys!! :eek:Or even Genesis, so I will not need to throw away Foxtrot just yet:cool:

135 million less than Celine Dion or Mariah Carey! Or even my beloved Pink Floyd.
Abba sold between 200 and 300million, right when Punk was at its highest:D

Finally The Beatles and Elvis, 1 Billion records.
Who said pop music was dead!:eek::eek:

mobertol 10-03-2012 21:48

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Boeing Guy (Post 976737)
So they are in good company, they have sold more than Johnny Cash, 1 million more than Lady Gaga, the same amount of Village People, very punk!
10 Million less than Journey, 35 million less than Dolly Parton, The Who, Paul Maccartney (solo) Janet Jackson! Britney Spears!
It gets better, 65 million less than Backstreet Boys!! :eek:Or even Genesis, so I will not need to throw away Foxtrot just yet:cool:

135 million less than Celine Dion or Mariah Carey! Or even my beloved Pink Floyd.
Abba sold between 200 and 300million, right when Punk was at its highest:D

Finally The Beatles and Elvis, 1 Billion records.
Who said pop music was dead!:eek::eek:

Hope you don't Google all these numbers while doing important things in the cockpit:eek:
I will be flying shortly -hope you can put my mind at rest...:rolleyes::)

PS Why is it called a "cockpit" ?

Boeing Guy 10-03-2012 21:54

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
No luck there, I'm at home at the moment!
Your flight will be okay, it's by far the safest form of transport.

However, I could tell you why we call it a cockpit........ But then I would have o turn into Captain Oveur from Airplane!!!

mobertol 10-03-2012 22:17

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Sounds exotic...do tell!

Haven't booked yet, will probably have to go to Tenerife first, then on to the good old UK.

Don't suppose you could stop off and pick me up on your way home!;):D

jaysay 11-03-2012 09:17

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 976427)
Think I heard he now runs a gym or something similar in London...

Liked his songs -really bring back a certain time of life for me..:)

He's actually still heavily into the music industry modertol

mobertol 11-03-2012 09:27

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaysay (Post 976814)
He's actually still heavily into the music industry modertol

Love it when you call me MoDertol, Jay. For some reason has me thinking of Gargling -Dettol?! Must go for a neurological check-up -I worry sometimes how my mind works:D (Have had a CAT scan and there is a brain in there!)

jaysay 11-03-2012 10:11

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 976824)
Love it when you call me MoDertol, Jay. For some reason has me thinking of Gargling -Dettol?! Must go for a neurological check-up -I worry sometimes how my mind works:D (Have had a CAT scan and there is a brain in there!)

Would you be so kind and publish that evidence:D

kestrelx 11-03-2012 14:02

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Boeing Guy (Post 976737)
So they are in good company, they have sold more than Johnny Cash, 1 million more than Lady Gaga, the same amount of Village People, very punk!
10 Million less than Journey, 35 million less than Dolly Parton, The Who, Paul Maccartney (solo) Janet Jackson! Britney Spears!
It gets better, 65 million less than Backstreet Boys!! :eek:Or even Genesis, so I will not need to throw away Foxtrot just yet:cool:

135 million less than Celine Dion or Mariah Carey! Or even my beloved Pink Floyd.
Abba sold between 200 and 300million, right when Punk was at its highest:D

Finally The Beatles and Elvis, 1 Billion records.
Who said pop music was dead!:eek::eek:

Opps I wasn't challenging your EGO! How many wasn't the issue mate!

I was clearly stating that a band playing punk in the Mid- noughties (or first 10 years of the 21st Century) were selling a lot of records!


But thanks for doing the research!!! :D
PS I note you say your beloved Pink Floyd, may I point out - a band who were inspired by LSD and Cannabis! :eek: :do-one:

Margaret Pilkington 11-03-2012 14:53

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
do you have to drag your drug theme into every post? (I wish you would find another fiddle to play on).
It is not relevant. I like Pink Floyd too...it was my era...that does not mean that I condone the use of illegal drugs.......where they got their creative drive did not interest me than and it doesn't now.

jaysay 11-03-2012 18:21

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 976910)
Opps I wasn't challenging your EGO! How many wasn't the issue mate!

