![]() |
Bank Charges
My wife has had notification this morning from The Halifax bank that a cheque drawn on her account has been sent back and a charge of £39.00 has been levied.
The account would have been overdrawn by 6p. Our pension goes into this bank every Monday. My wife has spoken to a representative of the bank about these charges and they refuse point blank to credit the account with the charges. I believe this is robbery and a very easy way to make money for nothing? I have been keeping up to speed with the current court cases that are going on at the moment about bank charges but it seems that these vultures are going to get away with it unless the government stand on their toes. The lobby for banks in Westminster is very strong and I would like to know (I doubt if I ever will) When the banks are going to be brought in line by the government? |
Re: Bank Charges
I was under the impression that they can't do this and people have been winning in court, has this changed?
|
Re: Bank Charges
I would be down to local branch and get it wiped.
If its not a regular thing, ie this is you first OD for a while they usuall waver it. Ask for the complaints procedure and make a nucence (SP) in the branch, I would. Never take the first refusal they would have to tell me no at least 5 times before I would let it drop. After all its for 6p. |
Re: Bank Charges
I remember watching an article about this on GMTV last week ....... may be of some use hopefully GMTV - Are you the victim of unfair bank charges? Get advice from Martin Lewis of MoneySavingExpert.com
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
Bank have been settling out of court for fear of a judgement against them. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Roy you should of watch the money programme on bbc last month was all about bank charges and it calculated this 50 year old mans charges over the past 30 years and it was thousands and thousands a real lot of money and then he took the bank to court and got it all back.
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
They make millions a year from this scam and it seems that they expect it to continue? |
Re: Bank Charges
I agree, it is really annoying if that happens.:mad:
Most Halifax current accounts will allow you a free overdraft facility, which would prevent this from happening, but I think you have to request it, so it might be worth asking if your account has it. I very rarely write cheques nowadays, as it is harder to keep track of your balance, as they can be drawn on your account anytime, up to three months after writing them. As other people have said, go in and speak to someone, explain what happened, and there is a good chance they will cancel the fee. Good luck. |
Re: Bank Charges
As other people have said, go in and speak to someone, explain what happened, and there is a good chance they will cancel the fee.
Good luck.[/quote] My wife has rung the bank this morning and they flatly refuse to give credit. The person on the phone was quite rude saying it does not matter if it is 1p or £60 the charge is the same. |
Re: Bank Charges
The people who answer the phones for the Halifax are basically call centre workers, and as such may not be authorised to waive the fee. I'd definitely go into your branch, you usually get a more sympathetic response.
|
Re: Bank Charges
Go to the bank and make a fuss in front of other customers, make the bank look bad. :)
|
Re: Bank Charges
One other point.
If these charges are illegal, does anyone know of a mechanism or procedure that would stop them taking the money from the account on the 28th June as notified? I will go to the bank with my wife..........dont hold much hope though. |
Re: Bank Charges
Most bank charges are clearly stated, especially when it comes to being overdrawn. The amount, though aggravating, is irrelevant. I don't know if the charges are illegal, if they are clearly stated, and you've agreed to them when you opened your account.
Does your wife have a free overdraft facility on the account? I think most Halifax current accounts allow you up to a hundred pounds. |
Re: Bank Charges
Martin Lewis' site which was mentioned earlier is a brilliant place for financial advice -I use it a lot- the forums will give you an insight into what to do next.
PS just got £30 for switching fuel supplier (yet again!) |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
GMTV - Are you the victim of unfair bank charges? Get advice from Martin Lewis of MoneySavingExpert.com We do not have an overdraft facility (Never needed one or requested one from the Halifax) She joined the Halifax many years ago and they wer'nt charging £39.00 then. They moved the goalpost not us |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
The overdraft facility is free, and will prevent this from happening in the future. |
Re: Bank Charges
I had that the other week not with the Halifax though and i rang them up and said what are you playing at cos my money went in on the same day the cheque had gone through its just that the money went in after the cheque was presented - the bank credited me the charges.
|
Re: Bank Charges
Banks do not really want private accounts, they make nothing on them, they are like insurance companies who would not insure private cars if the law did not requre them to do so, they only want to insure property etc.
