Accrington Web

Accrington Web (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/index.php)
-   General Chat (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/f69/)
-   -   Portrayal of women: (split) (https://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/f69/portrayal-of-women-split-25509.html)

lettie 04-11-2006 08:35

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Most of us are lardy compared to Sparks and I wouldn't mind but he never stops eating..:rolleyes: Where is the justice in that????

I was painfully thin as a teenager and my mate's boyfriend used to call me Spindle because of my skinny legs. I hated it and never, never wore skirts, shorts or anything that would show my legs in case I invited comments about how skinny I was.

Luckily I did put some weight on when I got into my 20's and managed to fill out a bit. Now, in my late 30's, it seems that I am still filling out a bit..:o My excuse is that I find it difficult to sit and watch Sparks eating a nice dessert in a restaurant and not have one too...:D

I know totally where Slinky is coming from because I used to find the comments about my weight and skinny legs hurtful..
Now I just find the comments about my lardy arse and wobbly bits hurtful..:rolleyes:

slinky 04-11-2006 11:45

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lettie
I know totally where Slinky is coming from because I used to find the comments about my weight and skinny legs hurtful..
Now I just find the comments about my lardy arse and wobbly bits hurtful..:rolleyes:

Thanks Lettie. Not once in this thread have I said I am un-happy about my size, people just think they heard me say it. What I was actually getting at is what you have just said Lettie. No matter what size you are, it does NOT give people the permission to make mindless nasty comments about your size.

Like you said Lettie, the comment about SPINDLE legs were at the time just as hurtful as being called FAT or CHUBBY and had such a impact that you didn't wear skirts because of it........ So that was my point, THINK before you speak, because your words might be meant in a LAUGHY kind of way, but doesn't excuse the hurt they cause.

Tinkerbelle 04-11-2006 12:09

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
That goes for most things not just weight issues. People regardless of who they are, have a hang-up about a particular part of their body. If someone is fat, or thin or has a big nose (thanks Mez ;) ) or wears glasses, I'm sure that person knows that themselves and may be self conscious about it, they hardly need it pointing out and drawing attention to it from someone else. Just a case of putting ones brain into gear before opening ones gob me does think. :rolleyes:

Neil 04-11-2006 12:11

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinkerbelle
Just a case of putting ones brain into gear before opening ones gob me does think. :rolleyes:

I have a feeling I will be reminding you of that quote soon. :D

katex 04-11-2006 12:13

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cherokee
So why is it that if someone sees the larger woman nothing dared be said but with the slim (thin)woman its usually something like omg you ve lost weight or, you need to put a few pounds on or, if you lose any more weight youll fall down that crack.
what im tryin to say is that why do we think its ok to comment on the size of the slimmer woman and not the larger one . this is my opinion anyway

I think that if anyone does this if just plain bad-mannered and would probably comment the same about someone they consider overweight ... a lot of the time it can be the overweight person who is conscious of her weight and a sort of bitchiness to compensate them.

I have a friend who insults me regularly by calling me the 'stick insect' and thinks ought to put more weight on ..... Excuse Me !! no way can I be described as this !!!

As always being slim herself in the past, and now 'grown' a little in size, is feeling a lack of self-confidence .. although she is still extemely attractive, just wants me to join her club so to speak.

I ignore it of course and, yes, still are good friends believe it or not.. :D

accymel 04-11-2006 12:13

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinkerbelle
That goes for most things not just weight issues. People regardless of who they are, have a hang-up about a particular part of their body. If someone is fat, or thin or has a big nose (thanks Mez ;) ) or wears glasses, I'm sure that person knows that themselves and may be self conscious about it, they hardly need it pointing out and drawing attention to it from someone else. Just a case of putting ones brain into gear before opening ones gob me does think. :rolleyes:

Dont worry tinks mine is ... "aqualine" ..too;) :D so u aint on yer own:(

accymel 04-11-2006 12:17

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Thing ive learnt over the years being bullied for everything so far lol is that the only person that has the problem is the person that subjects judgement onto someone for whatever reason, if someone insists on bringing a weight or height or whatever issue means that 'that' person themselves have the issue not the person subjected to it!

I mean if you aint got a problem with it .....then why do they bring it up then?:rolleyes:

Mind u i have yet for someone to come up with something new & insulting to call me:rolleyes: lol water off a ducks back

Tinkerbelle 04-11-2006 12:25

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by accymel
Mind u i have yet for someone to come up with something new & insulting to call me:rolleyes:


:rolleyes: Hmmm :rolleyes: ....... I'l get my thinking cap on :D

slinky 04-11-2006 12:27

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
[quote=accymel

I mean if you aint got a problem with it .....then why do they bring it up then?:rolleyes:[/quote]

Not sure if that is aimed at me and this thread?? But I will reply anyway. I brought this thread up because, It is one of my absolute hates when people think it is o.k to put people down about weight issues. I hate people who thinks it is o.k to call someone FAT, STICK THIN, ANOREXIC ( when they aren't they are just slim) being a Anorexic is a Illness - being slim is just what you are even though you eat see the difference. Making judgments on peoples sizes can have a lasting impact on that person, even though the person that makes the judgement may never ever think of the comment they made ever again.

accymel 04-11-2006 12:27

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinkerbelle
:rolleyes: Hmmm :rolleyes: ....... I'l get my thinking cap on :D

If ya do i will give ya a round of applause for originality:D lol

accymel 04-11-2006 12:37

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Not sure if that is aimed at me and this thread?? But I will reply anyway. I brought this thread up because, It is one of my absolute hates when people think it is o.k to put people down about weight issues. I hate people who thinks it is o.k to call someone FAT, STICK THIN, ANOREXIC ( when they aren't they are just slim) being a Anorexic is a Illness - being slim is just what you are even though you eat see the difference. Making judgments on peoples sizes can have a lasting impact on that person, even though the person that makes the judgement may never ever think of the comment they made ever again.

Nope its just aimed generally at the name callers.....but also yeh it could go for the thread too, people call people because of their ignorance, own in security & having a narrow mind - one thing that took me a long time to get in line was my own reaction to it [ask your tinks about my school years!] people say hurtful stuff to make themselves feel better & to gain reaction in hope others join the bandwagon so makes them feel GOOD or popular [saddo's] - so whats the worse thing you can do is fuel their fire with a reaction!!! I do the absolute opposite & well practised on one person i feared & it works cos it takes the power off them to yourself, like i said i dont take offense to name calling in fact immune had it too long over my life & like i said above i've yet to find someone to be original & call me something i haven't been called before if they have to, i will give em a round of applause - only happened a few times tho & it shocks them more that i aint bothered but clapped em for it with a :D

I dont know what started this slinky so cant comment about it but i've known you for a long time & know u as a person & i know u can hold yer own no matter what.

Tinkerbelle 04-11-2006 12:38

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
It is one of my absolute hates when people think it is o.k to put people down about weight issues.

I think it's just the way we are. Maybe subconsciously it makes us feel better about our own hang-ups if we criticise someone elses. I suppose it starts very young, in schools .... skinny, fatty, specky, bean pole. Maybe it's just easier to criticise than to give compliments. I dunno ... what I do know though is it would be boring if we were all the same. :rolleyes:

accymel 04-11-2006 12:46

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinkerbelle
I think it's just the way we are. Maybe subconsciously it makes us feel better about our own hang-ups if we criticise someone elses. I suppose it starts very young, in schools .... skinny, fatty, specky, bean pole. Maybe it's just easier to criticise than to give compliments. I dunno ... what I do know though is it would be boring if we were all the same. :rolleyes:

Too true:D Kids are mega mean!! LOL Surprising how many can still hold onto that time me included, i must admit i find it so much easier to take criticisms than actual genuine compliments:rolleyes: auto pilot comes on a bit quick

slinky 04-11-2006 12:50

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by accymel
Too true:D Kids are mega mean!!

