Editing and deleting posts.

Status
Not open for further replies.
garinda

garinda

Give, give, give member
Overlooker
Noticed that quite a few posts have been deleted this evening.

True, strictly speaking some posts will have gone off the subject of the thread title, and thus they did break forum rules, and therefore they can quite rightly be deleted.

However, I could point out thousands of similar posts on the forum, which have also veered off topic, but they remain on site.

Some of the deleted posts may have exhibited, or at least attempted a stab at humour.

Is this seen as going off thread?

Might be an idea if the reasons why some posts are deleted, and some aren't, are given. Then hopefully people will know how to avoid this happening.

If arbitrary deletion, in which some posts are deleted, and similar posts remain untouched, continues, it might deter some people from bothering to post at all, because it becomes a bit of a lottery if their post does, or doesn't remain.

Which would result in the forum becoming very sluggish, in my opinion.
 
There is a difference between being off topic, which as you know happens a lot and is usually left untouched and posts that are just argumentative and insulting each other.

Do you think those type of posts should be left on?
 
Re: Deep Fried Worms & Snot Cake

I have removed a lot of posts that were just argumentative and plain insulting. It was a toss up between removing posts and removing the whole thread.

I apologise for not cleaning up this thread sooner but I have been busy the last few days and not been online much.
 
Re: Deep Fried Worms & Snot Cake

If you only remove certain posts, people get a one sided opinion, sureley it's better to remove whole thread then it's not quite as biased.
 
Re: Deep Fried Worms & Snot Cake

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Neil,I have removed a lot of posts that were just argumentative and plain insulting.
Click to expand...
My post was far from argumentative or insulting. But as you are the mod will have to abide by your decision to delete it.
 
Neil said:
Do you think those type of posts should be left on?
Click to expand...

No, and as Cashman hinted I don't want to criticise any moderators, because that too would break forum rules.

However quite honestly I'm struggling to see any logic, in deciding which posts are deleted, and which remain untouched.

I'll state as fact that some recently deleted posts, although like thousands of others may have veered off topic, were definitely not 'argumentative and insulting'. Certainly no more so than posts that remain in the heavily edited thread. Including at least one post in the hacked thread, which could be argued contains at least two insults aimed at other members. Some of those deleted would have been seen as attempting humour, at least in the eyes of most people.

Rules should not be applied on a whim, willy-nilly, and in an arbitrary fashion.

Well they can be.

But as stated earlier, people wouldn't want to play a lottery game for long. Guessing if their very similar posts might, or might not be deleted.

I'm genuinely not criticising anyone.

Just trying to make sense of something that to me shows very little logic.

I've always had the utmost respect for the way this site is moderated, but this editing baffles me.

As in any society, if the law is deemed to be unfair, people soon get fed up.

A few might remain, a few might protest. Most will simply go elsewhere.

So we can learn from this, I'm more than happy if my own deleted posts are reproduced here, with an explanation as to why each needed removing, whilst similar are allowed to remain.

I'm sure all members would then know what to avoid, so as to create less work for the moderators.
 
Re: Deep Fried Worms & Snot Cake

BERNADETTE said:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My post was far from argumentative or insulting. But as you are the mod will have to abide by your decision to delete it.
Click to expand...

And your going to lay back and take it.........:eek:
 
Re: Deep Fried Worms & Snot Cake

Doug said:
And your going to lay back and take it.........:eek:
Click to expand...
Nothing I can do but abide by a mods decision whether I agree with it or not:( Think most members will have got the gist of how one of our esteemed members can get away with insulting just about everyone as they so please without warning:(
 
If there's a situation in which people think rules aren't being applied across the board, and are applied to some cases, and not to others, that's when accusations od fairness and credibility arise.

Again, not being critical. I want clarity, so myself, and hopefully others can learn, and we won't fall foul of rule breaking again.
 
Re: Deep Fried Worms & Snot Cake

Alan Varrechia said:
If you only remove certain posts, people get a one sided opinion, sureley it's better to remove whole thread then it's not quite as biased.
Click to expand...

Not always as simple as that.
The original post was a perfectly sensible post. Many of the following posts were just comments on other threads and insults between members.

Maybe I should have just left the original post and no others.
 
Re: Deep Fried Worms & Snot Cake

BERNADETTE said:
Nothing I can do but abide by a mods decision whether I agree with it or not:(
Click to expand...

Not true at all. You can PM me any time and discuss anything you want. I will reply as soon as I can.


BERNADETTE said:
Think most members will have got the gist of how one of our esteemed members can get away with insulting just about everyone as they so please without warning:(
Click to expand...

I moderate as fairly as I can and will remove posts I think need removing no matter who has posted them.
 
Doug said:
OK, let’s pretend that I’m thick. Is this or is this not a discussion board?
Click to expand...

So as not to start another unnecessary thread, I did search, to see if I could just add my comments to an old thread, seeking similar clarification.

I did find a thread started by your good self, which asked similar questions, but it was in the footy section. Hence, new thread.

:p
 
Re: Deep Fried Worms & Snot Cake

BERNADETTE said:
Nothing I can do but abide by a mods decision whether I agree with it or not:( Think most members will have got the gist of how one of our esteemed members can get away with insulting just about everyone as they so please without warning:(
Click to expand...

What about your rights......:)
 
Re: Deep Fried Worms & Snot Cake

Neil said:
Now that is just a troll post like the ones you complained about in Stanley section and have been removed.
Click to expand...

No Neil; why can't people express themselves; even at the expense of making themselves out to be idiots. This is a message board at the end of the day. Why does it have to be so clean all the time….
 
Re: Deep Fried Worms & Snot Cake

Doug said:
....Why does it have to be so clean all the time….
Click to expand...
It is not "so clean all the time" but a couple of the rules are below
Abusing Other Members
Abusing other members of this website is not allowed. Debates are welcome but must not become personal or target another member.
All threads started that are personal attacks on other members will be deleted.

 Insulting & Nasty Posts
Posts that are just insulting or nasty are not allowed on this website.
Click to expand...

They also say this

Arguments & Disagreements
If you feel a post is not correct or someone’s actions or comments have upset you, you must not start an argument in the forums. Instead, send a Private Message or E-mail to the user and speak to them directly. You must not question the Forum Staff’s actions within the forums but communicate via Private Message or E-mail. The Forum Staff have the final say in all actions that they have taken.
Click to expand...

But I think we appear to have a problem that we should discuss so if it can be kept sensible I think we should try and discuss it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top