![]() |
Hanging
Do you think murders would be reduced if the threat of hanging was brought back. I remember life in prison was voted for instead which does not happen.
|
Re: Hanging
To be honest i reckon if Life was to mean Life it may have more effect? personally i have nowt against topping em.
|
Re: Hanging
Well it will never be brought back claytonx, it wouldn't be so bad if murderer WERE sent down for life, I can never understand any judge saying I sentence you to life in prison and you'll serve a minimum of, say, 15 years, utter nonsense, say what you like about the American justice system, they do make the punishment fit the crime, pity we done follow suit here
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
And if Stefan Ivan Kiszko had been given the death penalty, what would you have said to his poor mother when he was finally cleared of Lesley Molseed's murder?
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
Canada's wrongful convictions - Canada - CBC News And to those, like Jaysay, who admire the American justice system: why don't capital punishment and heavy jail sentences seem to be working:confused: If they did work, the US wouldn't be the crime capital of the "civilized" world. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
But you guys must have some form of "real" life in prison. I know we do. The biggest punishment for first degree murder is 25 years before they have a chance to apply for parole. This, of course, doesn't mean they get out of jail after 25 yrs. The parole board can deny parole indefinitely. That seems to equal life to me. ... or at least the possibility of it. And you must have some form of "dangerous offender" status. This means the guy doesn't get out: period. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
I used to work in Salford, and that could be a bit rough, especially the walk from Salford Crescent railway station to my place of work. You had to walk under an underpass, and on a couple of occasions I was spat on by gangs hanging about.
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
with DNA today and it can be proved without a shadow of doubt murderers should be killed then tax payers money would not be wasted feeding and looking after them in prison
|
Re: Hanging
Ya what does it cost to keep Huntley in prison every year, around a million quid and rising, can think of better ways to spend that money
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
I could spend a million quid a lot better ways
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
They do say no one hanged for murder ever committed another one-or any other crime come to that.
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
A death penalty for me is impossible to defend in a civilized society. What do you think are the particular set of circumstances in Canada that make the lowering of the crime rate a reality? Do you think that it has something to do with the quality of life that you have over there? Is it something to do with the style of policing? Is there just a different mentality among the population which is successfully transmitted to the young - do you think that people have greater hope of having decent prospects and a better life? So many of our young people are disillusioned with what the UK/ Europe can offer -the future seems pretty dismal and perhaps that is a factor affecting the crime rate here (undoubtedly it was a factor in the summer riots both in the UK and Italy). |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
Could be that we rank 228th in the world in terms of population density, at 3.41 per square kilometer.:D Even with a tory government, right wing stuff like not allowing gay marriage, abortions, and capital punishment don't seem to bother most Canadians. We are a live and let live bunch. The only thing that really gets us going is hockey. Vancouver Riot 2011 - YouTube |
Re: Hanging
[quote=Eric;958946]Maybe because, in general, we're a happy bunch of hosers over here.;)
Could be that we rank 228th in the world in terms of population density, at 3.41 per square kilometer.:D Even with a tory government, right wing stuff like not allowing gay marriage, abortions, and capital punishment don't seem to bother most Canadians. We are a live and let live bunch. The only thing that really gets us going is hockey. Think you've hit the nail on the head there Eric, population density is an important factor affecting everything. (Think "lemmings"!) And;) the only time you guys get mad is when there are a lot of you in a confined space - eg hockey matches:D |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
Perhaps if we made hangings public again it would be more of a deterrent? |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
George Carlin - Death Penalty - YouTube |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
Sorry, Eric, I was just stirring it a bit. I wouldn't like to see the Death Penalty brought back, hopefully we've moved on from there. BUT(conjunction) I don't believe that currently the punishment for the ultimate crime matches that crime! Sky tv,laptops, xboxes, pool tables, 3 good meals a day, central heating, drugs, mobile phones etc., etc., And(conjunction) a life sentence that is NOT for life! Hell, I'm on the outside and I haven't got all that! |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Maybe we should put all the old folk in prison and the crims in the old folks homes...now that would be a bit of justice...especially if the crims had to pay for the pleasure of being 'looked after'.