Some adults can be just as mean Mel, it's not fair just to say it's kids....

accymel 04-11-2006 12:53

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Some adults can be just as mean Mel, it's not fair just to say it's kids....

Think u need to re read Slinky it was in reference to it starting at school as tinks post. Dont i know adults can be mean 1st lesson i learnt slinky, seems that who-ever started this has got just what they set out to do which is to upset you.:(

Tinkerbelle 04-11-2006 12:53

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Some adults can be just as mean Mel, it's not fair just to say it's kids....

Some adults? :( I've had this conversation many times! There's no-one meaner than adults. Give me a gang of name calling kids over nasty evil adults who should know better anyday.

Neil 04-11-2006 13:03

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
It is one of my absolute hates when people think it is o.k to put people down about weight issues. I hate people who thinks it is o.k to call someone FAT, STICK THIN, ANOREXIC....

We all do it Slinky, whether we realise it or not. Have a look at these 2 quotes while I go and hide.

Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
20 years ago!!!! I was on the school bus watching TINKS bully the fat lad lmao.........hey he's a big ****** now lol.

Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Tell him to keep him interfering, ugly, half witted, no good, fat head out of your garden....


accymel 04-11-2006 13:05

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Neil run & hide LOL but again very true point & a sad fact of human nature.

slinky 04-11-2006 13:10

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
We all do it Slinky, whether we realise it or not. Have a look at these 2 quotes while I go and hide.

Yeah but he does have a fat head lol...... well done Neil I applaud you.

I would never say that to his face though.......and yes as a kid I was just as evil as any other kid.

Don't hide Neil... you made a comment, and that is good. Say what you mean and mean what you say.

accymel 04-11-2006 13:13

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
I find the worst of the worse for hurtful biatchyness is women - they are really cruel - even worse hormonal LOL

Tinkerbelle 04-11-2006 13:15

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by accymel
I find the worst of the worse for hurtful biatchyness is women - they are really cruel - even worse hormonal LOL

Oh I don't know ... men are catching up quickly and they don't have the excuse of PMT ;)

slinky 04-11-2006 13:17

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by accymel
I find the worst of the worse for hurtful biatchyness is women - they are really cruel - even worse hormonal LOL

Hey Mel before I joined this site I would have agreed with you on that one!! BUT some of the men on this site put us BITCHES to shame. Maybe they are Testosteronal :D

accymel 04-11-2006 13:18

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinkerbelle
Oh I don't know ... men are catching up quickly and they don't have the excuse of PMT ;)

LOL true point if they can do the long chatty calls then they learnt how to biatch altho not quite as good yet lol:Banane43:

accymel 04-11-2006 13:20

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Hey Mel before I joined this site I would have agreed with you on that one!! BUT some of the men on this site put us BITCHES to shame. Maybe they are Testosteronal :D

LOLOL they not effected me yet i can handle them;) :D :Banane26:

Tinkerbelle 04-11-2006 13:31

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Maybe they are Testosteronal :D

Either that or they're all bi-sexual!! :D

slinky 04-11-2006 13:34

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinkerbelle
Either that or they're all bi-sexual!! :D

Hmmmmm one wonders!! :rolleyes:

garinda 04-11-2006 14:24

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
No matter what size you are, it does NOT give people the permission to make mindless nasty comments about your size.

Like you alluded to Willow's size, for anybody that may not have met her, when you refered to a member in this thread?

Respect works both ways.

slinky 04-11-2006 14:53

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda
Like you alluded to Willow's size, for anybody that may not have met her, when you refered to a member in this thread?

Respect works both ways.

Hmmm did I mean Willow?? how do you know who I meant?? you Mystic Meg these days.

Neil 04-11-2006 15:04

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Say what you mean and mean what you say.

I (nearly) always do. The hiding bit was just a joke. I know you are a pussy cat really. You must be to have shared Ginger with me at the meet :D :D Although I think you might have upset Rindy, he has a (not very) secret crush on your husband you know.

slinky 04-11-2006 15:05

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
I (nearly) always do. The hiding bit was just a joke. I know you are a pussy cat really. You must be to have shared Ginger with me at the meet :D :D Although I think you might have upset Rindy, he has a (not very) secret crush on your husband you know.

Lol I will share him any time!! I'm not selfish...... as for the pussy cat bit, yeah I am actually lol.

Neil 04-11-2006 15:09

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Lol I will share him any time!! I'm not selfish.

Maybe thats whats wrong with Rindy Roo, he is upset 'cus you are spreading Ginger around too much :D

Note to Mr R Roo.

Seeing as you are so upset about it you may have Ginger all too yourself.

slinky 04-11-2006 15:10

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
Maybe thats whats wrong with Rindy Roo, he is upset 'cus you are spreading Ginger around too much :D

Note to Mr R Roo.

Seeing as you are so upset about it you may have Ginger all too yourself.

That should put a smile on his face........and you can have him in the shower if you're a VERY good boy....:rolleyes:

garinda 04-11-2006 15:30

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Hmmm did I mean Willow?? how do you know who I meant?? you Mystic Meg these days.

Well who were you refering to? There was only myself, Gayle and Willow that had posted then. Not got the bottle to say what you actually mean because you'd look mean, peevish and just a tad shallow and hypocritical?

Tact goes both ways, or is it just slim people who are offended by supposed criticism?

slinky 04-11-2006 15:32

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda
Well who were you refering to? There was only myself, Gayle and Willow that had posted then. Not got the bottle to say what you actually mean because you'd look mean, peevish and just a tad shallow and hypocritical?

Tact goes both ways, or is it just slim people who are offended by supposed criticism?

Runs and hides behind sofa.......Rindy's dummy hitting the wall at lightening speed.

slinky 04-11-2006 15:37

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Actually Rindy Rudy......Tinkerbelle had posted in that thread ;)

garinda 04-11-2006 15:43

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Runs and hides behind sofa.......Rindy's dummy hitting the wall at lightening speed.

Great attitude Slinks.

If we lose Willow from this forum, because she thinks the coven hates her, it's down to you, according to the message I had from her.

She wasn't the only person you upset with your nasty comments, three more females pm'd me but were too afraid to post....and all because you were so insulted were non was intended, if you had the intelligence to actually read the original post, that so offended your delicate ego, you'd have seen that.

Like I said respect works both ways.

Bored now.

As for Ginger, I've just ordered a gold medal for putting up with you for the last ten years.:D

slinky 04-11-2006 15:46

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda
Great attitude Slinks.

If we lose Willow from this forum, because she thinks the coven hates her, it's down to you, according to the message I had from her.

Shut up you muppet.....Like I said.....prove who I meant first before spouting crap.



Like I said respect works both ways.

Bored now.

Yes actually I am, nice observation skills.