I was clearly stating that a band playing punk in the Mid- noughties (or first 10 years of the 21st Century) were selling a lot of records!


But thanks for doing the research!!! :D
PS I note you say your beloved Pink Floyd, may I point out - a band who were inspired by LSD and Cannabis! :eek: :do-one:

Why don't you just sod off and take your love of drugs with you, your just brain addled moron

kestrelx 12-03-2012 11:45

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaysay (Post 977004)
Why don't you just sod off and take your love of drugs with you, your just brain addled moron

What :confused: Can't you take the truth? Pink Floyd were inspired by LSD and encouraged others to take it buy their type of music - this is fact - not fiction. :rolleyes:

Pink Floyd - See Emily Play#

Sid Barrett wrote this track.:hothothot

cashman 12-03-2012 14:34

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Its a great track, but Syd was hospitalised in 68 with reports of mental illness, coupled wi drug addiction, so he aint exactly a great argument fer yer cause.:rolleyes:http://www.guardian.co.uk/culture/20...oyd.popandrock

kestrelx 12-03-2012 15:36

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cashman (Post 977218)
Its a great track, but Syd was hospitalised in 68 with reports of mental illness, coupled wi drug addiction, so he aint exactly a great argument fer yer cause.:rolleyes:Syd Barrett dies aged 60 | Culture | guardian.co.uk

No, the issue here is not that LSD is good, but that it was a major influence on Pink Floyds music - come on you can't deny that their music is Trip music! :alright:

kestrelx 12-03-2012 15:47

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda (Post 974816)
We don't.

We expect you to be wrong.

Why don't you pop some middle of the road pap on, and have a little pogo?

Try Manhattan Transfer.

Now they really were hard core punk rockers.

What an horrible world! :eek:

Joey Ramone - What a Wonderful World - YouTube

Joey Ramone recorded this track a few weeks before he died, apparently and now is being used in the TV ad for Thomas Cook!

Boeing Guy 12-03-2012 16:56

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 977224)
No, the issue here is not that LSD is good, but that it was a major influence on Pink Floyds music - come on you can't deny that their music is Trip music! :alright:

The same could be said of any psychedelic, new age, prog rock music. Have you listened to The Yes Album? Or Foxtrot by Genesis?


I have never abused any drug, legal or otherwise, yet I am a huge Pink Floyd fan as well as prog rock and find Sgt Peppers lonely hearts club band one of the finest albums of all time. Yet I do not feel the need to be stoned or high on drugs to enjoy them.

Just because a musician took drugs, is not a endorsement of them.
In fact David Gilmour did take cocaine during his divorce with then wife Ginger, he refers to the "usual rock star coke lifestyle"

And I quote from another website here:
I must say, Gilmour nails it on the head with one line, and this is a direct quote....."It's a drug that does nothing for anyone." True words, those! Actually it turns people into shells of people. It has the ability to deceive it's user, building up false confidence, "allowing" them to become more talkative and all the rest. "It left me with a prematurely aged heart", was another comment Gilmour made on the subject.

So back to the subject matter, Punk did not kill off Pop music, end of:cool:

Boeing Guy 12-03-2012 17:02

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 976910)
Opps I wasn't challenging your EGO! How many wasn't the issue mate!

As Zaphod Beeblebrox once said “If there's anything more important than my ego around, I want it caught and shot now.”:eek:

jaysay 12-03-2012 17:43

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 977224)
No, the issue here is not that LSD is good, but that it was a major influence on Pink Floyds music - come on you can't deny that their music is Trip music! :alright:

And the Lord said let there be light and there was light and it shone for miles:rolleyes:

kestrelx 12-03-2012 19:20

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Boeing Guy (Post 977233)
The same could be said of any psychedelic, new age, prog rock music. Have you listened to The Yes Album? Or Foxtrot by Genesis?


I have never abused any drug, legal or otherwise, yet I am a huge Pink Floyd fan as well as prog rock and find Sgt Peppers lonely hearts club band one of the finest albums of all time. Yet I do not feel the need to be stoned or high on drugs to enjoy them.