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
( It was too clever for me to have thought of myself! He probably realizes that now). However, there was a lot of truth in it! |
Re: Hanging
The so called 'Season of Good Will' has so far seen five murders (that we know of) committed in the UK. This demonstrates to me that the so called gang culture among the youth of this country is turning them into little more than savages. I would happily see the culprits strung up if it were proven beyond doubt that they were guilty of the offence charged.
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
Secondly, I don't think it would be a deterent as most murders are either in the heat of the moment after provocation or by psychopaths. The logical thought process of crime and punishment doesn't really come into it. Thirdly, as mentioned by other Posters, it doesn't work in other countries such as the USA which are some of the most violent in the world. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
If prison is so cushy why doesn't everyone want to be in there. I don't see queues of people begging to be sent down for a life of luxury.
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
If we could prove beyond doubt, and I do have my reservations, we should bring back the Death Penalty.
However the current penal system is far too soft. So instead of reform, why don't we adopt a similar system to the French, punish offenders. Life imprisonment should mean that, not release after 14 years or so, gun/knife crime should carry a minimum term of, say 10 years. Introduce the Three Strikes System, similar to the one that they use in Califonia, might be an idea. Let's get rid of tv's, games, comforts etc in prison. Make the crime pay |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
I have never been in one even to visit so I don't have first-hand experience. I certainly wouldn't want to end up in one and lose all my liberties and privacy. I have a friend who worked as a councellor for people who self-harmed in prisons in N.Ireland and it sounded pretty grim from what she could tell me. There are also a good number of people who are driven to suicide in prison don't forget and they are not all mass-murderers. I can understand the out-rage expressed at inmates getting board and lodgings effectively for free -surely some system of working for your upkeep could be introduced -I don't mean breaking rocks, of course, but something that would be useful and count as some form of pay-back to society. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Don't really know what it's like in prisons over here except to say there is over-crowding and a big problem with drugs/AIDS. This from TV reports not any personal experience or info from friends.
I suppose the Human Rights brigade have made life cushier for many in UK jails -stories heard of peoples rights to have children even when in for life etc. The SKY exposée earlier this year was pretty shocking - very lax security and lack of discipline. Perhaps they could do with a few of our old nuns from school to get them behaving!:D |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
Don't expect this argument to have much effect on the hang 'em high, bring back the lash crowd on here ... they seem to be beyond reason. It doesn't seem to matter to them that in Britain, and Canada for that matter, crime rates and recidivism rates are dropping owing to policies focussing on education and rehabilitation, rather than on punishment and deterrant. Someone mentioned in an earlier post that the UK had 5 murders over the holiday season (ok, Christmas;)) ... holy feces:eek: FIVE!!!!!!!!!!! In the Land of the Free, and the Home of the Electric Chair, this total reflects a slow wednesday in Detroit. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
Rehabilitation and education are fundamental if we expect offenders to be able to re-enter society and take up jobs. It is particularly hard for young people to manage this if they have no support network. Would you employ someone with a record or a person who has never offended? Time is one thing people have on their hands while in prison - it should be used constructively, learning useful skills and improving the possibility for an offender to become a full member of society once their sentence is completed. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
I would like to mention a case from personal experience and see what you think. I have visited five prisons in my time: Wormwood Scrubs, Dartmoor, Kingston (Portsmouth), Portland (Dorset) and Channings Wood (Devon) as a school friend of my partner was gaoled for life in the mid 1970s for stabbing his mother in law with whom he was having an affair at the time. He was still in prison in the 1990s so not all murderers get out after 10 or 12 years as has been suggested. Eventually he was sent to one of the prisons on the IOW, Parkhurst I think, where we did not visit him. He was hanged eventually... by his own hand. Now I don't know what mental problems he had, as I didn't know him before he went to prison, but I'm sure they didn't improve while he was inside. I also don't know why he was inside for so long. I think most murderers must have some degree of instability to do what they do. My question is - would it have been better to hang him on day 1 rather than try to sort him out? I don't agree with a life for a life but you can never tell whether someone will respond to rehabilitation attempts before they start. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
And I was interested to read that there is a Kingston Prison in Portsmouth. Kingston Pen, the oldest in English Canada, is in Portsmouth Village, Kingston. Inside Kingston Pen (1994) - YouTube Don't look much like a luxury hotel to me.:rolleyes: |
Re: Hanging
Oops ... sorry about the syntax; I was having a Yoda moment.;)
|
Re: Hanging
I mentioned Stefan Kiszko earlier in this thread. His life in prison was anything but a luxury. He was attacked on several occasions and constantly treated with contempt, not only by his fellow prisoners but also the guards. He endured 16 years of this until his release. He did not last long on the outside, probably because of the emotional scars of his life in prison. Oh, and let's not forget he was an innocent man.