As for Ginger, I've just ordered a gold medal for putting up with you for the last ten years.:D

Thats two he has now!!! I bought him one the first year we were married.:D

Tinkerbelle 04-11-2006 15:48

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Don't you dare try to make my sister feel like a lesser person than Willow or any other member! Everybody has feelings. My are my sisters not important? If you'd have just apologised for your sweeping remark about stick thin people she wouldn't have to ellaborate would she!! :mad:

slinky 04-11-2006 15:52

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinkerbelle
Don't you dare try to make my sister feel like a lesser person than Willow! Everybody hs feelings. My are my sisters not important? If you'd have just apologised for your sweeping remark about stick thin people she wouldn't have to ellaborate would she!! :mad:

Oh Tinks don't let him get to you chick. He can't have a opinion on his own, so he needs to make things up as he goes along, then say I upset people with my remarks. Will the people I have upset PLEASE pm me. I would like to know who you are. I had the guts to stand up for something I believe in, in full view of everyone else. SO SHOOT ME!!! If you reply to me by PM tonight, I may not have time to reply as I have to take my kiddi winkles to a Bonfire now. But I WILL reply and I look forward to hearing from you all.

garinda 04-11-2006 15:55

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinkerbelle
Don't you dare try to make my sister feel like a lesser person than Willow! Everybody hs feelings. My are my sisters not important? If you'd have just apologised for your sweeping remark about stick thin people she wouldn't have to ellaborate would she!! :mad:

If you bother to read back I've appologised for unintentionally causing offence to Slinks more than once, which is more than she has to Willow, and even if she wasn't refering to Willow, who has taken it personally, what's the difference between Slinks taking offence at something that was unintentional, and Willow doing the same? None. At least I had the good manners to appologise.

I'll state again, women of all sizes are welcome to come and model, not just stick thin anorexics.(Meaning that unlike Milan/New York/Paris, models of all sizes will be welcome, including anorexics and lard arses, and everyone in between.)

Neil 04-11-2006 15:56

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
If you all go to the Plough at 7:30pm tonight to watch the fireworks I will buy you all a drink so you can kiss and make up before this goes too far.



By all I mean Slinky and Rindy ( and Ginger if I get another kiss ;) ), the rest of you can buy your own you bunch of tight wads :rolleyes: :D

garinda 04-11-2006 15:57

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Oh Tinks don't let him get to you chick. He can't have a opinion on his own, so he needs to make things up as he goes along, then say I upset people with my remarks. Will the people I have upset PLEASE pm me. I would like to know who you are. I had the guts to stand up for something I believe in, in full view of everyone else. SO SHOOT ME!!! If you reply to me by PM tonight, I may not have time to reply as I have to take my kiddi winkles to a Bonfire now. But I WILL reply and I look forward to hearing from you all.

Don't start.

You'll lose.

Trust me.

slinky 04-11-2006 16:00

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
I would never have intentionally insulted WILLOW or any one on this site for there weight or the lack of it. And you say WOMEN rindy, I mean women and men alike with weight problems. Weight doesn't just affect women.

That was my whole point in this thread.........NOT PUTTING PEOPLE DOWN about there size. So why the hell would I go and do it to willow?? DUH :(

slinky 04-11-2006 16:00

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda
Don't start.

You'll lose.

Trust me.

We will see.......I want the PM's mate because I want to know who I have upset.

Who knows 04-11-2006 17:50

Re: Real models required
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda
There is an absolutely beautiful, stunning Lancashire girl in Channel 5's 'Make me a Super Model'.

She's a size ten, slim in anyones books, and at least two sizes larger than the other models. She's told she has no chance of 'winning' because she's too fat, and is being encouraged to loose weight and crash diet That is a sad reflection on the society we live in. A society were young, healthy, normal girls aged nine, that I know personally, feel pressured to diet rather than just get on and enjoy their childhood.

The show at Accy Town Hall, will hopefully show that women of all sizes can be happy, confident, and glamorous.

End of.

As a bloke my self, i assure u im straighter than a pair of parallel lines :D
I, far one hate skinny doesn't do it 4 me at all. My girlfriend constantly strives far that extra pound that she can lose, time and time again i tell her skinny is not attractive (at least to me) its all about the tone. You can be 10 stone and still do it 4 me ^^

Gayle 04-11-2006 20:57

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Not sure if that is aimed at me and this thread?? But I will reply anyway. I brought this thread up because, It is one of my absolute hates when people think it is o.k to put people down about weight issues. I hate people who thinks it is o.k to call someone FAT, STICK THIN, ANOREXIC ( when they aren't they are just slim) being a Anorexic is a Illness - being slim is just what you are even though you eat see the difference. Making judgments on peoples sizes can have a lasting impact on that person, even though the person that makes the judgement may never ever think of the comment they made ever again.

This is not a new argument

Life and Health | Health and wellbeing | The shape we're in

Can I just reiterate that at no point did I say that you, Slinky, or anyone else for that matter, was unattractive because you were slim. I would never, ever, say anything to anyone about their weight. Mostly because I am self concious enough about my own that I would never comment on anyone elses.

My point was, and still is, that some women STARVE themselves to attain the body of a model. STARVING yourself is not healthy and there is no way that I would want to promote STARVATION as a lifestyle.

Healthy people come in all shapes and sizes, and that is what we want to represent in our fashion show.

WillowTheWhisp 05-11-2006 00:28

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
OK, I was going to stay away from AccyWeb until people had stopped arguing about this because I have some real life things which have a bit of a bearing on some of the comments in here but which I don't actually want to go into in public, but following something someone said to me privately today I felt I want to come on this thread to clear up a couple of things from my point of view.

In Gayle's orignal thread Slinky said:


Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky

Twice In this thread it says " hey guy's you don't have to be stick thin"....

What happens if I started one saying " Hey models needed, but you don't have to be a FAT cow to join"?? yes just as cutting!!

I would never call anyone a FAT COW or otherwise, so why do people think it is acceptable to call someone " stick thin, anorexic" ??

Now when I'd read Gayle's post and Rindy's post referring to thin models I did not think of naturally slim and attractive people, I thought of the so-called "super waif" image which is neither natural nor attractive. These aren't people who are naturally slim. Naturally slim people are attractive. These people Gayle and Rindy referred to are people who starve themselves almost to death to acheive an impossible figure which does not look attractive. I'm sure even the slim people on here and not just the 'fat cows' like me will look at those photographs with all the ribs and collar bones poking through the skin and in no way feel that these are images of attractive people.

Now normal people come in all shapes and sizes - some of us are short squirts with little fat legs and can't reach the top shelves in the kitchen. Some of us are blessed to be taller and oh how I envy them when they can just reach out and get something when I have to go and get a stepstool first. I refer to my own "little legs" when I can't reach things - or even struggle to climb onto a bar stool (Mez may rmember me doing that in the Stag) because I know I'm short. If anyone else refers to me as short it's just a fact. It's not an insult. Some people who are taller than average get a complex about their height. Maybe it's uncomfortable to be very tall - I don't know. Only a tall person can answer that.

I didn't, and still don't, see any reason why a naturally slim person who hasn't starved themselves into ill health to acheive a bustless bumless straight up and down bag of bones shape but who has a normal natural figure should jump to the defence of a hypothetical someone who has.

When some people see gorgeous dresses being worn by these models who only have the figures they have due to abusing their bodies they then buy something similar and when it doesn't look the same on them they assume they are at fault and try to emulate the model and acheive the same figure - with often tragic results. Young women have literally starved themselves to death trying to acheive something which they were never meant to be.

To those of you who are naturally slim and healthy then naturally slim is what you are meant to be and as I said to Garinda, if anyone called me a beanpole or a stick I'd be chuffed to little mintballs because it would mean I'd actually managed to lose weight, but it is probably an impossible dream for me due to a mixture of health problems which I don't intend to go into.

Please don't insult the intelligence of the fat cows amongs us by saying that people daren't insult us because it isn't PC. There is no legislation against fattism. In fact it has even been suggested that we are a hazzard to the public at large by our very existence in just the way that passive smokers cause others to breathe in their fumes. It has been proposed that we should be weighed when travelling by air and have to pay excess baggage. I've had insults shouted at me by ignorant kids and snide remarks made by ignorant adults such as "look at the size of that one." and "no wonder the chairs in here are broken" (in an office where I once worked, and no, I didn't break the chairs young idiots playing on them did that.)