Just because a musician took drugs, is not a endorsement of them.
In fact David Gilmour did take cocaine during his divorce with then wife Ginger, he refers to the "usual rock star coke lifestyle"

And I quote from another website here:
I must say, Gilmour nails it on the head with one line, and this is a direct quote....."It's a drug that does nothing for anyone." True words, those! Actually it turns people into shells of people. It has the ability to deceive it's user, building up false confidence, "allowing" them to become more talkative and all the rest. "It left me with a prematurely aged heart", was another comment Gilmour made on the subject.

So back to the subject matter, Punk did not kill off Pop music, end of:cool:

Well a lot of these bands may have only taken LSD once or twice but after that if you carry on smoking dope it can bring back the acid effect, so that explains why they carried on making that kind of music.

Regardless the issue is "would Floyd, Yes, Genesis and all the others made that kind of music without LSD?" Because it all came out of the Psychedelic scene which was based on LSD.

Drugs uncovered: The link between drugs and music | Society | The Observer

Cocaine and LSD are 2 totally different drugs. Funny how it took Dave Gilmour ex amount of money spent on Cocaine to come to those conclusions.

No Punk did not Kill off pop music I don't think it aimed to!

Have you seen this TV advert with Joey Ramones track - up your street as it's for holidays...

It is a wonderful world - Thomas Cook advert March 2012 - YouTube

mobertol 12-03-2012 20:10

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Ahhhh...some New Wave! being a Simple Mind myself...
Just in case anyone was forgetting about me;)
Simple Minds - Don't You (Forget About Me) - YouTube

Saw them by chance at a little music festival in Chateaux Arnoux in Provence in 1998 -fab concert, Jim's hair was much shorter, met them after in the village -really nice folks.

kestrelx 20-03-2012 19:24

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 977321)
Ahhhh...some New Wave! being a Simple Mind myself...
Just in case anyone was forgetting about me;)
Simple Minds - Don't You (Forget About Me) - YouTube[/URL]

Saw them by chance at a little music festival in Chateaux Arnoux in Provence in 1998 -fab concert, Jim's hair was much shorter, met them after in the village -really nice folks.

Simple Minds aren't new wave they are more like Nu Romantics! Then became rock :rolleyes:

mobertol 22-03-2012 20:57

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 979076)
Simple Minds aren't new wave they are more like Nu Romantics! Then became rock :rolleyes:

Split all the hairs you want...New this or that..:D

Ultravox - Vienna - Live 1983 - YouTube

Ahhhhhh! Vienna!

kestrelx 22-03-2012 23:05

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 979397)
Split all the hairs you want...New this or that..:D



Ahhhhhh! Vienna!

Have you heard this? A "new - wave" band from Accy! :alright:


cybermen - wheres the new wave - YouTube

kestrelx 01-05-2012 23:25

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
punk 76 - YouTube

mobertol 02-05-2012 13:32

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Interesting film -isn't it funny how time and distance make something which was seen as shocking and threatening now seem faintly laughable.

Glad I never donned the safety pins and chains myself - might have ended up like the two "old" punks who feature at the end:rolleyes:

They just about prove that punk is, if not dead, then not "wearing well with age"!

Whereas pop lives on..
Scritti Politti - Wood Beez (pray llike Aretha Franklin) Top Of The Pops 1984 - YouTube

Another favourite of mine, the dress over trousers is still fashionable and I love the earrings:D

kestrelx 06-05-2012 18:46

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 988828)
Interesting film -isn't it funny how time and distance make something which was seen as shocking and threatening now seem faintly laughable.

Glad I never donned the safety pins and chains myself - might have ended up like the two "old" punks who feature at the end:rolleyes:

They just about prove that punk is, if not dead, then not "wearing well with age"!

Whereas pop lives on..

Another favourite of mine, the dress over trousers is still fashionable and I love the earrings:D

Everybody gets old. Look at Maggie Thatcher - a shadow of what she was and it happens to everybody. Punk was a reaction and a statement against the system - today Pop music is part of the system. People like Bob Geldof and Paul Morley say that pop music doesn't have a cause any more it's basically just entertainment. Punk was more than entertainment. One thing that changed with punk is that people started singing about things that weren't sung about before, such as basic issues of life, being unemployed, politics, bodily functions and so on - subjects that hadn't been sung about before. Punk had it's own films...

