buddy or elvis ??

,,,,i Think Buddy Holly Would Have Been A Lot More Popular Than He Was, If He Haddent Died So Young,,,21 I Think ,
oooo completely agree granny ... and i love watching the buddy holly story could watch it over and over ..
 
neither of them, i went off Elvis when they started re-releasing his singles all mashed up, and i dont think i know one song by Buddy Holly
 
Buddy was Great!:)
But there was only one King!!:D
If there is one song that makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand on end it has to be " An American Triology" Pure class!!
 
Last edited:
If there is one song that makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand on end it has to be " An American Triology" Pure class!!

I agree, that and 'How Great Thou Art' has the same affect on me.

Buddy Holly's music was great, but doesn't compare to Elvis's.
 
buddy holly for me never did like elvis still don't. i prefared billy fury ..
 
Both of them ... but Elvis had such a powerful voice; remember these were the days before the massive banks of amps and speakers, you can see it in the early Beatles broadcasts too. It's the voice tho' ... there again Elvis came out of the gospel tradition, the same roots that Mahalia Jackson came from ... now there is a singer! If you have never heard her stuff, give it a listen ...
 
Never that keen on Cleo's scat, give me Ella Fitzgerald or Lady Day anytime.

Love Piaf and Ms. Jackson but I'd also add Bessie Smith, she was one bluesy Momma.
 
I don't accept that Elvis was one of the greatest singers, Roy Orbison was a much better singer than Elvis Presley (The Big O's version of Mean Woman Blues cannot be beaten). Buddy Holly - he was truly great.
 
Last edited:
I don't accept that Elvis was one of the greatest singers, Roy Orbison was a much better singer than Elvis Presley (The Big O's version of Mean Woman Blues cannot be beaten). Buddy Holly - he was truly great.

Ok ... but do you remember the duet that he did with k. d. lang, that fantastic version of "Crying" ... I would say on that one k. d. had the more powerful voice.
 
Ok ... but do you remember the duet that he did with k. d. lang, that fantastic version of "Crying" ... I would say on that one k. d. had the more powerful voice.

Oh she is a great singer too..Have you heard her singing The air that i breath ,,, its every bit as good as The Hollies version .
 
Back
Top