We are told that we are ugly and accused of being sweaty, smelly and lazy by people who do not know us and in voices loud enough to be heard.

I would never insult a slim person. I envy slim people and would love to be one and if it was as easy as you think then why would I still be the size I am? I don't enjoy it. It isn't fun. Some overweight people may make jealous comments about slim people out of envy. I doubt a slim person would ever make a comment about a fat person out of envy.

However, although I would never insult a person of any size for being naturally that size, height or whatever; I do think it is wrong for fashion models to have been forced into trying to maintain an unnaturally skinny (and I choose that word intentionally as opposed to slim) shape which they can only sustain by living an unhealthy lifestyle.

For Gayle to have simply wanted to represent normal people of all shapes and sizes as opposed to the artificial model image and for it to have deteriorated into insulting people of different shapes and sizes is something I cannot understand. If you slim people have experienced insults from others in real life why should you then want to insult fat people here on AccyWeb when we have done nothing nor said anything to insult or offend you?

I hope this makes sense. I hope you can understand that the only people I have a problem with are the Kate Moss 'superwaif' types who live on snorting coke and smoking in order to stay impossibly thin. As a mother of teenage girls I hope and pray they never see anyone like that as a role model.

slinky 05-11-2006 00:43

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp
OK, I was going to stay away from AccyWeb until people had stopped arguing about this because I have some real life things which have a bit of a bearing on some of the comments in here but which I don't actually want to go into in public, but following something someone said to me privately today I felt I want to come on this thread to clear up a couple of things from my point of view.

In Gayle's orignal thread Slinky said:



Now when I'd read Gayle's post and Rindy's post referring to thin models I did not think of naturally slim and attractive people, I thought of the so-called "super waif" image which is neither natural nor attractive. These aren't people who are naturally slim. Naturally slim people are attractive. These people Gayle and Rindy referred to are people who starve themselves almost to death to acheive an impossible figure which does not look attractive. I'm sure even the slim people on here and not just the 'fat cows' like me will look at those photographs with all the ribs and collar bones poking through the skin and in no way feel that these are images of attractive people.

Now normal people come in all shapes and sizes - some of us are short squirts with little fat legs and can't reach the top shelves in the kitchen. Some of us are blessed to be taller and oh how I envy them when they can just reach out and get something when I have to go and get a stepstool first. I refer to my own "little legs" when I can't reach things - or even struggle to climb onto a bar stool (Mez may rmember me doing that in the Stag) because I know I'm short. If anyone else refers to me as short it's just a fact. It's not an insult. Some people who are taller than average get a complex about their height. Maybe it's uncomfortable to be very tall - I don't know. Only a tall person can answer that.

I didn't, and still don't, see any reason why a naturally slim person who hasn't starved themselves into ill health to acheive a bustless bumless straight up and down bag of bones shape but who has a normal natural figure should jump to the defence of a hypothetical someone who has.

When some people see gorgeous dresses being worn by these models who only have the figures they have due to abusing their bodies they then buy something similar and when it doesn't look the same on them they assume they are at fault and try to emulate the model and acheive the same figure - with often tragic results. Young women have literally starved themselves to death trying to acheive something which they were never meant to be.

To those of you who are naturally slim and healthy then naturally slim is what you are meant to be and as I said to Garinda, if anyone called me a beanpole or a stick I'd be chuffed to little mintballs because it would mean I'd actually managed to lose weight, but it is probably an impossible dream for me due to a mixture of health problems which I don't intend to go into.

Please don't insult the intelligence of the fat cows amongs us by saying that people daren't insult us because it isn't PC. There is no legislation against fattism. In fact it has even been suggested that we are a hazzard to the public at large by our very existence in just the way that passive smokers cause others to breathe in their fumes. It has been proposed that we should be weighed when travelling by air and have to pay excess baggage. I've had insults shouted at me by ignorant kids and snide remarks made by ignorant adults such as "look at the size of that one." and "no wonder the chairs in here are broken" (in an office where I once worked, and no, I didn't break the chairs young idiots playing on them did that.)

We are told that we are ugly and accused of being sweaty, smelly and lazy by people who do not know us and in voices loud enough to be heard.

I would never insult a slim person. I envy slim people and would love to be one and if it was as easy as you think then why would I still be the size I am? I don't enjoy it. It isn't fun. Some overweight people may make jealous comments about slim people out of envy. I doubt a slim person would ever make a comment about a fat person out of envy.

However, although I would never insult a person of any size for being naturally that size, height or whatever; I do think it is wrong for fashion models to have been forced into trying to maintain an unnaturally skinny (and I choose that word intentionally as opposed to slim) shape which they can only sustain by living an unhealthy lifestyle.

For Gayle to have simply wanted to represent normal people of all shapes and sizes as opposed to the artificial model image and for it to have deteriorated into insulting people of different shapes and sizes is something I cannot understand. If you slim people have experienced insults from others in real life why should you then want to insult fat people here on AccyWeb when we have done nothing nor said anything to insult or offend you?

I hope this makes sense. I hope you can understand that the only people I have a problem with are the Kate Moss 'superwaif' types who live on snorting coke and smoking in order to stay impossibly thin. As a mother of teenage girls I hope and pray they never see anyone like that as a role model.

And you WILLOW!!! before I am banned!!! You should have known better than to hide behind ****ing RINDY!!!!!!

Never did I ever make any nasty comment towards you.........but you!!!! didn't have the ****ing guts to PM me and tell me where and when I had offended you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! probably because it never ****ing happened.

WillowTheWhisp 05-11-2006 00:55

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
What I discussed with Garinda was private between me and him. It was not insulting you at any time Slinky, nor your sister. I was discussing something with him which I did not wish to discuss on the open board, which I do not wish to discuss with anyone else and which has absolutely nothing to do with you. It is personal.

Now, for the record if anyone goes up to Tinks as she said earlier and says "God isn't your sister thin" then yes I agree with her that it's an insult and they have absolutely no right to say such a thing. Anyone doing so should be ashamed of themselves

Apart from anything else though I don't see that either of you are unnaturally thin. I think you both look great. I wish I could look the same.

I actually said to Busman that night at the Boar's Head when you, Tinkerbelle and AccyMel were sitting together, that I wished I could be as slim as you three because you have a figure I would die for but cannot ever hope to acheive. If you were my sister and anyone said to me "God isn't your sister thin" then I would find that as offensive as them saying to me "God aren't you fat." I would also think they were slightly barmy because there's nothing remarkable, odd, unusual or whatever about the way you look.

The point is that the original comment about models wasn't about normal slim people it was about people who are not a normal natural size and stay that way by starving themselves and living off drugs - it's that lifstyle method of being what they are and portraying it as desireable which was the point raised.

slinky 05-11-2006 01:23

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp
What I discussed with Garinda was private between me and him. It was not insulting you at any time Slinky, nor your sister. I was discussing something with him which I did not wish to discuss on the open board, which I do not wish to discuss with anyone else and which has absolutely nothing to do with you. It is personal.

Now, for the record if anyone goes up to Tinks as she said earlier and says "God isn't your sister thin" then yes I agree with her that it's an insult and they have absolutely no right to say such a thing. Anyone doing so should be ashamed of themselves

Apart from anything else though I don't see that either of you are unnaturally thin. I think you both look great. I wish I could look the same.