You are in a catch 22 situation Royboy39, not a big enough fish to rock the banks boat, or attract another bank. The Halifax i'm afraid has gone downhill since merging with the banks. I am with the Yorkshire and had the same problem through an oversight on my part, I rang the Bank who then rang the branch and they rectified the matter the same day, so they are not all as bad as those you are unfortunately dealing with, anyway keep at them you can only gain by making noises. |
Re: Bank Charges
I am currently going through court with my bank to reclaim my charges, I have went through the correct procedure for doing it all - started way back in april..and I am finally at the courts with it...just waiting on a date for my hearing....and I know folk will say you should manage your account better but I dont have a problem with being charged - its the amount they charge...
and although the martin lewis site is ok - I have used this one..which gives you all court documents too and also what to put on them...really good forum for anyone wanting to know more about it all... Penalty Charges Forum - Powered by vBulletin |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
Is this the first time your wife has ever gone overdrawn? If it is you should go into your Halifax branch and ask for the fee to be waived on this occasion - the branch manager has the authority to waive the fee if it is the first time you have incurred one. On the all subject of bank charges, the majority of current account customers never incur any charges asthey manage their accounts within the terms of the account and never go overdrawn. As a result of the few who do incur penalties trying to get their charges back, it is highly likely free current accounts will go and everyone will be charged a monthly fee for having a current account. Why should the majority be penalised because of the minority. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
Can I assume from your comments that you have never made a mistake on your account and that you are in favour of the bank charging ridiculous and excessive charges for work that is done by a machine? Our case has been resolved by going through the complaints procedure where common sense prevailed. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
I have been in Accrington branch of Halifax many time to enquire about my account, overdraft ect and not once have I been made to ring, there is usually someone at the special counter near the door, cant harm to speak to them. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
I think they treat personal accounts as a non entity, business accounts are different. The young lady said no-one at the branch could deal with the account and I said we were directed to use the telephone. The call center operator did not want to know and refused to credit the account, however when we got home a call was made to the complaints department and they were prepared to listen and deal with the problem on it's merits . The charge was cancelled |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
We've done the whole bash banks thing previously.
I work for one, they are a business, they make money for their shareholders, the vast majority of profit comes from business/investment/credit side of the business. To run a current account costs money. Have you ever stopped to work out how much is invested in ATM networks? the bank I work for has > 2000 machines each costing significantly over £100K, then you have software costs and supply/maintainence on top. how much do you pay to use your own banks machines, nowt, nadda. likewise you walk into a branch(Costs money to buy and run) speak to staff(Wages) who access systems(Mega Millions of pounds worth) who deal automagically with billions of payments each week, making sure your DD's, STO and cheques etc all get paid. They look after your cash (from £1 to £XXXXXXXX's) in a secure manner that you can't lose out as they are managed by FSA regulations. what does this cost you? £NOWT. When you opened an account you were all given a full T&Cs which outlined all charges etc but as is usual nobody can be bothered to read it so you just sign that you accept it without so much as a cursory glance. Then when you get charged for going outside what you agreed to you complain. IS £40 outrageous, possibly, what the whole claim your bank charges things is about is NOT the behaviour of charging you, only what that charge should be. The steer is that they should charge you something like what the actual cost to the bank is (commonly quoted at £15) yet this does not take into account anything of teh infrastructure costs I outlined above. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
If I charged any of my customers a "Fee" for making a mistake the business would not last very long. Why should banks, and now the utility companies get away with it? |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
You quite clearly do need an overdraft facility. If you have one and do not use it there is no charge. If you'd had one and gone overdrawn by 6p the interest charged would have been minimal compared to the £39 fee incurred for a returned cheque. It may not please the person to whom the cheque was returned either as their bank may well charge them for representing it. You could save a lot of problems all round by taking the overdraft facility option. When any goalposts are moved, charge increases and so on, customers are informed. Of course the local manager has a say in the refunding of charges. Perhaps you were fobbed off with the telephone if you were becoming stroppy in the branch and no-one wanted to deal with you. I have often found that a polite request accompanied by an explanation of the error and oversight, with intentions made clear that it will not occur again is more likely to be listened to with a sympathetic ear than marching in with all guns blazing and a determination to have a row in front of all the other customers as previously suggested. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
I admit that I do waffle on most occasions Roy but in this case it was a seriously thought out post with helpful advice but of course you may choose to ignore it if you wish.
I have over 20 years of banking experience but of course you know much more about it than I do. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
and yes I probably do. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
As regards my attitude to bank charges - yes I have made mistakes in the past, but accept that I have to pay for them. As Entwisi says there are lots of costs involved with servicing free current accounts, and I strongly object to the fact that because of a minority of people who can't manage their money properly the majority are probably going to be peanalised. Why should I (and others who do not allow their accounts to go overdrawn - beyond any agreed overdfarft facility) pay for the actions of a few. As regards not being informed of changes to the conditions of your Halifax current account - whenever the conditions are revised, there is a leaflet enclosed with your statement of account. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
I'm also a customer so I deal with banks from your 'sharp end' too - only I'm not quite so sharp about it and we usually manage to reach an amicable agreement.
