Noel Gallagher Interview!

kestrelx · 30-03-2012, 23:30

Did anyone see the Noel Gallagher interview tonight with Mark Lawson?

Mark Lawson Talks to Noel Gallagher, 11.20pm, BBC4 - Entertainment - Corkman.ie

Noel claims Oasis are the biggest band ever and no one will ever touch them! What do you think about his claims? A product of his over blown ego?

Oasis bigger and better than U2? The Beatles? Everybody else who every played a guitar?

annesingleton · 30-03-2012, 23:48

Yes I've just watched it, I really like Noel Gallagher, I think he's a really intelligent, creative and interesting person. I can see where he's coming from retrospectively in that there aren't many people as famous as Oasis from that time, and I do think they were talented, but they were most definitely not the biggest band ever, there are far far bigger talents than them.

Restless · 30-03-2012, 23:57

Both of them Noel and Liam are pretentious aholes. Oasis' first album was quite good, then come a few good songs which turned out to b-sides from singles from the second album. Everything else is just bland, boring and soulless.

More annoyingly they seem to think they are on equal par to Lennon and the Beatles.

kestrelx · 31-03-2012, 00:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by annesingleton

Yes I've just watched it, I really like Noel Gallagher, I think he's a really intelligent, creative and interesting person. I can see where he's coming from retrospectively in that there aren't many people as famous as Oasis from that time, and I do think they were talented, but they were most definitely not the biggest band ever, there are far far bigger talents than them.

How did you swallow what he said about drugs - that it's part of the music game and that he's glad he took them, but no longer does take them! How do you square that with your attitudes to drugs

walkinman221 · 31-03-2012, 06:55

Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx

How did you swallow what he said about drugs - that it's part of the music game and that he's glad he took them, but no longer does take them! How do you square that with your attitudes to drugs

For gods sake change the record you are obsessed, people have disagreed with your view on drugs thats what debate is about. You seem to bring drugs into every post/thread you do.

jaysay · 31-03-2012, 08:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by walkinman221

For gods sake change the record you are obsessed, people have disagreed with your view on drugs thats what debate is about. You seem to bring drugs into every post/thread you do.

Well when drugs have shaped your life, people like birdy tend to keep harping on about then, its like an addiction really

jaysay · 31-03-2012, 08:06

If you've heard one Oasis record you've heard um all, gallagher was a legend in his own lunch hour

kestrelx · 31-03-2012, 08:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by walkinman221

For gods sake change the record you are obsessed, people have disagreed with your view on drugs thats what debate is about. You seem to bring drugs into every post/thread you do.

Your an idiot! I was asking a bonafida question! Anne said she liked Gallagher! He said he has taken drugs and is glad he did! When I said that, Anne was attacking me - bit hypocritical don't you think!

kestrelx · 31-03-2012, 08:58

Quote:

Originally Posted by Restless

Both of them Noel and Liam are pretentious aholes. Oasis' first album was quite good, then come a few good songs which turned out to b-sides from singles from the second album. Everything else is just bland, boring and soulless.

More annoyingly they seem to think they are on equal par to Lennon and the Beatles.

I agree with you on this - I did a search apparently U2 sold 150 Million records Oasis 50 Million. Oasis no where near as good as the Beatles or the Who or even the Stones - their songs arn't that good though they have a few good ones!

Michael1954 · 31-03-2012, 09:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by kestrelx

Your an idiot! I was asking a bonafida question! Anne said she liked Gallagher! He said he has taken drugs and is glad he did! When I said that, Anne was attacking me - bit hypocritical don't you think!

Read the posts above. Anne didn't attack you. However, you do go on about drugs a lot.

Restless · 31-03-2012, 10:22

I have often thought that It seemed that the majority of great music was written by drug users.

Well there is the proof against that

Beatles were high on drugs-- they made great music
Oasis were high on drugs-- most of their music sucks