I actually said to Busman that night at the Boar's Head when you, Tinkerbelle and AccyMel were sitting together, that I wished I could be as slim as you three because you have a figure I would die for but cannot ever hope to acheive. If you were my sister and anyone said to me "God isn't your sister thin" then I would find that as offensive as them saying to me "God aren't you fat." I would also think they were slightly barmy because there's nothing remarkable, odd, unusual or whatever about the way you look.

The point is that the original comment about models wasn't about normal slim people it was about people who are not a normal natural size and stay that way by starving themselves and living off drugs - it's that lifstyle method of being what they are and portraying it as desireable which was the point raised.

Thankyou for that post WILLOW..I really hope through these post's that I haven't offended you in any way shape or form, but as you will have noticed, I am being made out to be calling large people, and as people will have noticed, my own husband is not a small person either, so as I meant at the beginning of all this I do NOT like comments about either size and that is how all this started me voicing a personal opinion. So once again, there was no offence meant to anybody.

WillowTheWhisp 05-11-2006 01:26

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slinky
Never did I ever make any nasty comment towards you.........but you!!!! didn't have the ****ing guts to PM me and tell me where and when I had offended you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! probably because it never ****ing happened.

You didn't direct a comment towards me. You made a comment about a fat person having posted in the thread and I was the only fat person to have posted in the thread so presumably Rindy knowing that I am a fat person because he knows me and knows that you know I am a fat person quite naturally saw that as a reference to me. As would any other AccyWeb member who has even seen pictures of me in the gallery let alone met me.

I did mention to him that I was puzzled about how I had managed to anger you and Tinkerbelle in the 'intermittent custodial sentences' thread without intending to as it seemed that way when one of you quoted my post and added a comment about the thread being closed and the other said that exprssed her anger in a far nicer way than she could have. I mentioned that because I was baffled by why you were both angry when all I had done was refer to a quote one of you (Tinkerbelle) had made earlier in the thread about the idea having been adandoned.

WillowTheWhisp 05-11-2006 01:29

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
I just hope that you can see that no-one was actually having a go at thin or fat people but trying to avoid people thinking they couldn't be in Gayle's fashion show if they didn't look like Kate Moss. The point being that probably no-one in Accrington looks like Kate Moss and 99.99% of the women in the Uk don't look like Kate Moss.

slinky 05-11-2006 01:36

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp


I did mention to him that I was puzzled about how I had managed to anger you and Tinkerbelle in the 'intermittent custodial sentences' thread without intending to as it seemed that way when one of you quoted my post and added a comment about the thread being closed

I am soooo sorry if you thought this was aimed at you willow!! Actually it was aimed at MADHATTERS post and post's being closed when still good opinions were being put forward SORRY again if you thought this was because of you.

And actually before the last meet I would never have known you even if I had have fallen over you.......but I would never have described you as the FATEST person I ever met.......not only would that be awfully bloody wrong.......but it is something I would never ever say in the first place.

Mick 05-11-2006 08:28

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Right now thats sorted can we get back to the thread PLEASE:)

WillowTheWhisp 05-11-2006 08:47

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Right, so on the actual subject of this thread can I please ask if you, Slinky, think this looks attractive?

http://omeuescape.blogs.sapo.pt/arquivo/anorexia41.jpg

This is what I preume Gayle doesn't want in her fashion show and what she was saying no-one needs to look like to be in the fashion show because she needs real people with real normal bodies of whatever various shapes and sizes, but NORMAL.

You'd have to serously crash diet to look like that!

The above image is what Garinda meant by "stick thin annorexic". No-one at any time ever implied that they thought you or any other AccyWebber is a stick thin annorexic. Someone who starves themselves in order to look like the person in that photograph (because that image has been portrayed as ideal on the catwalk) in my opinion does need help because no way is it natural to harm your body in order to acheive that.

Back in the 60s (you're too young to remember) there was a famous model by the name of Twiggy. She called herself Twiggy because she was slim. She described herself as thin as a twig. By Kate Moss standards however she would probably been seen a slightly plump! That's how mad things got. People tried to emulate Twiggy because she was the icon of the day - then they tried to outdo her, then it got stupid.

WillowTheWhisp 05-11-2006 14:31

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Now that some of the posts have been removed it unfortunately makes some of the responses to those posts looks as foolish as posts which respond to those which have been subsequently edited. :(

panther 05-11-2006 14:40

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp
Right, so on the actual subject of this thread can I please ask if you, Slinky, think this looks attractive?

http://omeuescape.blogs.sapo.pt/arquivo/anorexia41.jpg


is that where my mop went!!
GET SOME STEAK PUDS DOWN YA WOMAN! YUK!!

WillowTheWhisp 05-11-2006 14:41

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
I know a 14 year old girl, already slim, who is dieting because she looks at people like that and thinks that she herself is fat!

WillowTheWhisp 06-11-2006 00:15

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tinkerbelle
Again with your pictures of anorexic girls your missing the point.

How is that missing the point when Gary was actually referring to annorexic girls and not naturally slim ones?

There was a program on TV tonight about this very issue - not about naturally slim and attractive women but about those who have shortened their lifespan and damaged their internal organs by trying starving themselves into a size 6 or 8 at 5ft 10 or more. Even Sophie Dahl succumbed to pressure to conform.

Medical experts described these women in similar terms to those which have been cricicised in this thread.

I have a friend whose naturally slim 14 year old daughter has dieted herself into a scary frailty and yet still sees herself as fat and still wants to lose more weight!

I admit that I'm fat, or to be more accurate, obese. I don't enjoy it and I don't stuff my face with pies and chocolate 24/7 as is the popular misconception. It may seem ironic for me of all people to worry about this girl but I do worry about her and I'm thankful my girls aren't as stupid.

I wish the fashion industry in general had the approach that Gayle has and would show normal people of all sizes and admit that we come in short, tall, slim and rounded shapes all of which are natural instead of portraying the unnatural as an ideal to be aimed for.

Tinkerbelle 06-11-2006 01:08

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp
How is that missing the point when Gary was actually referring to annorexic girls and not naturally slim ones?

Do you think I'm stupid or something? :rolleyes: ....... In fact don't answer. :)

I'm not going to be responding Willow, between you and Gary you'll only manage to twist and turn it to make me look the bad guy ;)

Delete it Len ....... Thick skinned and don't give a shi ....... damn! :)

WillowTheWhisp 06-11-2006 08:38

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Oh well I'll just confirm again what I've said before, that I for one don't think you or Slinky could ever be described as stick thin annorexic and for anyone to do so or to insult either one of you to the other, or indeed anyone else of a similar size or smaller for that matter is inexcusable. If someone is naturally slim then that is their natural shape and shouldn't be ridiculed.

I don't know what it's like to be a very slim person who would like to gain weight and can't. I've never been there. It isn't something I've experienced. I do know what it's like to be a fat person and then an obese person who has tried to lose weight and only ended up gaining more and I do know what it's like to be ridiculed and told that I'm a liar and that all I need to do is eat less. I even believed that all I needed to do was eat less, and then less than that when it wasn't working and couldn't understand why it wasn't working until I finally learned only a few months ago how metabolism works and how the human body stores fat from the most meagre resources.

I do still go along with the sentiments of the TV program last night that presenting artificially thin women who diet in order to get even thinner as a norm to be aspired to is unhealthy, dangerous and very, very wrong. I'm talking about slim people who want to LOSE weight, not about slim people who are happy with their weight or slim people who want to gain a bit. This is about how they are endangering their health and presenting a role model to young girls who are then endangering their health and even putting their lives at risk by trying to emulate them when they already have lovely slim attractive figures. Maybe kids like that need to be 'insulted' to shock them into looking at themselves and realising what they are doing to their bodies with the dangrous dieting when they are already thin.