I know my old manager would never refund charges to someone he referred to as "the cantankerous old bleep bleep" who stormed into the branch effing and blinding but he would listen sympathetically to an explanation by someone of a simple oversight or miscalculation, refund the charges, and offer suggestions (such as the free overdraft facility) as to how they could avoid any future problems. |
Re: Bank Charges
In answer to both Claytonender and Willow:
I have had enough experience not to go in anywhere with guns blazing. I am quite articulate and can express my feelings without ranting and raving. I would like to know when either of you have been into a Halifax branch to discuss your Personal account and spoke to the manager about it, thats if you are not asking for an overdraft or discussing investments which would probably gain his/her attention? |
Re: Bank Charges
I don't have a Halifax account - but if I did have I would take advantage of the free overdraft facility. ;)
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Your (unused) overdraft facility would not keep any cats fat. It's just like a note on your account to say that it has been agreed that you are allowed to go overdrawn by £X. Unless you do overdraw the account you will not pay anything.
It would however provide a safety net for any possible future occasion where you or your wife miscalculate again by 6p. The interest charged on an overdraft of 6p would be negligable. You quite clearly do need the overdraft to cover such eventualities or you wouldn't have had the problem in the first place. All you are doing by refusing to accept the available facility is cutting off your own nose to spite your face. It's not a suggestion that you keep your account in a permanently negative state, just a safeguard against any possible future bouncing cheques. We've got a Nationwide account with an overdraft facility of £300 but the account remains in the black. It doesn't cost anything when it's in the black but if we had a technical hitch and the goings in were delayed and didn't go in until after the comings out had come out the facility would kick into action and nothing would bounce. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
Then you should have advised your wife to take advantage of the free overdraft facility...and then no charges would have been levied against her account in the first place.:) Lots of people in this thread have been sympathetic, and given useful advice as well, what you chose to do with it is up to you, but I just hope there isn't another thread moaning about it in the future, if you don't.:D As for banking compared to other businesses, most companies receive a discount if prompt payement is forthcoming, and are charged on a gradually increasing scale if it isn't. Not rocket science, just simple economics, and not just confined to banking. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
I do take advice when i'ts offered in good faith. Do I have to ask your permission to post a thread on any subject? As for your last comment - nothing to do with the thread at all |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
'I know how much it cost to run a business, I have run three. If I charged any of my customers a "Fee" for making a mistake the business would not last very long. Why should banks, and now the utility companies get away with it?' Banks are business, there to make a profit, not state run monopolies, and if you are clever you don't have to add to their profits, in this case by taking advantage of their free overdraft facility.:) |
Re: Bank Charges
I think some of the perception around this is that the banks are effectively charging you for making a 'mistake'. IMHO you are as a responsible adult in charge of your own finances. You choose to use the services of a bank and accept that if you transgress certain parameters then you will be charged. The bank is not doing anything that it hasn't already told you it will. You just choose to ignore the fact and being perfectly honest it almost sounds like you don't want to take responsibility for your actions. i.e. your wife allowed herself to write a cheque knowing that there might be a chance that it would be presented to your bank before the funds were available. That was a gamble she took and lost. Would you complain to a bookie that you accidentally wrote the wrong horses name down?
As an owner of 3 companies how would you feel if you weren't allowed to make a profit on something that costs you money to provide? You wouldn't be in business for long. |
Re: Bank Charges
[quote=entwisi;440302]I think some of the perception around this is that the banks are effectively charging you for making a 'mistake'. IMHO you are as a responsible adult in charge of your own finances. You choose to use the services of a bank and accept that if you transgress certain parameters then you will be charged. The bank is not doing anything that it hasn't already told you it will. You just choose to ignore the fact and being perfectly honest it almost sounds like you don't want to take responsibility for your actions. i.e. your wife allowed herself to write a cheque knowing that there might be a chance that it would be presented to your bank before the funds were available. That was a gamble she took and lost. Would you complain to a bookie that you accidentally wrote the wrong horses name down?
I think you have misread this was a mistake not a gamble. You would have to take the banks point of view because you work for them that is why your response sounds a bit "off pat" If your comment is to be taken seriously why are bank charges under investigation with the OFT and why have so many people been able to reclaim bank charges and are continuing to reclaim? |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
As you said earlier all charges, and changes in those charges, are sent out to all the bank's customers. It isn't about moving the goal posts, more about paying attention, and observing prudence, and taking advantage of services that this particular bank offers, which if they had, would have resulted in no charges at all being levied...and I'm not a banker.:D |
Re: Bank Charges
Also just to add the halifax has a very good internet banking site.