Jubilee Derek Jarman (1978) - YouTube

Punk lives on as much as Scritti Politti does. Most of the music in the chart today is not like punk or Scritti Politti! But the attitude of punk can be seen in some people take singer Pink also Amy Winehouse had a punk attitude. So the pop of today is not the pop of yesterday.

mobertol 06-05-2012 19:35

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
I don't follow the charts these days -can't stand commercial radio stations with all the useless banter and the same songs being played over and over.

jaysay 07-05-2012 08:45

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 990087)
I don't follow the charts these days -can't stand commercial radio stations with all the useless banter and the same songs being played over and over.

Its a pity you can't get Vintage TV CHANNEL 369 on Sky mobertol, its great for 50s 60s 70s 80s music, its on all the time in my gaff, its like a backdrop to AccyWeb:D

mobertol 07-05-2012 11:26

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jaysay (Post 990185)
Its a pity you can't get Vintage TV CHANNEL 369 on Sky mobertol, its great for 50s 60s 70s 80s music, its on all the time in my gaff, its like a backdrop to AccyWeb:D

The channels are different over here Jay but I do put on 1980's music on 701 at SKY! It's amazing how many songs you forget about but when you hear them again, for the first time in years, you immediately remember all the words.:D

Heard this again the other day which we used to love back whenever!

Definitely different but somehow not as good as i remember:o:D

Gary Numan - Are 'Friends' Electric? - YouTube

mobertol 09-05-2012 13:26

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Modern pop, been listening to this a lot lately - love this song it has a particular atosphere to it and Gotye and Kimbra both have good voices,the video is really very clever too!
Gotye - Somebody That I Used To Know (feat. Kimbra) - official video - YouTube

:D

kestrelx 09-05-2012 14:08

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 990087)
I don't follow the charts these days -can't stand commercial radio stations with all the useless banter and the same songs being played over and over.

I occasionally listen to it, I think it's much more uniform these days; that is there are strict standards of "cool" to get in the chart, you'd never get a Worzels type record in the chart these days because they are all to busy being hip and trendy.:cool: Not that I'd want a Worzels type record in the chart! :rolleyes:

Restless 09-05-2012 20:50

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
I absolutely hate the link between LSD and Pink Floyd. I was often told "you have to listen to this on acid"

I would rather (back then)take LSD and bash my head against a wall that listen that rubbish.

Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 977224)
No, the issue here is not that LSD is good, but that it was a major influence on Pink Floyds music - come on you can't deny that their music is Trip music! :alright:


Mancie 09-05-2012 21:19

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Was just thinking tunes like Mobertol's Gary Numan tune was 1979.. don't think it can be classed as punk.. no way punk killed pop.

Claytoner40 09-05-2012 21:23

Punk augmented some pop? Some pop is total crap though. Punk circa 1976 changed music forever

Mancie 09-05-2012 21:39

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Claytoner40 (Post 990834)
Punk augmented some pop? Some pop is total crap though. Punk circa 1976 changed music forever

Let's face it punk was crap..it did pave the way for some good "new wave" music in the UK that was good.. but at they end of the day chart music is "pop"

Claytoner40 09-05-2012 21:41

Got to disagree. Clash, Sex Pistols, Stiff Little Fingers, Buzzcocks and Damned were brilliant.

Mancie 09-05-2012 21:56

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Claytoner40 (Post 990838)
Got to disagree. Clash, Sex Pistols, Stiff Little Fingers, Buzzcocks and Damned were brilliant.

Yes of course.. but most of them ended up making pop songs.:)

Claytoner40 09-05-2012 22:01

Unfortunately I can't disagree there apart from maybe SLF.

Mancie 09-05-2012 22:07

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 977321)
Ahhhh...some New Wave! being a Simple Mind

Reckon this is as close as Simple Minds got to New Wave

Simple Minds - Sweat In Bullet - YouTube

Restless 09-05-2012 23:28

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Well UK punk left something to be desired.... US hardcore punk... hmm now some of those guys did great songs. Don't like many but I love Angry Samoans 'back to Samoa' album

Mancie 10-05-2012 01:12

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Punk did cause the impact of new wave music in the UK .. new wave like Magazine, Buzzcocks.. even the Jam.
Magazine

Magazine - Definitive Gaze (OGWT) - YouTube

Mancie 10-05-2012 01:34

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
I jumped the gun there .. this is "new wave" from Magazine in 1977 when Punk was in full swing.. Motorcade

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94jGx...eature=related

kestrelx 10-05-2012 07:02

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Restless (Post 990817)
I absolutely hate the link between LSD and Pink Floyd. I was often told "you have to listen to this on acid"

I would rather (back then)take LSD and bash my head against a wall that listen that rubbish.