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
In time, the convicted murderer will adjust to their incarceration and find within its limitations, time when they feel joy, times when they laugh, talk to their family, etc., but as the victim, no more are such opportunities available to them. Those that are pro death penalty feel it is society’s responsibility to step in and be the voice of the victim and determine what is a just punishment, for the victim not the criminal.
Think of the phrase itself, "life sentence." Does the victim get a "life sentence"? The victim is dead. To serve justice, that person who ended their life should have to pay with their own in order for the scale of justice to remain in balance. Opponents of capital punishment say, capital punishment is barbaric and cruel and has no place in a civilized society. It denies an individual of due process by imposing irrevocable punishment on them and depriving them from ever benefiting from new technology that may provide later evidence of their innocence. Murder in any form, by any person, shows a lack of respect for human life. For victims of murder, sparing the life of their killer is the truest form of justice that can be given to them. Opponents of the death penalty feel to kill as a way to "even out" the crime would only justify the act itself. This position is not taken out of sympathy to the convicted murderer but out of respect for his victim in demonstrating that all human life should be of value.My standing on what is a very emotive issue is that if there is no doubt capital punishment should be implemented, our justice system as it stands seems to be weighed very much in favour of the perpetrators of crime and not the victim. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
So...the two scummers who killed an innocent lad because of the colour of his skin have received minimum sentences of 15 years and 14 years 3 months. The judge said he couldn't give them longer because he was "constrained by Parliament".
THIS is why so many people clamour for a return to capital punishment. Because justice is so obviously not seen to be done in this country...and this is the fault of politicians of all parties who misrule us. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
The judge should beallowed to give two life sentences....to run consecutively...and even that would not be long enough for them.
I hope that when these two do go to Jail, their lives are made miserable by the Afro carribean population in the nick.....I hope one of them grasses up the other chaps who were in this gang of lads, on the night that Stephen Lawrence was murdered too. They thought they were home free.......no chance of being brought to justice. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
Had they been convicted at the first trial they would be out round about now.
The law should allow for the judge to add on extra years for the years that they avoided justice. And the mother who said her son was home at the time of the attack, should now be prosecuted for perjury and perverting the course of justice. |
Re: Hanging
Two down, three to go.
Gary Dobson and David Norris have been put away for a long, long time (although not as long as they should be!) The police have received fresh information that will hopefully lead to the conviction of Neil Acourt, Jamie Acourt and Luke Knight. They have already been branded 'murderers' And the public appetite is for them to be brought to justice. And they will, however long it takes. |
Re: Hanging
I'm sure that Knight and the Acourt boys are brickin' it right now.
|
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
I doubt this is over..these two are bound to appeal.
Never liked the US style of plea bargianing but can't see any of the accused "grassing" if they are likely to get the same sentence... these two may not be the one that stabbed the lad but they were there and involved .. but the one who committed the murder may still be free. |
Re: Hanging
Quote:
|
Re: Hanging
A contentious issue, to be sure.
Just to stir the waters a little, what would those who do not advocate a return to the death penalty do to rehabilitate this character..? Convicted killer Liam Ryan shows off his PlayStation, TV and snacks from inside young offenders institute cell | Mail Online |
All times are GMT. The time now is 16:40. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1
© 2003-2013 AccringtonWeb.com