I'm not twisting anything Tinkerbelle. I'm just trying to explain to you that neither I nor Gary nor Gayle ever set out to insult you, Slinky or anyone on AccyWeb or even anyone not on AccyWeb by referring to the general public's preconceived idea of what a model should be and Gayle simply saying that wasn't what she was looking for for her fashion show.

BTW you can both call me fat if you like. You do better to call me obese as that is more accurate but please don't call me a cow. I don't mind you speaking the truth. That isn't an insult, it's merly factual and I know that fat people look ugly. I've been told that before. However, I also think that annorexic models look ugly. Slim people on the other hand look attractive and you two as slim attractive people surely cannot imagine that anyone could ever class you alongside the ugliness of the superwaif catwalk model image.

Neil 06-11-2006 09:09

Portrayal of women
 
Listen you lot,

I am the only stick thin anorexic in the village so the rest of you can sling yer 'ook.


I think it is time for the media to stop printing pictures and airing TV programmes of these stick thin anorexic type models as shown above. Maybe then us, the public can show these 'few homosexual designers' (as Rindy said above) that we don't want to see this type of model and we don't want our daughters unhealthily starving themselves trying to achieve that look.

Until the media start giving a damn about the health of these (and our) young girls then we can vote with our wallet's and TV remote's. Don't buy the magazines and turn over the TV when the fashion shows come on. If you really care enough then why not email the magazines and TV companies stating you view.

Maybe someone on here could get together and post a list of email addresses for all the fashion type magazines and TV shows. We could write an email with picture attachments and we can all send emails to them.

Neil 06-11-2006 09:14

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp
I know that fat people look ugly.... Slim people on the other hand look attractive

Sorry Willow but I don't agree with your comment above. As the saying goes 'Beauty is in the eye of the beholder'. I think a more accurate statement would be 'some people are ugly and some people are not'. I see good looking people of all shapes and sizes, I also see ugly ones of all shapes and sizes. Size is not a definition of beauty.

WillowTheWhisp 06-11-2006 09:23

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
It's actully been pointed out to me before Neil that I'm fat and therefore ugly and I don't dispute that. How could I? I look at photographs of myself and I don't like what I see. I look at photographs of what I once looked like and wish that I still looked like that. I'll find a couple of contrasting images of myself to show you what I mean.

accymel 06-11-2006 09:29

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Personally i think this is a no win arguement everybody even me have some form of hang up over our own bodies so you should all kiss & make up!:D

Neil 06-11-2006 09:39

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by accymel
everybody even me have some form of hang up over our own bodies







































I have left some space above for you to list them Mel :D :D :D

Gayle 06-11-2006 09:39

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp
It's actully been pointed out to me before Neil that I'm fat and therefore ugly and I don't dispute that. How could I? I look at photographs of myself and I don't like what I see. I look at photographs of what I once looked like and wish that I still looked like that. I'll find a couple of contrasting images of myself to show you what I mean.

No, please don't do that Willow. Neil is right (look at that Neil, we're agreeing again), beauty is absolutely nothing to do with size - as I'm sure Busman will also confirm. Beauty is far more than that and fortunately there are men out there who like all different types of women.

I'm not conventionally beautiful and according to Less I'm dumpy, add to that the view that my children have of me with a wrinkly forehead and wobbly belly and I could have a real downer on my body image. We all have issues with the way we look but beauty is well and truly in the eye of the beholder and so no one should ever allow anyone else to call them ugly and no one should ever call themselves that.

As we get older things change and we have to accept that we are never going to look like we did at 20 again but we can't beat ourselves up about it.

Willow, you have so much more to offer than physical beauty, please don't do yourself an injustice.

accymel 06-11-2006 09:48

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Who sets the rules for beauty? what one can see as beautiful another can see as not so [ugly is not a nice term] we set our own rules for it, as for having gone thro councelling a lot of it is in the mind & attitude - i much rather someone be beautiful in the inside than on the outside - trust me! I've known some outsidely good looking people but absolutely horrible on the inside, to deem an outside attractiveness takes about 30 secs but then what u want to find is that the outside matches the inside.

accymel 06-11-2006 09:51

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil
I have left some space above for you to list them Mel :D :D :D

LOL im not listing them:eek: mind u theres not anything that i would go under the knife for so cant be that bad i've learnt to accept myself wrinkly & wobbly an all that least its mine :D

WillowTheWhisp 06-11-2006 10:08

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
OK, here we have me about 17 years ago before I started trying to lose weight. Please ignore hideously baggy bottomed jeans! I have no idea why I thought they were appealing but I liked them at the time!! I look back on this and hopefully without sounding conceited I now think this is an attractive image. I didn't at the time because I felt my bum was too big and I wanted it to be smaller, hence the dieting.

http://i15.photobucket.com/albums/a3...p/Image001.jpg

Here we have me a couple of years ago. This is not an attractive image. In no way can this image be described as anything but ugly and fat. I am the first to admit that.

http://i15.photobucket.com/albums/a3...p/Image002.jpg

But I don't think the superwaif catwalk models are any more attractive or any less ugly than the second photo of me and yet they intend to look like that and they are expected to look like that by a fashion industry which says that looking like that is necessary in order to be a fashion model. Why else would the pleasantly attractive Sophie Dahl have conformed? She was already beautiful but she spoiled her beauty in order to conform.

Neil 06-11-2006 10:11

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gayle
according to Less I'm dumpy

So from other recent posts, if dimbo is a dim bimbo and dumbo is short for dim jumbo then dumpy must mean dumb and lumpy.
Thats not very nice of Less, I think you are very intelligent Gayle :rolleyes: :D

Gayle 06-11-2006 10:21

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Groucho Marks once said - if you want to get a beautiful woman into bed tell them they're smart and if you want to get an intelligent woman into bed tell them they're beautiful! :D

WillowTheWhisp 06-11-2006 10:26

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Groucho Marks missed an obvious point there - an intelligent woman would be intelligent enough not to fall for a dumb line like that!

garinda 06-11-2006 10:36

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Sophie Dahl is an interesting point, re: the fashion industry's attitude to size. When she became the face of Yves Saint Laurent she was a size 14.

Gasp!

An 'outsize' model was chosen to front one of the world's leading fashion companies!

After gaining a lot of good publicity for the company, a year later she was quietly dropped and replaced by Kate Moss. She's said in interviews since that in order to carry on finding work, once the novelty had worn off about 'outsize' models, remember she was a size 14 and six foot tall, she felt compelled to diet. She's now a size 8. Still beautiful, but the point is she was compelled to become thinner if she wanted to work.

http://www.lacoctelera.com/esestosan...ntitled3_7.jpg

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but certainly wasn't present in some of the foul mouthed posts from the early hours of Sunday morning, that have since been deleted, and to refer to me as a 'milk shaker', which I have taken to refer to Parkinson's, and which showed a very ugly attitude.

WillowTheWhisp 06-11-2006 11:49

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Good grief is size 14 is outsize then what the heck are the upper end of M&S never mind Evan's where I shop!

I agree that Sophie Dahl still has a pretty face but her body looked it's best before she went to extremes.

To insult someone due to an illness or disability is very ugly indeed and rather sad. :( There was a girl I was at school with who used to refer to a disabled classmate who wore leg braces as "a spaz" and thought it was clever to do so. Not surprisngly she was the one who didn't end up with many friends.

CASPER 06-11-2006 12:38

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
I have only one thing to say in this thread and that is that BEAUTY comes from WITHIN. Some of the things that have been said on this thread have not been very Beautiful, however I can see both sides and do see where you are coming from.