I wasn't a big Pink Floyd fan in the 70's but I heard their records a few occasions and the lyrics from Dark Side of the Moon also stuck in my mind...

"Hanging around on a piece of ground in your home town, waiting for someone or something to show you the way!"

I never taken LSD and listened to Pink Floyd - but those lyrics strike a bell!

kestrelx 10-05-2012 13:45

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Claytoner40 (Post 990834)
Punk augmented some pop? Some pop is total crap though. Punk circa 1976 changed music forever

Punk changed Pop music without a doubt...

Artists like Elvis Costello were launched by Punk...

Elvis Costello - I Don't Want To Go To Chelsea - YouTube

mobertol 11-05-2012 12:51

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Prefer Joe Jackson to Elvis Costello - this is a great song-hadn't heard it in years...

Joe Jackson - Steppin' Out - YouTube

Not a bit influenced by punk!:D

jaysay 11-05-2012 17:51

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 991130)
Prefer Joe Jackson to Elvis Costello - this is a great song-hadn't heard it in years...

Joe Jackson - Steppin' Out - YouTube

Not a bit influenced by punk!:D

Never like Elvis Costello mobertol, never floated my boat at all

kestrelx 12-05-2012 16:34

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 991130)
Prefer Joe Jackson to Elvis Costello - this is a great song-hadn't heard it in years...

[/URL]

Not a bit influenced by punk!:D

You seem determined to undermine the fact that punk changed the music business, that is fact. For one it opened the door for mass indie music market and in the light of punk a multitude of indie record labels sprang up and the DIY ethic brought on by punk was responsible for this. Joe Jackson would probably have not got a record deal but for Punk. Regardless I only remember 2 of his songs - but he did come out on that crest of a NEW WAVE launched by punk rock. :mosher:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n34s98WpwJg

Boeing Guy 12-05-2012 17:17

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Being a big fan of Joe Jackson, I got into him in the early 80's, I would say he is anything but punk.
Night and Day, the album which 'Steppin Out' was off was a nod and tribute to Cole Porter.
he is just finishing a tribute album to Duke Ellington, his work comprises Classical, Jazz, Pop and Rock sometimes combining them all.
I have seen him a few times live and he is one of the best live acts I have ever seen.

To say that Punk paved the way for him, well if having a record producer hear your tape, then signing you is down to the influence of punk so be it. but where does that leave The Beatles.
His label at the time was A&M a rather large label.

To be fair, I always thought the start of DIY etc started with the Teac A3440 4 track reel to reel and the Tascam home studio that used cassettes.

Maybe we should class Marillion as punk, they don't have a record label, instead rely on their fans to buy albums up front, so they can record them.

Boeing Guy 12-05-2012 18:44

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
All that said, punk did help change the established music record industry ethic, just as ska and new wave, helped by the likes of Talking Heads and The Cars did.
I just don't like punk, that's all

kestrelx 12-05-2012 18:53

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Boeing Guy (Post 991309)
Being a big fan of Joe Jackson, I got into him in the early 80's, I would say he is anything but punk.
Night and Day, the album which 'Steppin Out' was off was a nod and tribute to Cole Porter.
he is just finishing a tribute album to Duke Ellington, his work comprises Classical, Jazz, Pop and Rock sometimes combining them all.
I have seen him a few times live and he is one of the best live acts I have ever seen.

To say that Punk paved the way for him, well if having a record producer hear your tape, then signing you is down to the influence of punk so be it. but where does that leave The Beatles.
His label at the time was A&M a rather large label.

To be fair, I always thought the start of DIY etc started with the Teac A3440 4 track reel to reel and the Tascam home studio that used cassettes.

Maybe we should class Marillion as punk, they don't have a record label, instead rely on their fans to buy albums up front, so they can record them.