This can help keeping track of your account to make sure you dont fall into the overdrawn trap and get charged. Saved me on a few occasions.:) |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
You also seem quite incapable of accepting advice about a free overdraft facility - which makes good sense, because as Willow says there are some occasions when salary credits etc are late being credited into an account. Having a free overdraft facility means that you will not incur any bank charges for debits which bounce because of insufficient funds. It also makes sense to have internet banking, then you can check your bank balance daily. I only ever keep a balance of about £15.00 in my Halifax current account, but because I have a free overdraft facility I know that if I pay using my debit card or cheque there will always be funds to clear the payment. Then I go online and transfer money from my websaver account (which pays 5.05% interest - before tax) into my cheque account to cover the money I have spent. That way I never get any bank charges and get a reasonable rate of interest on my money. For someone whom purports to have run three businesses you do not appear to be aufait with how to run an account to your advantage rather than to the banks. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
This is looked upon my many more learn-ed than me or you as a fine and not a fee. I dont purport to have run 3 businesses, I have, luckily now retired I dont have to put up with bank rights or wrongs. This is not about whether or not to take advice, I have taken that on board and will use that advice if it suits me. At the moment IT DOES NOT. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
As for only taking the advice that suits you -well you are obviuosly very pigheaded - the only reason I can see that you started this post was for everyone to agree with you, you obviuosly can't cope with being corrected. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
How on earth can a miscalculation of 6p be seen in any way shape or form as fraud. Fraud is a deliberate attempt to defraud in the eyes of the law. What is against the law is anyone who administers a fine disguised as a fee when not authorised to do so. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
'I know how much it cost to run a business, I have run three.' Make your mind up. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
As the fees are clearly stated and circulated, as a leaflet enclosed with your wife's statements, whenever they change. How can it be a fine? When you ran a business did you not make your customer's pay to the terms which you clearly set out to them. Halifax mailing out there revised terms of busines is no different. Did the batteries run out in her calculator or did she run out of fingers in her calculations and have to use her toes. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
Hope you've got your bank details sorted out, for when they pay your pension into your bank account in Spain.:D |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
Have you been reading "Eats, Shoots and leaves" ? :D A panda walks into a café. He orders a sandwich, eats it, then draws a gun and fires two shots in the air. "Why?" asks the confused waiter, as the panda makes towards the exit. The panda produces a badly punctuated wildlife manual and tosses it over his shoulder. "I'm a panda," he says at the door. "Look it up." The waiter turns to the relevant entry and, sure enough, finds an explanation. "Panda. Large black-and-white bear-like mammal, native to China. Eats, shoots and leaves." So punctuation really does matter, even if it is only occasionally a matter of life and death. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
It's as clear as mud now. |
Re: Bank Charges
You might find banking in Spain is a little costlier than it is here. Are you going to complain when they levy their perfectly legal charges?
6p or £6,000 writing a cheque when you have insufficient funds to cover the cheque is illegal. Writing a cheque when you have insufficient funds to cover it but do have an agreed overdraft limit is perfectly fine. Quote:
The advice you choose to ignore would actually be of benefit to you. You claim to have taken it on board but still intend to ignore it. I cannot for the life of me see any sense in that. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
I have'nt got a bank manager anymore I deal with a call center. I will look at the overdraft facilty and it's benefits or otherwise. OK |
Re: Bank Charges
It seems to me that you have two choices. 1) Make sure you have enough money in your account before you write checks. B) Get overdraft protection.
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
I think Roy should pay a fee, to all the kind people who have offered advice for free in this thread.:D
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
The correct use of punctuation would have helped. |
Re: Bank Charges
I've posted this before in the dim and distant past, but for those who haven't seen it:
The Importance of Correct Punctuation -unknown -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Dear John: I want a man who knows what love is all about. You are generous, kind, thoughtful. People who are not like you admit to being useless and inferior. You have ruined me for other men. I yearn for you. I have no feelings whatsoever when we're apart. I can be forever happy--will you let me be yours? Gloria -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Dear John: I want a man who knows what love is. All about you are generous, kind, thoughtful people, who are not like you. Admit to being useless and inferior. You have ruined me. For other men, I yearn. For you, I have no feelings whatsoever. When we're apart, I can be forever happy. Will you let me be? Yours, Gloria |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
He could be in for a whale of a time in Spain then; everything takes 3 times as long ,my mum waited over a year for a cheque book !
|
Re: Bank Charges
Do they still pay for all transactions over there Lindsay?
|
Re: Bank Charges
Not sure about that but I do know that it's usually painstakingly slow to do anything !
|
Re: Bank Charges
Can anyone lend me a tenner. I promise to pay you back-------sometime.