Willow DO NOT pull yourself down, there are enough people out there in the world waiting to do that! I know that you are a very beautiful, caring person, and that means far more to others than wether you are slim or not.

Love to everyone, I think we need a GROUP HUG !!!!!!!!!

Tinkerbelle 06-11-2006 14:05

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
[color=darkorchid]
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp**[/COLOR
OK, I was going to stay away from AccyWeb




You’re not the only one. I had no intention of posting in this thread or on the forum boards of accyweb again, so last night I didn’t appreciate being dragged into it yet again. I only came into thread to try and explain it from slinkys point of view. Between Gary, yourself and a lovely bit of editing to one of my posts (which, for the record, was in no way any reference to your weight, it was an answer to the numerous references Gary had made to you in an earlier post), we’ve been made to look like we have a problem with large people.


Willow I can see you’ve got a very painful issue with your weight, but this thread was never about you. How you’ve managed to take it personally only you know. No were did I see slinky reference YOU as being over weight. You really need to sit back and have a think about this Willow, was it comments made by slinky that you have taken personally yourself or has Gary managed to make you believe it was aimed at you, being, as you say the only large lady to post in the thread? You’ve go to admit when he uses someone so blatantly in pain about a situation she has no control over, it doesn’t half strengthen his argument ;)


As slinky has said, she has no issue with her weight, it just bugs the life out of her, as it does me, having to endure years of comments such as,” God aren’t you skinny” or “God your sister is skinny”. You say you would never make a comment like that Willow, no of course you wouldn’t, you know how it feels just in an opposite respect.


It’s a shame this conversation has to be had over a pc or you would see how sincere I am when I say this thread was not at aimed at you. As others have said, which I whole heartedly agree with, you are a wonderful person, why you feel the need to worry about your weight I don’t know. You’re just our Willow off accyweb. :) I hope one day, for yourself, you can find some personal peace with your size, as I can see how raw your feelings are.


Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda
certainly wasn't present in some of the foul mouthed posts from the early hours of Sunday morning, that have since been deleted




People in glass houses Gary, your nasty little comments directed at my sister at the start of this thread were far from funny or polite. You never fail to surprise me the lengths you will go to when you’re backed into a corner. I hope you’re happy with the amount of people you’ve managed to upset in this thread! In fact, I know you will be! Feel free to exonerate yourself of any upset caused, I know you won’t have a problem doing so, at least that way it keeps your conscience clear.


Slinky still hasn’t had any pm’s from these women you say she’s supposedly upset by the way, fictitious, again to strengthen your argument? Yes probably.

CASPER 06-11-2006 14:09

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
I said GROUP HUG folks!!!!!

There's not enough love in this thread

WillowTheWhisp 06-11-2006 14:50

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
The reason why I personally have an issue with my weight is that being so much overweight as I am is a health problem just as being too much underweight is a health problem. Where the people in the TV program I watched have damaged their internal organs by dieting from naturally slim to unnaturally thin they have lost the weight intentionally. My problems are beginning to affect my health and I need to be able to find a solution to them or I have as much chance of dying from them as an annorexic has of starving herself to death, but I have not gained the weight intentionally, I have gained it as a by-product of trying to lose in order to fit better into bum hugging jeans. Trying to lose caused me to gain which then left other people (my doctor included) telling me I needed to lose weight for the sake of my health.

At one time I used to visit a gym 3 nights a week (before I had kids and had more time to myself) and although larger than all the other people there I was actually fitter than most and able to demonstrate to newcomers how to do some of the excercises, under the direction of the owner. The newbies were quite surprised that this podgy person was more agile and supple than they were but that was only because they hadn't had as much practice (or indeed any practice in some cases). At one point I trapped a nerve whilst at the gym - my own fault for not doing what I always told other people to make sure they did carefully - and I ended up having to see a chiropractor. He, like my doctor, told me I needed to lose weight and made the flippant remark that of course eating less would solve it because you didn't see any fat people coming out of Belsen. My response to that was that you didn't see any healthy people coming out of Belsen either.

Both you Tinkerbelle and Slinky have obviously, from what you've said, had nasty cutting remarks made about you which are totally unjustified and I can appreciate your anger at the people who directed those nasty remarks to you and made stupid suggestions that you need to eat when you already do eat. Be angry with those idiots by all means but why be angry with people who did not direct any insults to either of you? You are healthy and slim and not dieting due to some ill-conceived notion that you need to lose weight (as unfortunately many young girls do when they see these impossible role models); it's the people who tell you that you need to gain who are idiots who don't know what they are talking about. Their ignorance in saying the things they have said to you is pathetic and probably more to be pitied than anythng. You are obviously the right healthy weight for who you are and that isn't in dispute. I don't see where it ever has been.

However, when my weight is causing me health problems as well as causing me to be on the receiving end of names like 'fat pig' or 'fat cow' it is something which I would dearly love to solve. If the name calling hurts you when you are healthy can you imagine how much more it hurts someone who is unhealthy? Can you imagine what it is like to take your kids to McDonalds on holiday and have some ignorant yobbo shout "Oi missus are you trying to make them as fat as you?"

If I was just slightly plump with no health problems and past caring about trying to fit into a pair of jeans that wouldn't zip up unless I laid flat on the bed and pulled my tummy in then I'd probably shrug off the insults and get on with life but it isn't the words like "fat" and "obese" (which is the medically accurate term for someone my size) which worry me - althopugh I don't like being called a cow or a pig - it is the fact that my health is suffering and yes to be perfectly honest I do think that a slim person looks far more attractive than an obese one. I can't imagine anyone would really honestly argue the opposite. I have to undergo an operation in the not too distant future and size is a major factor in whether or not I wll survive it. No doubt if I pop my clogs some ignorant fool like the ones who've taunted you two will say it's my own fault for being so fat - but as I won't be around to hear it I don't suppose it will matter to me by then. It might just upset my girls though.

How I managed to take the fat cow comments personally was when I saw the reference to a large person having posted in the thread and I was the only large person to have done so. As I said before, Gary and I had talked about other things - I had told him that I had inadvertantly got the wrong side of Gayle in her funding thread (but susequently she understood where I'd got the impression it was for arts projects as she was the one who posted that it was for talented artists) and the wrong side of you two in the custodial sentences thread (which is how it looked at the time) and I said I had better just keep out of AccyWeb discussions because I was getting everyone annoyed - or words to that effect. I also told him that I understood what he and Gayle were referring to about the models. Maybe it's just because we were on the same wavelength about not approving of the image the model industry presents due to one of his friends having died of annorexia and my friend's daughter being in danger of going the same way as she is naturally slim but dieting to get thinner.

garinda 08-11-2006 08:10

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
http://casadesign.free.fr/images/anorexia_3.jpg

Mick 08-11-2006 08:27

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
It does not matter what your size is its what's inside that counts.
I have made a lot of friends here on Accyweb,
I dont care what size,colour, shape,age ect they are you are all good mates and fun to be with.
I just love YOU ALL
now can we stop this and get back to the thread ta:) :) PLEASE

WillowTheWhisp 08-11-2006 08:59

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Er, I thought this thread was about size, hence it being cut off like from t'other one about t'fashion parade. ;)

WillowTheWhisp 08-11-2006 09:00

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda

Who IS that?

garinda 08-11-2006 10:33

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Again I would like to appologise for the hurt I caused because of the thoughless terminology I used earlier.

However I do think it is a serious issue.

An interesting note about the issue of the fashion industy's attitude to size can be seen on Channel 5's programme Make me a Supermodel.

I mentioned before that one of the girls is a single mum from Wigan. She gets hassle from the judges all the time because they tell her she's too big to be a model. She was measured last night and weighed, and has actually gained weight and put two inches on her waist size in the three weeks she's been on the programme.