It's the musical climate of the time and his first hit 79 "Is she really going out with him!" is most definately on the bandwagon of Elvis Costello style market! This is how record companies work - they advise artists and produce artists to make their sound fit the moment. That record is definately of that sound of New Wave - no not punk mate but there is a line drawn by punk of the type of music that was in the chart before punk and then after wards and there is a massive difference! Records that made it in 78 - 79 like Elvis Costello and Joe Jackson would not have been as successful before punk.

This is not just my opinion but many well known music business pundits.

You had Punk - New Wave - Power Pop - Joe Jackson wasn't punk, his single "Is she really going out with him!" was New Wave and I bet the producer made sure it was like that so they'd get a hit!

Quote from Wikipedia entry on him - " He was popular for his pop/rock and new wave music early on before moving to more eclectic, though less commercially successful, pop/jazz/classical hybrids."

mobertol 13-05-2012 16:03

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx (Post 991316)
Quote from Wikipedia entry on him - " He was popular for his pop/rock and new wave music early on before moving to more eclectic, though less commercially successful, pop/jazz/classical hybrids."

Did you go on Wikipedia and write that yourself?:rolleyes:

I listened to Joe Jackson all the way from Accy to Strasbourg on a coach (school exchange trip) Easter 1979, that and Outlandos D'amour, almost wore the tapes out -both on A&M if i remember rightly.

It's fair enough on the part of a record company -who want to make money on their investment, to suggest the direction of an artist's first output - their own style will prevail if they are destined for success. Joe Jackson and The Police have stayed the test of time as artists even though their first songs were less "them", as you suggest in the case of JJ. The Police had a "Punk" first record -Landlord, which was not a hit -listen to it and you'll see why! They were also told by A&M to bleach their hair blond to look more Punk -they just looked a bit daft as they were much older than the kids playing punk -even though Sting pulled it off better than the other two because of his natural beauty.:D

Just to throw the cat among the pigeons -was thinking about Squeeze -another group I loved back in the good old days of the 70's. Where would you place them with relaton to Punk? Might be an idea to ask Jools;)
Squeeze - Up the Junction (TOTP) - YouTube

Have just listened to this one again with much pleasure:D

kestrelx 14-05-2012 20:58

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mobertol (Post 991429)
Did you go on Wikipedia and write that yourself?:rolleyes:

I listened to Joe Jackson all the way from Accy to Strasbourg on a coach (school exchange trip) Easter 1979, that and Outlandos D'amour, almost wore the tapes out -both on A&M if i remember rightly.

It's fair enough on the part of a record company -who want to make money on their investment, to suggest the direction of an artist's first output - their own style will prevail if they are destined for success. Joe Jackson and The Police have stayed the test of time as artists even though their first songs were less "them", as you suggest in the case of JJ. The Police had a "Punk" first record -Landlord, which was not a hit -listen to it and you'll see why! They were also told by A&M to bleach their hair blond to look more Punk -they just looked a bit daft as they were much older than the kids playing punk -even though Sting pulled it off better than the other two because of his natural beauty.:D

Just to throw the cat among the pigeons -was thinking about Squeeze -another group I loved back in the good old days of the 70's. Where would you place them with relaton to Punk? Might be an idea to ask Jools;)


Have just listened to this one again with much pleasure:D

No I didn't write it myself it was on the Wikipedia page. As for the Police - yeh they jumped on the Punk Bandwagon and it worked they went onto being a massive band with the dyed hair! :cool: They also cashed in on the Reggae link!

Blondie-Hanging on the telephone - YouTube

Squeeze, Joe Jackson were New Wave or Power Pop - definately taking advantage of that market.

Debbie Harry were also part of the New York Punk Scene from about 1975 - but very soon from around 78 she was doing pop with a New Wave edge quickly converting to Disco mixed with their new wave/punk edge! :D:D:D:mosher:

DaveinGermany 14-05-2012 21:50

Re: Punk heralded the death of pop
 
Aaaaahhh, Debbie Harry, my generation of Schoolboys fantasy, she was a proper darlin' in them days. :) Not looking to bad now either, eeeehh.


All times are GMT. The time now is 01:52.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1
© 2003-2013 AccringtonWeb.com