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
He's going to have fun there then. :D
|
Re: Bank Charges
[quote=Royboy39;440366]
I dont purport to have run 3 businesses, I have, luckily now retired I dont have to put up with bank rights or wrongs. You're right there Willow.A simple full stop after 'have' would have saved all the confusion:) Should have been 'I don't purport to have run three businesses,I have.Luckily now retired I don't have to put up with bank rights or wrongs.' Sorry Royboy,not trying to pull you to pieces here,it just confused us for a bit that's all.Just like eats shoots and leaves that someone mentioned earlier:D |
Re: Bank Charges
[quote=Lilly;440499]
Quote:
One of the business I had was in Spain and by reason of your response to my question to Willow I now realise that you have not got a clue. Punctuation or not pure guesswork will find you out in the end. A cheque book in Spain is worthless (Cash is King). Monies can be transferred within Spain for little or no cost. If you are transferring money out of Spain that will cost the same as it does transferring money from the UK to any European country. I do take on board what is said on this forum but if your are second guessing or making up a senario which makes no sense whatsoever,,,, KEEP YOU FINGER THAT TAPS NONSENSE IN YOUR POCKET |
Re: Bank Charges
Roy, all you appear to want to do in your recent posts is express your own self opinionated views. You appear to regard your own views as being sacroscant and try to ridicule anyone who disagrees with them.
In this thread several people have tried to help you, but you did not want help. You only wanted a forum to air your views and those of anyone who agreed with you. I stand by my posting that why should the majority of responsible holders of current accounts be expected to subsidise the irresponsible minority who expect to be able to overdraw their accounts with impunity. If you have run 3 business, as you claim to have, you should appreciate that being responsible in your financial dealings is of paramount importance. And no, I do not work for a bank, I am just one of the majority who will probably be penalised by the withdrawal of free current account banking by people who think like you do. People who are totally self centred and not prepared to accept that if you break the rules, you have to pay the penalty. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
(For some reason I wanted to write Mrs Warboys instead of Mrs Royboy, but then realised that she was the neighbour in One Foot in the Grave. I don't believe it! Silly me.) |
Re: Bank Charges
Yes this is how they make there money and i think there a rip off with there bank charge,s as well.
|
Re: Bank Charges
[quote=Royboy39;440554]
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
Widow Twanky - Old lady from the shoe - Simple Simon. (Or Buttons) I WILL TAKE THE ADVICE ON BOARD AND ACT ACCORDINGLY. The arrogance and ignorance of Simple Simon (Or Buttons) will be noted. I was thinking of naming Simple Simon as an ugly sister but that would offend them. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
Well he won't be Mother Goose, as she laid a golden egg, rather than bounce a cheque.;) |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
I only want one more to make up the cast. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
I wonder where that came from? |
Re: Bank Charges
What's a red mark and what's it mean?
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
I presume it was given to you this morning, but if you'd have shown a little initiative you could have hovered your cursor over my name and would have seen that I hadn't been online since thirteen minutes past midnight early this morning.:D Back to the drawing board as to who gave you bad karma.;) |
Re: Bank Charges
This is getting silly.
I've just given you some nice green karma, to make up for whoever gave you the negative karma. Have a good day.:) |
Re: Bank Charges
Couldn't have been me because I've been out, although I was here before I went. :D
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
Before you jump in with both feet mind you don't fall on your head again |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
I worked hard for that one |
Re: Bank Charges
Out of interest you have said that you have run 3 businesses, what line of work were you involved in.
|
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
|
Re: Bank Charges
Do not let it put you off Royboy 39, I for one and I know if the members did not like your threads, they would not respond to them, keep up the good work and enjoy the forum.;)
|
Re: Bank Charges
How this thread slipped through the nominations process, for an Accy Web award, is beyond me.:dummy2:
:D |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
It worked for me. |
Re: Bank Charges
Quote:
In the good old day's I had a five thousands pounds cushion.....my Mrs Meldrew did not because we thought it was not needed. Being in the same bank, the funds were there to transfer without question from my account in my name to that of my wife. I will explain that to you Jim because I think you are a free thinking person who does not wish to score brownie points |
All times are GMT. The time now is 14:03. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1
© 2003-2013 AccringtonWeb.com