Each week the judges, Rachel Hunter, Dylan Jones, Tandy the owner of one of the UK's top model agencies, and a photographer, put up the models who haven't in their eyes followed their advice. Jen the Wigan lass was put up for the public vote last week, and the public voted to save her. Mainly because she has a cracking sense of humour as well as being gorgeous.

Ironically, even though she isn't the judges favourite to win, and if the public vote her as the ultimate winner, she will struggle to find work as a model because she isn't the perfect sample size.


jen's gallery | make me a supermodel | five.tv

garinda 08-11-2006 10:35

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp
Who IS that?

Krizia model on the catwalk this Spring in Milan.

Neil 08-11-2006 11:02

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp
Who IS that?

More like WHAT is that.

WillowTheWhisp 08-11-2006 11:24

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by garinda

I mentioned before that one of the girls is a single mum from Wigan. She gets hassle from the judges all the time because they tell her she's too big to be a model. She was measured last night and weighed, and has actually gained weight and put two inches on her waist size in the three weeks she's been on the programme.

I bet she's been dieting to try to lose weight to please the judges and in her case it's having the opposite effect just like I described with me - whatever small amount she does eat is automatically being turned to fat.

It is wrong, wrong, wrong for the judges to keep perpetuating this harmful ideal.

WillowTheWhisp 08-11-2006 11:27

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
I've just been looking at those pics and Jen is absolutely gorgeous.

garinda 08-11-2006 12:36

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp
I've just been looking at those pics and Jen is absolutely gorgeous.

She is.

Sadly the judges decided to put her up for the public vote again this week, citing her weight as the reason. After leaving the room she then went white and fainted.

It showed a clip from the next programme, and in it she explains why she fainted. Lets hope she hasn't been making herself sick or starving herself in a last ditch attempt to win over the judges.:(

A close relative, sporty, healthy and intelligent, and ten years old, told me this week at my Mum's birthday tea that she needs to lose three pounds. That I find sick.

WillowTheWhisp 08-11-2006 13:16

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Oh I wish I could get hold of those judges and bash their heads together! Trouble is as a fat person I would never be taken seriously they'd just say I was jealous.

In a way I do hope the reason she fainted is that she's been making herself ill trying to get thin enough to please the judges and I hope the media kick up an almighty stink about it and perhaps people will start to get real.

I've just been thinking (it happens sometimes) following a little chat I've just had (in real life) on this very subject. If there weren't all these offensively starved bodies portrayed as ideals then perhaps normal slim people wouldn't be subjected to insults about their size which imply that they are annorexic. They'd just be seen as one of the many varied examples of normal because we wouldn't have been bombarded with anything abnormal.

Just a thought.

harwood red 08-11-2006 14:13

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp

I've just been thinking (it happens sometimes) following a little chat I've just had (in real life) on this very subject. If there weren't all these offensively starved bodies portrayed as ideals then perhaps normal slim people wouldn't be subjected to insults about their size which imply that they are annorexic. They'd just be seen as one of the many varied examples of normal because we wouldn't have been bombarded with anything abnormal.

Just a thought.

Hee hee, that real life chat wasn't the one with me by any chance was it willow???? :D :rolleyes:

WillowTheWhisp 08-11-2006 14:14

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Nah, it was one of the cats! :D

harwood red 08-11-2006 14:16

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by WillowTheWhisp
Nah, it was one of the cats! :D

Hmph, well I'm not coming round to yours again if you think I'm one of your cats now!!!!! :D

WillowTheWhisp 08-11-2006 14:52

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
2 Attachment(s)
http://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/a...1&d=1163001071


http://www.accringtonweb.com/forum/a...1&d=1163001071

lindsay ormerod 08-11-2006 17:24

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
It's a sad world we live in;my daughter's father is of the opinion that she is overweight and has told her so,very helpful for a hormonal 10 year old to hear that! She is turning into a young lady and developing virtually before our eyes! She is never gonna be Kate Moss as I am 5ft 4.5 and her dad is about the same,neither of us are slim so what does he expect! It's a constant struggle to get her to focus on the more important things in life and realise that we love her as she is!

garinda 08-11-2006 17:45

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lindsay ormerod
It's a sad world we live in;my daughter's father is of the opinion that she is overweight and has told her so,very helpful for a hormonal 10 year old to hear that! She is turning into a young lady and developing virtually before our eyes! She is never gonna be Kate Moss as I am 5ft 4.5 and her dad is about the same,neither of us are slim so what does he expect! It's a constant struggle to get her to focus on the more important things in life and realise that we love her as she is!

I've met your beautiful daughter, and she is a star. It just seems sad that young girls, and increasingly boys, are being taught to become body concious at such a young age, this is nothing to do with health.

There is plenty of time for us to develop neurosis as adults, without screwing up the next generation now. Let them enjoy their childhoods, without all this b*llocks about wanting to have the perfect body, which is foisted upon us by the fashion industry and the media, and which most of us will never obtain anyway.

WillowTheWhisp 08-11-2006 18:21

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
I wouldn't mind so much if it was actually perfect but this image we are faced with isn't perfect it's unrealistic and abnormal.

I just showed 2 images to my daughters and asked for opinions. The first was that back view of a spine and ribs with a few bits of cloth draped across them. Don't tell me there's anyone in Accy who looks like that so why do we have models who look like that? The response was "yeeeeeeee-uew!" and "OH MY GOSH!"

The second was of Jen from the website in that link. The response was "She's nice and slim."

When I told them that she had been told to lose weight because she's too fat to be a model Mimi said "You're kidding! She ain't fat. She's slim!" (I'd have preferred her to have said "isn't" ;) ) Emz just said "Flip!"

LancYorkYankee 09-11-2006 15:32

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
1 Attachment(s)
Okay, looks like this thread has finally run out of steam. I truly hope so many of these "intense" discussions don't cause any lasting damage to relationships. As in real life, families fight and families make up (most times). I hope a few p.m. are sent to ensure wounds are healed eh. Not a sermon, just a thought!

Plus, as you all can see by the latest entrance in Gayle's show. No others need apply!:D

Keep Smiling!

Brian

Sparkologist 09-11-2006 19:36

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
Judging by the way you strike a pose, Garinda will be looking over his shoulder! :D

Has anyone else notised the old boy in the foreground giving it the "Peter Kay" treatment? :rolleyes:

garinda 11-11-2006 11:41

Re: Portrayal of women: (split)
 
I'm not reigniting this thread to cause offence, just to let you know what happened on Make me a Supermodel last night, for those of you who may have a life, and were probably doing something more interesting on a Friday night instead.:D

Jen, the Mum from Wigan, again faced the public vote for the second time because she's put on weight whilst taking part of the programme. In the live catwalk walk off they showed a VT clip were she talked about her weight and the pressure she felt under to conform. She looked stunning, but was told by the judges she had a pretty face but was too fat to be a successful model. Rachel Hunter really layed into her for using the clip about her weight to gain votes.

It's quite ironic, Rachel Hunter was never a supermodel, she only found success after she married Rod Stewart. Another of the judges Tandy who runs one of the biggest model agencies, is a larger women to put it politely.

Anyway the public voted to keep Jen in, and next week she's in the final four to win the modelling contract. I was so incensed at the way she was treated I, for the first time ever in a reality show, texted my vote to keep her in.

The thing is even if the public vote her the winner she won't get much work as a model because she has hips and isn't a perfect sample size, but hopefully she will get other work because she has a great personality, as well as being beautiful.


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:19.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1
© 2003-2013 AccringtonWeb.com