Pointless discussing that once he's hanged.
Perhaps if we made hangings public again it would be more of a deterrent?
Hanging
- Thread starter claytonx
- Start date
Pointless discussing that once he's hanged.
Perhaps if we made hangings public again it would be more of a deterrent?
No it wouldn't ... would just mean that more sickos could get together and watch someone hang ... lot like a snuff movie, eh. Kinda like the hard-line islamists, who fill football stadiums with horny males getting their jollies from watching women being flogged.
George Carlin - Death Penalty - YouTube
Well Eric deterrent or no deterrent, why should scum like Brady, Sutcliffe, Neilson (who's now dead, thank god) and Huntley, who committed such atrocious murders, be locked up and cosseted for the rest of their miserable lives, with the cost to the tax payer running into millions of pounds, oh yes the warders have to call them MR as well, because they have rightsCanada's a very big country, home to many different races and cultures. We don't have the death penalty. And even (notice I began this sentence with a conjunction) without the death penalty, our murder rate is going down. In fact, the rates for all types of crime are on the way down. Point is though, if anyone could demonstrate to me ... logically, statistically, whatever -ally, that capital pusnishment is a deterrent to murder, I would be all in favour of it. But as far as I can see, it doesn't work as a deterrent. I know folks who are in favout of it for the wrong reasons: probably the decendants of those who did their knitting by the guillotine, or who got their jollies at Tyburn. But, as a deterrent to murder, it just doesn't work. And however many jerks, assholes, losers, etc. are hanged, fried, or shot, it will never work.
And I agree fully with what you say Eric
A death penalty for me is impossible to defend in a civilized society.
Well living in a civilised society, its best to put rabid dogs down, animals do not behave like some people claiming to be human beings, When your dealing with scum that act like rabid animals the only thing in my eyes is to put them down
Whatever turns you on!
Sorry, Eric, I was just stirring it a bit.
I wouldn't like to see the Death Penalty brought back, hopefully we've moved on from there.
BUT(conjunction) I don't believe that currently the punishment for the ultimate crime matches that crime!
Sky tv,laptops, xboxes, pool tables, 3 good meals a day, central heating, drugs, mobile phones etc., etc., And(conjunction) a life sentence that is NOT for life!
Hell, I'm on the outside and I haven't got all that!
How did the discussion get around to rabies
Seems like you are setting yourself up as judge and jury. Don't you guys already have a well-established system for that, one that has been around for, let me think ... at least the time of Henry ll?
The scum I mention are worse than Rabid Dogs, and were all convicted of outrageous murders, they were found guilty by a jury and to me should have been sentenced to 3 days in prison, then strung upHow did the discussion get around to rabies
Maybe we should put all the old folk in prison and the crims in the old folks homes...now that would be a bit of justice...especially if the crims had to pay for the pleasure of being 'looked after'.
Hey Ho, Margaret, that was one of my first threads and Less told me off for not saying it was a quote so I may have to rebuke you!
( It was too clever for me to have thought of myself! He probably realizes that now).
However, there was a lot of truth in it!
The so called 'Season of Good Will' has so far seen five murders (that we know of) committed in the UK. This demonstrates to me that the so called gang culture among the youth of this country is turning them into little more than savages. I would happily see the culprits strung up if it were proven beyond doubt that they were guilty of the offence charged.
The death penalty should not be brought for the simple reason that it would make us no better than they are. It sends out a message of inhumanity. An eye for an eye and the whole world turns blind.
Secondly, I don't think it would be a deterent as most murders are either in the heat of the moment after provocation or by psychopaths. The logical thought process of crime and punishment doesn't really come into it.
Thirdly, as mentioned by other Posters, it doesn't work in other countries such as the USA which are some of the most violent in the world.
I wasn't quoting from an e-mail or anything else in particular.........it just seems crazy that the old folk of this country can be cold, lonely and hungry while the miscreants(and that is just me being diplomatic) are looked after admirably....and all this is paid for by our taxes, whilst these old folk have to sell their homes to pay for their care. It just seems to me that society has its' values a bit skewed.
In a nutshell,society has gone nuts n conveniently ignores such stuff.
So are yeh content to leave it as is? doin about 10/12 years in relative comfort fer murder? cos yeh sure aint said yeh wanna change it.
you really are a plank,
i said relatively as regards to how many elderly have to live, and yeh avoided answering me question.
If we could prove beyond doubt, and I do have my reservations, we should bring back the Death Penalty.
However the current penal system is far too soft.
So instead of reform, why don't we adopt a similar system to the French, punish offenders.
Life imprisonment should mean that, not release after 14 years or so, gun/knife crime should carry a minimum term of, say 10 years.
Introduce the Three Strikes System, similar to the one that they use in Califonia, might be an idea.
Let's get rid of tv's, games, comforts etc in prison.
Make the crime pay
However the current penal system is far too soft.
So instead of reform, why don't we adopt a similar system to the French, punish offenders.
Life imprisonment should mean that, not release after 14 years or so, gun/knife crime should carry a minimum term of, say 10 years.
Introduce the Three Strikes System, similar to the one that they use in Califonia, might be an idea.
Let's get rid of tv's, games, comforts etc in prison.
Make the crime pay
Last edited:
I think you are right - it's too easy to think that all prisons are like hotels.
I have never been in one even to visit so I don't have first-hand experience. I certainly wouldn't want to end up in one and lose all my liberties and privacy.
I have a friend who worked as a councellor for people who self-harmed in prisons in N.Ireland and it sounded pretty grim from what she could tell me. There are also a good number of people who are driven to suicide in prison don't forget and they are not all mass-murderers.
I can understand the out-rage expressed at inmates getting board and lodgings effectively for free -surely some system of working for your upkeep could be introduced -I don't mean breaking rocks, of course, but something that would be useful and count as some form of pay-back to society.
Most decent people would have no wish to be in prison,thats rather obvious to me,
n aint seen anyone mention hotels? the conditions n facilities in prison are better than many good,elderly people enjoy, is that difficult fer some to grasp?
A couple of friends of mine are Magistrates, and they both went on a visit to Lancaster Farm, Young offenders institute. They both came to the conclusion that this was no deterrent what so ever, was like a 5 star hotel to some of them and the majority would rather be there than at home. This is significant with our penal system throughout, they are better treated than pensioners, thus the usual statement I can do the time stood on my head, now if we made the penal service a place where no body wants to return we'd be getting somewhere, I'm sure that criminals are not given the same consideration in Italy or anywhere else for that matter, because all the hand wringing woolly headed liberals live in good old Britain